Live data from Hacker News

Chord progressions of 25,000 songs

amitkohli.com

111–113 of 113 posts

Re: Chord progressions of 25,000 songs

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't mean to be rude, but I'm not sure you understand the comma. It has nothing to do with combining types of instruments. It's a problem that exists even with a single instrument. The problem is that, even on a single instrument (say a piano), if you start on some note (say C0), going up seven octaves should land you on exactly the same note as going up twelve perfect fifths (C7). The problem is that the precise…

I understand that pianos have to pick a frequency for each key. I wonder if there is any effort in electronic instruments to produce "better" frequencies on the fly? I'll explain: On a piano hitting C+G plays something close to a perfect fifth. An electronic instrument could move the G slightly to produce a perfect fifth when that key combination is played.

It's not just a matter of 'better' frequencies. It's trivial to have a softsynth or something similar set up to use just intonation (and many modern composers have experimented with this), but that has practical problems of it's own. Problems which were the very reason that equal temperement took over in the first place. This page has some wonderful examples http://www.nesssoftware.com/home/asn/homepage/teaching/exp-l...

Re: Chord progressions of 25,000 songs

#112
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just remove the frets, problem solved.

Fretless is difficult to play accurately, especially for chords. Also, you get a louder sound from frets because your fingers aren't muting the strings quite so much.

Of course, but it does solve all such intonation problems.

Re: Chord progressions of 25,000 songs

#113
> ... how will humanity ever learn to be creative if everyone keeps doing the same thing over and over

this charted for the yearly top 100 selling songs over the last ~80 years would clearly show the dumbing down of popular music. The Standard Songbook contains music that everyday people sang and danced to, but has a creative variety of chord progressions.

Post reply on HN