Live data from Hacker News

MSBuild is now open source on GitHub

blogs.msdn.com

11–20 of 185 posts

Re: MSBuild is now open source on GitHub

#11

Nobody is seriously going to fork this and create their own port of MSBuild, possibly one of the most mocked and reviled parts of the .NET ecosystem. I do however congratulate the ground level MS staffers on the effort it likely took to convice the Risk and Legal departments that open sourcing something like this won't make their business fail. That must have been trying.

> Nobody is seriously going to fork this and create their own port of MSBuild, possibly one of the most mocked and reviled parts of the .NET ecosystem.

You're probably right. But it does mean there's one more part of the .NET ecosystem that potentially runs on Linux and OSX, and that's probably the reasoning behind this.

Re: MSBuild is now open source on GitHub

#14

Nobody is seriously going to fork this and create their own port of MSBuild, possibly one of the most mocked and reviled parts of the .NET ecosystem. I do however congratulate the ground level MS staffers on the effort it likely took to convice the Risk and Legal departments that open sourcing something like this won't make their business fail. That must have been trying.

While I agree, having access to the source of your build tool can be invaluable for debugging odd issues. So while no one will ever want to fork this they may use it as reference and/or for debugging.

I definitely look forward to being able to check the source for all the things with zero meaningful documentation beyond a few old blog posts and a book.

Re: MSBuild is now open source on GitHub

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I agree, having access to the source of your build tool can be invaluable for debugging odd issues. So while no one will ever want to fork this they may use it as reference and/or for debugging.

I definitely look forward to being able to check the source for all the things with zero meaningful documentation beyond a few old blog posts and a book.

Yeah, I've never written anything in .NET but I know from experience the pain of sub-par documentation. Thankfully most of the stuff that I work with is OS so I can always dig into the code if the docs are lacking. Glad that now .NET devs who use this can do the same!

Re: MSBuild is now open source on GitHub

#17
post #11

Nobody is seriously going to fork this and create their own port of MSBuild, possibly one of the most mocked and reviled parts of the .NET ecosystem. I do however congratulate the ground level MS staffers on the effort it likely took to convice the Risk and Legal departments that open sourcing something like this won't make their business fail. That must have been trying.

> Nobody is seriously going to fork this and create their own port of MSBuild, possibly one of the most mocked and reviled parts of the .NET ecosystem. You're probably right. But it does mean there's one more part of the .NET ecosystem that potentially runs on Linux and OSX, and that's probably the reasoning behind this.

The reasoning is likely that there is now an internal KPI for open sourcing code because it helps MS PR.
Post reply on HN