Live data from Hacker News

LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network

interactually.com

71–80 of 93 posts

Re: LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network

#71
post #58

It may be the creepiest social network, but it is also the only network where I can be endorsed for skills I've forgotten I had by people I've forgotten I worked with.

I frequently get endorsed for 'social media.' Not entirely sure why, and not legitimate skills I may have.

Re: LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network

#73
post #28

Other users who have imported their contact list is probably what causes them to show up on "People You May Know". I have noticed that people who I'm suggested to add are ones that I have only communicated with through email.

This is the most obvious explanation. It compares your email to the list of contacts that other people have imported. If you were on their list, you may 'know' them. Pretty simple.

Not necessarily. I've had recommendations from people I've never exchanged emails or phone numbers with and our only "connection" has been through Facebook or Twitter. They'd have no reason or way to have me in their contacts list. As the article describes, they've even recommended people who just happen to share the same name as someone I DO know, but otherwise have not the slightest connection in the world with.

Re: LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network

#75
post #21

> I don’t currently and haven’t previously used the Imported Contact feature But perhaps the others did? If 'Steve Jacobs' imported his contacts and you exchanged emails with him, LinkedIn apparently becomes aware of that relationship. In fact: > Tami has a total of 5 connections, lives in Seattle, no public company or title listed, but we just happened to exchange a few emails a couple days prior regarding some ques…

Author here: You're probably right on that particular example. Unfortunately there's still a number of others that have no other explanation other than undisclosed relationships with other sites. Just the other day, I had two requests to connect from people I'm only friends with on FB; I haven't seen either of them for over a decade so I'm definitely not in their contacts list.

Re: LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network

#78

This link is now redirecting to an odd mix of the intended link + the wp install url http://www.interactually.com/linkedin-creepiest-social-netwo...

Sorry about that; my web host sucks and this happens whenever this post blows up. The problem should be resolved now.

Re: LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network

#79
post #25

I had an interesting experience last year when I was working in a co-working space. I noticed that LinkedIn started suggesting to me the other people who were working in the same space. I had no verbal or virtual contact with these people, other than basic office small talk, but I never knew their name and they never knew mine. I mentioned it to them, and they all claimed they hadn't looked me up on LinkedIn, and tha…

I had a similar experience with LinkedIn, which also suggests they are using IPs to discover people who may be connected to you. In this case, I had gone into a local coffee shop, used the free WiFi, and then when I went home and accessed LinkedIn from my desktop PC it suggested several of the employees of that coffee shop as possible connections.

I thought that was actually pretty scary - normally, if you're a service employee at a business, the most a customer is going to learn about you is the name printed on your name tag. In this case, after buying my coffee and going home, I was presented with the last names of these employees and whatever other information was publicly visible in their LinkedIn profiles.

Re: LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I am not going to add him but from my point of view, proposing you to add people you only know remotely diminishes the usefulness of the network. The people I know who are the best at networking (I don't count myself in that class) are able to extract a remarkable amount of value out of contacts they only barely know or just have an indirect connection to. It might not be in your nature (or mine for that matter) to…

Except the rest of us all hate those people. I guess maybe you're right that it works for them, but at the cost of real human relationships.

I don't understand what you're referring to. There are people I know who are better able to reach out to a friend of a friend when a certain question/need comes up because they're better at networking. Oftentimes at that time, more of a relationship is developed at that time. I don't see why you would hate someone like that...
Post reply on HN