Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 60 posts

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#51
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah there's a weird internal thing where Amazon employees are not supposed to publicly contribute to open source projects but I don't know the reasoning behind that...

Former Amazonian here. When I was employed: To do ANY FOSS work as an individual unrelated to the company (And I mean ANY: private projects that may be on Github, projects with nothing to do with Amazon) required a one-off application for permission. To actually contribute something to some FOSS project that is in use at Amazon (For example, to fix a bug) requires even more special permissions (I think it is once per…

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#52
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah there's a weird internal thing where Amazon employees are not supposed to publicly contribute to open source projects but I don't know the reasoning behind that...

Former Amazonian here. When I was employed: To do ANY FOSS work as an individual unrelated to the company (And I mean ANY: private projects that may be on Github, projects with nothing to do with Amazon) required a one-off application for permission. To actually contribute something to some FOSS project that is in use at Amazon (For example, to fix a bug) requires even more special permissions (I think it is once per…

As an Amazonian, I was shocked one day by telling my colleagues about some javascript widget I am working on and a plan to open source it, I got warned that pretty much everything that developed on my laptop belongs to the company, thus I need my manager's permission to open source something that is not pretty much not related to anything in do in my fulltime job....

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#53
post #38
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, but that doesn't really answer the question. His site also has a lot of information on Apple, Google, and Microsoft, but none of it is about their considerable open source contributions.

Apple's considerable open source contributions?

WebKit and clang, for example. For WebKit, they started with a fork of KHTMP, which is under LGPL, and some have tried to say that this means it does not count since they were forced to open source it, but that is not correct. They were only required to open source a subset of it. They could have made the rest closed. Instead, they opened it all.

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Former Amazonian here. When I was employed: To do ANY FOSS work as an individual unrelated to the company (And I mean ANY: private projects that may be on Github, projects with nothing to do with Amazon) required a one-off application for permission. To actually contribute something to some FOSS project that is in use at Amazon (For example, to fix a bug) requires even more special permissions (I think it is once per…

I'm a prolific open source contributor, and I found it strange when Amazon tried to recruit me. Let me get this straight: you're scouting me because of all this open source stuff which you will now insist I abandon.

You don't have to abandon. You just have to check your ego and contribute anonymously, with full corporate backing.

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#55
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah there's a weird internal thing where Amazon employees are not supposed to publicly contribute to open source projects but I don't know the reasoning behind that...

Another former employee here. When our company was acquired, all of the engineers were given these guidelines immediately (signing/agreeing was a non-negotiable precondition of keeping your job). It was essentially a blanket ban on any programming outside of work. No open source contributions, game development, or work on any software used in current (or future!) Amazon markets. The language was such that even learni…

No. An analysis of contribution patterns would signal to GCE, Azure, etc., what they're up to, in advance. Not a good strategy.

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm a prolific open source contributor, and I found it strange when Amazon tried to recruit me. Let me get this straight: you're scouting me because of all this open source stuff which you will now insist I abandon.

You don't have to abandon. You just have to check your ego and contribute anonymously, with full corporate backing.

This is bad advice and creates a liability for the project. Many large FOSS projects require you to identify yourself and sign a committer's agreement.

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm a prolific open source contributor, and I found it strange when Amazon tried to recruit me. Let me get this straight: you're scouting me because of all this open source stuff which you will now insist I abandon.

You don't have to abandon. You just have to check your ego and contribute anonymously, with full corporate backing.

I would rather work for a company that appreciates the value of my open source involvement and encourages me to develop it further.

Re: Ask HN: How much does Amazon contribute to the open source community?

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stallman does use a web browser, just locally. His workflow is that he works offline, but when he runs across mentions of webpages that he might find useful, he queues them up to be wgetted via a proxy, then later points his browser at them. So it doesn't seem too ironic to me that he might put up web pages that others can retrieve (and indeed he's been doing so since the early days of the web). If he had some kind o…

I never knew he did this, I sometimes do the same with websites I enjoy so I can have archived backups.

If you're using Firefox, try ScrapBook. Very useful addon to save and organize websites.
Post reply on HN