Live data from Hacker News

Secret Shuts Down

techcrunch.com

31–40 of 253 posts

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#31

For the curious, pulled their deal history from PitchBook: Secret raised their B last July at a post valuation just over 130M ( http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png ). They had some major investors backing them up, and then the hype train just... stopped. I remember so many people being so high on it when it launched, with several friends all raving about how fun/addicting it was, then just poof it disappeared from convers…

Noobie question: what happens with the off the table cash?

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#32

Here's the official Medium post by the cofounder, in which there is confirmation that they are returning the money to investors: https://medium.com/secret-den/sunset-bc18450478d5 The post also includes the phrase "incredible journey" verbatim.

Was that a reference to this tumblr: http://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ Pretty appropriate.

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#33
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Totally makes sense - but I also completely get why the investors would bite on hype - missing the next billion dollar company is way worse than incorrectly picking a few duds.

A $35m dud, though. That's not small fry.

True, but there are 27 investors on that table, not too bad spread out

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#34

For the curious, pulled their deal history from PitchBook: Secret raised their B last July at a post valuation just over 130M ( http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png ). They had some major investors backing them up, and then the hype train just... stopped. I remember so many people being so high on it when it launched, with several friends all raving about how fun/addicting it was, then just poof it disappeared from convers…

>http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png

Here was the intended use of the $25M: "The funding will be used to implement two new features, a Facebook login and the ability to follow posts on a certain topic". This is what is wrong with Silicon Valley today. An afternoon project for a single developer gets $25M from investors. Please, someone give me just $10M....I've already implemented Facebook login for my apps.

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#35
"Secret will hand its remaining cash back to investors"

Minus the $6M the founders took off the table?

If they keep it.. if ever there were a case for blacklisting founders, this is it.

It is definitely NOT cool to pull a move like that. You want to cash out early a little because you've been boostrapping, ok, but if you then bail on the company and shut it down within a year, then you start to look like a fraud who knew the company was in trouble and took advantage of investors.

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#38
I thought secret was a really, really cool idea. I downloaded the app and played with it for a few days. After the hype died down, the app was almost 100% about sexual fantasies, coming out of the closet, and having been beaten/molested as a child.

I can't be sure, but it seemed to me that the "upvote/like" mechanism boosting posts to the top (with no validity required) turned Secret into an enormous, "Who can say the most absurd clickbait thing" contest. It got tiring, and I deleted the app.

Having talked with a few other people about Secret, they said the same thing.

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#39

For the curious, pulled their deal history from PitchBook: Secret raised their B last July at a post valuation just over 130M ( http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png ). They had some major investors backing them up, and then the hype train just... stopped. I remember so many people being so high on it when it launched, with several friends all raving about how fun/addicting it was, then just poof it disappeared from convers…

> http://i.imgur.com/jNXw5PZ.png Here was the intended use of the $25M: "The funding will be used to implement two new features, a Facebook login and the ability to follow posts on a certain topic" . This is what is wrong with Silicon Valley today. An afternoon project for a single developer gets $25M from investors. Please, someone give me just $10M....I've already implemented Facebook login for my apps.

That's hilarious! In Web 1.0, people raised $7 million to buy a domain name. Needing $12.5 million to implement a Facebook login ($25/2 projects) is even more ridiculous.

Re: Secret Shuts Down

#40
post #35

"Secret will hand its remaining cash back to investors" Minus the $6M the founders took off the table? If they keep it.. if ever there were a case for blacklisting founders, this is it. It is definitely NOT cool to pull a move like that. You want to cash out early a little because you've been boostrapping, ok, but if you then bail on the company and shut it down within a year, then you start to look like a fraud who…

The whole point of taking money off the table is to keep it when the company goes bust. What you're describing is more similar to a loan where the collateral would be a slice of equity.
Post reply on HN