Live data from Hacker News

Old New Jersey Factory to House Earth’s Largest Vertical Farm

weburbanist.com

11–15 of 15 posts

Re: Old New Jersey Factory to House Earth’s Largest Vertical Farm

#11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There was an article I read a little while ago about urban/vertical farming in Detroit. It was saying that traditionally, like you say the economics of cost of transport vs cost of land has meant that farms are placed further out where land is cheaper. In Detroit, apparently the land in inexpensive enough in the inner city that the economics dont work out that way. I think its interesting to think in a macro scale wh…

I wonder how much marijuana is grown indoors in the US? Perhaps there are some parallels not so much with cost of land but cost of transport with that one.

The cost of discovery is what drives marijuana plantations indoors.

Re: Old New Jersey Factory to House Earth’s Largest Vertical Farm

#12
post #4

There's a well-known vertical farm in Japan which produces 10,000 heads of lettuce a day. But even with LED lighting, they need subsidies on power costs. There are some special situations where this is a big win. Places with poor growing climates and difficult shipping, such as Alaska, where a big indoor farm is starting up. Indoor farms have been big in Saudi Arabia for decades. But for places within trucking range…

There was an article I read a little while ago about urban/vertical farming in Detroit. It was saying that traditionally, like you say the economics of cost of transport vs cost of land has meant that farms are placed further out where land is cheaper. In Detroit, apparently the land in inexpensive enough in the inner city that the economics dont work out that way. I think its interesting to think in a macro scale wh…

Not only that but there's a steam heating district in Detroit. I've wondered why cheap heat and cheap land hasn't resulted in green houses.

http://www.detroitthermal.com/company/service_area.aspx

There's even a large farm market where you could sell what you grow.

http://www.easternmarket.com/

Re: Old New Jersey Factory to House Earth’s Largest Vertical Farm

#13
post #4

There's a well-known vertical farm in Japan which produces 10,000 heads of lettuce a day. But even with LED lighting, they need subsidies on power costs. There are some special situations where this is a big win. Places with poor growing climates and difficult shipping, such as Alaska, where a big indoor farm is starting up. Indoor farms have been big in Saudi Arabia for decades. But for places within trucking range…

Farmers needing subsidies isnt a problem unique to vertical farming, though.

Re: Old New Jersey Factory to House Earth’s Largest Vertical Farm

#14
post #5

I just finished the book "abundance" by Stephen H. Diamandis and Steven Kotler. They discuss Vertical Farms at length, and many other future technologies that show immense promise at revolutionizing the world. Great Read. Highly Recommend.

Agreed, it was a really motivating read. I enjoyed the optimistic (and not too preachy) outlook he has regarding technology just on the horizon, especially in medicine/biotech.

Re: Old New Jersey Factory to House Earth’s Largest Vertical Farm

#15
post #4

There's a well-known vertical farm in Japan which produces 10,000 heads of lettuce a day. But even with LED lighting, they need subsidies on power costs. There are some special situations where this is a big win. Places with poor growing climates and difficult shipping, such as Alaska, where a big indoor farm is starting up. Indoor farms have been big in Saudi Arabia for decades. But for places within trucking range…

I'd have to believe that 30 years out, indoor farming will be far more cost effective than outdoor farming for certain crops. Some of California's vast farming industry should move indoors via solar and battery storage. With the way that costs in both of those segments will drastically fall over the coming decades, mixed with California's sun and large local market, it would seem ideal. Not to mention California's de…

Lettuce can be overclocked. It needs a day/night cycle, but that cycle can be shorter than 24 hours. The farm in Japan does that.
Post reply on HN