Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Hacker news, but for ideas

idea-ne.ws

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–50 of 70 posts

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#41

Post by chrischen »

rglullis wrote: post #37
chrischen wrote: post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's always the crazy ideas that get marginalized by the majority, because chances are the majority are right. However the ideas that turn out to be great initially manifests as crazy to the majority. Rather unfortunate "adaptation" but the one way we can avoid killing potentially great things is to not discredit something until it can be proven to be bad, and to not discourage "weird" behavior.

It's not my job to filter out every idea out there and try to prove it's a bad one. It's not up to me to carry the burden of proof. Also, I don't "discourage weird behavior". I do discourage "weird behavior who relies on my acceptance of the terms", and that's what bugs me about amichail constant polls and 'ASK YC' posts. To make an analogy, I don't mind reading about people who are into body modification, even to th…

When I say "weird", I really mean anything that you may think of as stupid. The whole point is that we can't filter out every idea and prove it's a bad one, but if we don't dismiss them they can at least rise through to the top through natural selection via survival of the fittest.

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#42

Post by rglullis »

jacquesm wrote: post #39
rglullis wrote: post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd argue exactly the opposite. I want people to feel self-conscious about their own ideas. I want people to be reasonably good filters. We already live in an information overloaded world. If I started "putting my ideas" out there with no filter, I would certainly be a source of information with a terrible SNR. And please, this is not saying that I want to conform to the majority. What I want is for you to stop trans…

I really don't like this personal attack. If you don't like amichails post / comments ignore him or vote him down. Inspiration can come from the most unexpected sources and we have the vote button in order to express what we think is good stuff and what isn't. As of this writing amichail has 5x the karma that you have, and you are both members of the sites for roughly equal duration. I think I'll let that speak for i…

- It's not a personal attack. I'm trying as reasonably as I possibly can to show why I don't like this particular kind of behavior. I got into the same kind of argument when Jeff Atwood started shooting drivel at HN.

- I do ignore his posts. In almost three years of HN, this is the second time that I've tried to make my point, and it was not out of nowhere.

- Argumentum ad populum.

- As for the content: I think that a website for the discussion of ideas is where amichail will thrive. If he moves his usual posts to the new website I would have absolutely nothing to say about it. I'd probably participate, precisely because I know that is the website's purpose.

- I'd be (even) less vocal about his posts if he showed he is working on his ideas. If you read what I wrote carefully, you'll see that my criticism is not for the ideas, but rather the fact that he throws millions of them without any follow-up work. Whoever dreamed up the hula-hoop built the damn thing, he/she did not make it big by sending mail to people with "Why don't we make a object that is simple, cheap and fun? That would certainly be a successful toy."

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#43

Post by bdr »

fnid wrote: post #14
hpvic03 wrote: post #5

I love talking about ideas and was actually thinking of implementing something like this myself. You've got one user.

Great people talk about ideas. Average people talk about things. Small people talk about people. - Dave Marinaccio

How about: Wealthy businessmen talk about people. Average businessmen talk about things. Poor businessmen talk about ideas.

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#44

Post by [deleted] »

chrischen wrote: post #41
rglullis wrote: post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not my job to filter out every idea out there and try to prove it's a bad one. It's not up to me to carry the burden of proof. Also, I don't "discourage weird behavior". I do discourage "weird behavior who relies on my acceptance of the terms", and that's what bugs me about amichail constant polls and 'ASK YC' posts. To make an analogy, I don't mind reading about people who are into body modification, even to th…

When I say "weird", I really mean anything that you may think of as stupid. The whole point is that we can't filter out every idea and prove it's a bad one, but if we don't dismiss them they can at least rise through to the top through natural selection via survival of the fittest.

[deleted]

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#45

Post by bootload »

rglullis wrote: post #19
amichail wrote: post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It seems that talking about ideas -- especially your own -- is somehow taboo. Rather unfortunate.

I'm sorry. I know this is going to sound harsh, but I'll be the one saying it - again - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=182193 . Talking about ideas was never taboo. It's just that your ideas are consistently inane and not worth talking about.

"... Talking about ideas was never taboo. It's just that your ideas are consistently inane and not worth talking about. ..."

I don't think Amichail is inane. Inane is defined as "empty", "vain" or "lacking of meaning". I recognise the behaviour Amichail is displaying, "continuously asking lots of questions". As a kid I did this. I asked so many questions I distinctly remember my old man telling me to shut-up. So I did. Then had the problem of teachers asking me why I never bothered asking for help. In the real world continuously asking questions and being curious seems stupid, pointless and suppressed.

HN isn't a slice of the regular world. Tolerance of eccentric and unusual behaviour strengthens HN not weakens it. So let Amichail ask as many questions as possible, don't suppress the questioning, it's a sign of youthful curiosity.

Harnessing Amichail as a sounding board for ideas and pointing out any weakness in ideas seems more reasonable than scolding.

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#47

Post by bootload »

rglullis wrote: post #36
amichail wrote: post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You shouldn't make people feel self-conscious about putting their ideas out there. Maybe something that sounds silly at first might develop into something more interesting with some discussion. Of course, you can have mechanisms in place to give everyone a chance to express their ideas. For example, you could make people pay for submissions using karma points.

