Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

developers.facebook.com

41–50 of 203 posts

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#41
post #23
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Turn off chat. Nothing is forced onto you.

I never even turned it on. Since they split messenger off I can no longer read read messages on my cellphone...without installing a separate app. Functionality that worked perfectly fine previously until they decided to disable to force messenger onto people. http://techcrunch.com/2014/07/28/facebook-moving-messages/

I agree. It is terrible and I have stopped responding to messages on facebook when I'm on mobile.

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#42
post #23
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Turn off chat. Nothing is forced onto you.

I never even turned it on. Since they split messenger off I can no longer read read messages on my cellphone...without installing a separate app. Functionality that worked perfectly fine previously until they decided to disable to force messenger onto people. http://techcrunch.com/2014/07/28/facebook-moving-messages/

Can't you just open facebook.com in your phone's browser? I've been doing that for a couple of years since noticing that it's both faster and more reliable than the Facebook iOS app.

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#43
post #23
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Turn off chat. Nothing is forced onto you.

I never even turned it on. Since they split messenger off I can no longer read read messages on my cellphone...without installing a separate app. Functionality that worked perfectly fine previously until they decided to disable to force messenger onto people. http://techcrunch.com/2014/07/28/facebook-moving-messages/

What about people that only want to use chat, without having the Facebook app. Especially since you don't need a Facebook account to use messenger.

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#45

Also it is worth mentioning that Google Talk !== Google Hangouts Everyone who uses XMPP/iMessage/Adium to connect to Google Talk is: 1) Apparently missing some messages from Hangouts users. Haven't been able to track it down but it's gotten me in trouble with my girlfriend a few times for "ignoring her" 2) Your friends see you as "Online" on hangouts and send you messages, which often seem to relate to #1 (you never…

setup a ejabberd server on a beaglebone and put a web xmpp client on it. encrypt the shit out of everything, get your friends on to it. i'm sure there's valid business reasons to kill xmpp, not just total information awareness pressures from above.

i suggested this because i believe xmpp to be superior to irc.

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#46

To play devil's advocate, what part of the XMPP protocol is dated, that doesn't allow Facebook and Google to continue using it? Maybe if there's a way to update XMPP to include features that shared amongst these services, they can fall back to using it?

A big problem for me is that there's no push notification standard. This means that a mobile device needs to keep the app running and stay awake to receive messages. This kills batteries faster than you might expect.

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#47
post #37
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Directly via the graph api. Simpler than xmpp. Someone recently posted a graph api chat example.

Do we know if Adium/pidgin are likely to update to use that API, or is it too early to say?

Someone will build it. But it still just adds another proprietary API to the arsenal. Ugh.

I echo other sentiments here: what exactly is broken about XMPP that companies keep moving away?

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#48

Also it is worth mentioning that Google Talk !== Google Hangouts Everyone who uses XMPP/iMessage/Adium to connect to Google Talk is: 1) Apparently missing some messages from Hangouts users. Haven't been able to track it down but it's gotten me in trouble with my girlfriend a few times for "ignoring her" 2) Your friends see you as "Online" on hangouts and send you messages, which often seem to relate to #1 (you never…

This may not be unique to XMPP...I use regular Google Hangouts with my fiancee (also on stock Google Hangouts) and have found that occasionally messages to my fiancee get to her hours later or not at all. Apparently the Hangouts team doesn't consider "reliable message delivery" to be a key feature.

I think people don't realize just how unreliable the major messaging networks are. There was a Reddit thread a year or so ago where some folks who worked in the telecom industry said that they shoot for a 98% delivery rate with SMS, i.e. one in every 50 SMS messages will just get lost. I've personally experienced arriving at a friends' house, sending them a text to let them know I'm there, waiting 10 minutes, knocking on the door, and then 20 minutes later, while I'm in the car with them, my own text message finally arrives.

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#49

Sigh , yet another nail in the XMPP coffin, at least as far as the general public is concerned. Remember when we had ICQ, and AIM, and MSN Messenger, and Gadu-Gadu, and we were dreaming of a unified messaging system?

Now we have twice as many incompatible services. And still dreaming. :/

This is what we get when we embrace closed platforms. Free Software gets you nice, simple, easy to use services and closed platforms will always manipulate you for their needs.

This is why I want to make a Free Hardware cell phone. I have made one wireless product already and wrote the frequency hopping stack myself, but something like a phone needs better data rates and a more advanced protocol.

Still, I dream of a simple cell phone that runs vanilla linux and has apps for IRC, XMPP, and the other functions you would want. The key component would be that the protocol would be designed from the ground up to respect user privacy, including a "broadcast" mode for towers where certain low data rate data channels are streamed without requiring any transmission from the handset. Then you could follow IRC or twitter during a protest without any risk of being probed for your location.

The protocol would also be built with anonymity in mind as much as possible, so phones would route data using rolling anonymous ID numbers and spoofing location could perhaps be trivial for plausible deniability (unless that opens up a vector for DoS).

I met the "Game of Drones" guys last night and they seemed interested in my wireless. I can only do 1km at 20kbps with current boards and 10km at 20kbps with amplified boards, but I think they might be interested in a solution that would work for FPV and that could be a good excuse to develop something that would also work for a cell phone.

I am 100% Free Hardware all the way, so maybe your dreams can come true eventually. :)

Re: Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away

#50
post #29
post #13

Alternative to your desktop client. http://www.goofyapp.com/

I found out about Goofy a couple of months ago and when I'm at my desk, I don't have to use my phone at all for messaging (except for whatsapp). Now I'd wish someone would do the same for Gmail chat / Hangouts, or maybe a way to combine all the webviews into one ;)

Whatsapp has a web client.
Post reply on HN