Live data from Hacker News

Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

blog.whatsapp.com

61–70 of 86 posts

Re: Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

#61
post #38

WhatsApp isn't about putting ads into the app but for better data collection. That is why Facebook bought them. Facebook sells ads and targeting data and one of the best ways to analyse a persons life to better target them for ads is from their personal, non-public communication. You will talk about many more things in private conversation with friends and family than you will publicly on your Facebook profile. A sim…

Except, as far as I know, Facebook/WhatsApp shouldn't be able to read the messages people send each other over the WhatsApp network because of end-to-end encryption: https://whispersystems.org/blog/whatsapp/

True, but this doesn't stop them from cataloguing who I'm talking to. That data can be very valuable with facebook's model.

Re: Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

#63
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They say the network communication is encrypted between end points but they don't say analysing is not being done prior to encryption on your end . What I mean is it is possible for the communication over the network to be encrypted between Bob and Alice but everything Bob writes to Alice could easily be used by WhatsApp/Facebook prior to being sent. They could even go as far as to encrypt it and just transmit your s…

Whatsapp is encrypted in transit. It is still stored on their servers. So they can read your messages. Edit: Link -- https://www.eff.org/secure-messaging-scorecard

If it was stored on their server I would assume I would be able to get my old messages when I change phone but it didn't happen last time I did, plus they could have implemented web also for iOS without relying on your phone to show messages in the browser (through more permissive android functionality), no?

Re: Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

#64
post #38

WhatsApp isn't about putting ads into the app but for better data collection. That is why Facebook bought them. Facebook sells ads and targeting data and one of the best ways to analyse a persons life to better target them for ads is from their personal, non-public communication. You will talk about many more things in private conversation with friends and family than you will publicly on your Facebook profile. A sim…

Except, as far as I know, Facebook/WhatsApp shouldn't be able to read the messages people send each other over the WhatsApp network because of end-to-end encryption: https://whispersystems.org/blog/whatsapp/

See http://blog.nadim.computer/post/114970275623/on-the-secure-m... and http://blog.nadim.computer/post/115940264683/how-whatsapp-ne... about the end-to-end encryption in WhatsApp.

Re: Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

#67
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They say the network communication is encrypted between end points but they don't say analysing is not being done prior to encryption on your end . What I mean is it is possible for the communication over the network to be encrypted between Bob and Alice but everything Bob writes to Alice could easily be used by WhatsApp/Facebook prior to being sent. They could even go as far as to encrypt it and just transmit your s…

Whatsapp is encrypted in transit. It is still stored on their servers. So they can read your messages. Edit: Link -- https://www.eff.org/secure-messaging-scorecard

They claim end-to-end encryption, which means they don't store it unencrypted.

From a wired article about it:

"Textsecure has actually already been quietly encrypting Whatsapp messages between Android devices for a week. The new encryption scheme means Whatsapp messages will now travel all the way to the recipients? device before being decrypted, rather than merely being encrypted between the user?s device and Whatsapp?s server."

Re: Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

#68
post #58
post #38

WhatsApp isn't about putting ads into the app but for better data collection. That is why Facebook bought them. Facebook sells ads and targeting data and one of the best ways to analyse a persons life to better target them for ads is from their personal, non-public communication. You will talk about many more things in private conversation with friends and family than you will publicly on your Facebook profile. A sim…

That could explain why I've been getting oddly accurate (highly targeted) ads on FB related to the niche of a new app I'm developing. I haven't liked similar stuff on FB and I was wondering how in the world FB knows that info (I have talked about it extensively via whatsapp). So there are only 2 options: 1- They somewhat are able to read my browser history even when I have ABP with "Fanboy's Social Blocking List" and…

How would they link your whatsapp account to your facebook account? Whatsapp only knows my phone number and what phone numbers I contact, and my facebook account doesn't know my whatsapp phone number.

Re: Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can do end-to-end encryption just like with emails. Just the metadata (sender, recipient) needs to be plaintext.

Ahh, i think i get it. but that brings us back to my question; how is the data store on the server, Encrypted or plaintext? if its encrypted would that mean decryption happens per each session. e.g. when using whatsapp web ( could it be why they need the phone to be online? )

They seem to use a public key method.

How I would do it was by distributing keys to devices at login and let friends use a users public key to encrypt messages to him.

Now you pack that encrypted message in a metadata envelope, send to server to be later retrieved by the owner.

The keys should never leave the device.

Re: Why we don't sell ads – WhatsApp Blog

#70
post #7

> creates app that leeches your contact list and spam people to o install the app in your name > post about hating advertising you can cut the irony/hypocrisy with a knife. what's next? a post about how he loves client interoperability? heh.

Unfortunately every non-closed IM system to date has been inundated with spammers and become practically useless.
Post reply on HN