I'd argue exactly the opposite. I want people to feel self-conscious about their own ideas. I want people to be reasonably good filters. We already live in an information overloaded world. If I started "putting my ideas" out there with no filter, I would certainly be a source of information with a terrible SNR. And please, this is not saying that I want to conform to the majority. What I want is for you to stop trans…

"... What bothers me is not the fact that you want to think on problems with little practical utility. What bothers me is that you expect others to join you without showing no glimpse of a solution! ..."

I'm beginning to see a pattern here. Do you have a problem with Amichail? If you keep on repeated attacking, causing distress and others join in this is technically bullying. The beaut thing is all it takes to stop even a hint of bullying is for bystanders to stand up for the attacked.

So what's your call? Are you going to continue this vein of argument? Do you feel the need to continuously dominate others? Because bullies should not be tolerated and I'll stand up for Amichail.

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#49

Post by rglullis »

bootload wrote: post #45
rglullis wrote: post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sorry. I know this is going to sound harsh, but I'll be the one saying it - again - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=182193 . Talking about ideas was never taboo. It's just that your ideas are consistently inane and not worth talking about.

"... Talking about ideas was never taboo. It's just that your ideas are consistently inane and not worth talking about. ..." I don't think Amichail is inane. Inane is defined as "empty" , "vain" or "lacking of meaning" . I recognise the behaviour Amichail is displaying, "continuously asking lots of questions" . As a kid I did this. I asked so many questions I distinctly remember my old man telling me to shut-up. So I…

The questions that I see coming from amichail are either questions that have no real, objective answer (Are parents essentially AI researchers? Why not turn twitter into a massive brain for problem solving / brainstorming? Should games like The Sims be banned?) or questions where the best way to get an answer is to just be scientific about it and create an experiment - Would presenting less evidence for evolution convince more people? Allow PhDs to apply for expert status in various subreddits?. This is why I think they are inane. It's not about asking questions. It's about making the right ones.

-----

Whenever I'm around a child that keeps asking me questions, my standard response is "I don't know. How can we figure that out?". It usually works. If it's genuine curiosity, then they will be really excited to be able to take part in the discovery. If they were just trying to be annoying or looking for an easy answer, then they just forget about it and move on.

Re: Hacker news, but for ideas

#50

Post by jacquesm »

rglullis wrote: post #42
jacquesm wrote: post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really don't like this personal attack. If you don't like amichails post / comments ignore him or vote him down. Inspiration can come from the most unexpected sources and we have the vote button in order to express what we think is good stuff and what isn't. As of this writing amichail has 5x the karma that you have, and you are both members of the sites for roughly equal duration. I think I'll let that speak for i…

- It's not a personal attack. I'm trying as reasonably as I possibly can to show why I don't like this particular kind of behavior. I got into the same kind of argument when Jeff Atwood started shooting drivel at HN. - I do ignore his posts. In almost three years of HN, this is the second time that I've tried to make my point, and it was not out of nowhere. - Argumentum ad populum. - As for the content: I think that…

It is as personal as can be, it is in a public forum and you are specifically singling out one individual for this 'treatment' and you are effectively telling him you think this forum has no place for him.

Let me give you one simple example of why I think this kind of contribution is useful, maybe even very useful.

I've seen in practice several times that people that shoot off their wild-ass ideas for literally years on end suddenly hit one right out of the ballbpark. Having ideas is like having to paint, or blog or anything other that is creative that is a drive outside of yourself. You literally can't control it.

And if in all those ideas there is ONE golden one and it is recognized as such amichail will be the one to reap the benefits from that.

HN is a great place to get criticism for your 'stupid' ideas, and it isn't always the smart ideas that end up making you money.

If I look at my own history it is the stupid ideas that made be lots of $ and the intricate and lots of work stuff is what gave me great intellectual satisfaction but ended up losing literally buckets of money.

Give the guy a break, there is room enough for everyone here.

One of the reasons these 'niche' HNs seem to fail is simply because of the lack of volume and requiring the potential audience to monitor yet another website.

If amichail were to take his 'idea fountain' elsewhere I for one would miss him, and I would consider it a loss to all of us.

A couple of years ago I guy I knew was bugging everybody about his idea for 'foldable storage boxes'. He eventually made a cardboard model, and couldn't stop talking about it. The follow-up was dreadful, it never went anywhere. Fast forward 10 years, he's back at it, only now he's gotten this idea that maybe he can make them larger, so that trucks that drive south with flowers can use these boxes on the way there, and fold them up on the way back so they can carry payload both ways, instead of driving back with empty flower racks. Oh, and of course everybody was telling him he's nuts.

Same basic idea, took well upwards of 10 years for the coin to drop. I would not be surprised at all if amichail is like that guy. He takes a shower, comes back out and can literally fill 10 pages of his 'notebook' with ideas.

99% of them are crap, and everybody keeps telling him.

I wished I had his banking problems though...

Post reply on HN