Live data from Hacker News

Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

linkedin.com

21–30 of 44 posts

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#21
post #4
post #3

That's a common criticism of google; that everyone there is so educated and qualified, you have PHD comp sci people writing unit tests.

Would that be so bad?

Wow look at the downvotes.

I guess I'm assuming that said PhD isn't doing nothing but unit tests all data, but rather writing unit tests for their code.

Good unit tests are hard, often harder than product code. Smarts and experience help.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#22
post #15

TIL that even students from top CS program have no idea about taxes if they think that housing stipend is taxed higher than ordinary income. He is not alone though - compensation director at Box tried to convince me that higher salary is significantly better than lower salary + bonus because of higher taxes on bonus.

There is some truth to this actually. Companies often charge both sides of payroll tax on bonuses, which adds another ~6%. IIRC some states have a bonus tax as well.

That said, higher base salary is usually better than lower salary + bonus because your annual raises are larger on a higher base. Variable comp also just kind of sucks period - you get a big windfall at some point in the year, but you can't plan for it because you don't know how big it will be.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#23
post #8

According to one recent grad. Why is this even an article?

I can say from my interactions with CS students at top schools that this attitude is common. Google is no longer seen as innovative; everyone wants to work for Facebook or Apple now. Google isn't seen as a bad company to work for, just not sexy like it used to be. It's like going to work for Microsoft: you'll make good money and get some interesting projects, but major engineering decisions happen in an ivory tower and you just have to roll with the punches.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#24
post #2

"For full time specifically, you get equity at a startup. If it IPOs, you make millions if you're one of the first 100-1000 employees." Not really. You can make millions if you're a founder... As a regular employee you have more chances to make millions by going to Vegas than with stock options.

In my experience the first 1K employees at companies prior to going public have a much higher chance of becoming millionaires as a result of their equity holdings in the company. I'll see if I can find a better source.

How many companies have you experienced?

For 1K employees each becoming millionaires, their holdings in the company would need to be worth at least $1B, and if the IPO is 50% of the company, that means the company must be worth at least $2B. That's not a whole lot of companies, and I'm being deliberately conservative in my numbers to give you the benefit of the doubt.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#25
The writer of this article has a pretty faulty premise: it's all about the money. After close to a decade of working as an employee in startups, some that failed and some that succeeded, my view is that the last thing you want to do is join a startup for the money. You join (and more importantly, stay) because of the other benefits: the independence, the impact, and the camaraderie. Unless you're working on the next unicorn - and realistically, you're not - you're not going to come out with much cash. Google and Facebook are exceptions, not the rule.

I eventually left the startup space to see what the rest of the world is like, and I can tell you that the money is much better out here.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#26
When I got out of school 4 years ago, people were already making the same arguments. While Google isn't perfect, I can't imagine a place I'd rather work, where I can really dig into technical details of things while having freedom to set my agenda in many ways, very smart coworkers and predictably high compensation. I don't think any of those things have changed in 4 years.

Talking about top CS schools/going to Stanford is really irrelevant. I went to Carleton College, which has a nice little CS department but not really well-known, and got a liberal arts education. Because I did some open-source work and maybe because of some academic projects, I was able to get lots of interviews and offers, all in the same range as people are discussing today. All Stanford does at a company like Google is get your foot in the door--small, poorly run startups may hire on that basis, but that's it.

My one piece of advice for people who want to get into the tech industry: Choose one open-source project and contribute to it over a long period of time (ideally starting in high school, but never too late). The short time span of college courses and lack of large projects (a semester is not long) means that you can't really develop the skills that you need to be effective by that alone. Large, open-source projects give you real experience in structuring code to be maintainable, working with others and receiving feedback, and understanding and changing existing code that other people wrote. It might also get you some nice internal references.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#27
post #22
post #15

TIL that even students from top CS program have no idea about taxes if they think that housing stipend is taxed higher than ordinary income. He is not alone though - compensation director at Box tried to convince me that higher salary is significantly better than lower salary + bonus because of higher taxes on bonus.

There is some truth to this actually. Companies often charge both sides of payroll tax on bonuses, which adds another ~6%. IIRC some states have a bonus tax as well. That said, higher base salary is usually better than lower salary + bonus because your annual raises are larger on a higher base. Variable comp also just kind of sucks period - you get a big windfall at some point in the year, but you can't plan for it b…

6% is nothing compared to the raises or stocks or other random bonuses that come with working for a big tech company for a while and doing well. It seems really short-sighted to compare details about initial offers at such a minute level. Plus, Google offers other nice ways of evading taxes, like a good 401k plan.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#28
post #23
post #8

According to one recent grad. Why is this even an article?

I can say from my interactions with CS students at top schools that this attitude is common. Google is no longer seen as innovative; everyone wants to work for Facebook or Apple now. Google isn't seen as a bad company to work for, just not sexy like it used to be. It's like going to work for Microsoft: you'll make good money and get some interesting projects, but major engineering decisions happen in an ivory tower a…

... it seems to me like all that would be true for Apple and Facebook as well?

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#29
post #28
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can say from my interactions with CS students at top schools that this attitude is common. Google is no longer seen as innovative; everyone wants to work for Facebook or Apple now. Google isn't seen as a bad company to work for, just not sexy like it used to be. It's like going to work for Microsoft: you'll make good money and get some interesting projects, but major engineering decisions happen in an ivory tower a…

... it seems to me like all that would be true for Apple and Facebook as well?

Yeah, these are 21-year-old kids. But Facebook is still in heavy growth mode, and their options packages for engineers are no joke. Facebook also has enough money and talent that they will build a few more blockbuster products before they're done. Apple is seen as desirable because their core product engineering teams are treated like royalty and they don't hire very many people, so it's seen as a badge of honor if you can get hired.

Re: Google Is Now a 'Tier Two' Employer, Says Recent Comp-Sci Grad

#30
post #2

"For full time specifically, you get equity at a startup. If it IPOs, you make millions if you're one of the first 100-1000 employees." Not really. You can make millions if you're a founder... As a regular employee you have more chances to make millions by going to Vegas than with stock options.

Amen. I made enough for the down on my house - and I was the 2nd FTE hired.
Post reply on HN