Live data from Hacker News

App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 60 posts

Re: App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

#12
post #7

after getting 100k active users, and over 2million sessions per week, which was 1 year after submitting my app, google play suspended my app without warning, and i lost all. they were right, i didn't accurately follow their terms, but if they reviewed my app once submitted a year ago, that could've been avoided. it was a bitter experience for me, and i decided to port my app to iOS. i heard iOS provides warnings atle…

> they were right, i didn't accurately follow their terms, but if they reviewed my app once submitted a year ago, that could've been avoided.

Couldn't they say that to you about reading the terms a year ago?

Re: App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

#14
post #7

after getting 100k active users, and over 2million sessions per week, which was 1 year after submitting my app, google play suspended my app without warning, and i lost all. they were right, i didn't accurately follow their terms, but if they reviewed my app once submitted a year ago, that could've been avoided. it was a bitter experience for me, and i decided to port my app to iOS. i heard iOS provides warnings atle…

> they were right, i didn't accurately follow their terms, but if they reviewed my app once submitted a year ago, that could've been avoided. Couldn't they say that to you about reading the terms a year ago?

that's what i'm saying. i wish they did. when they suspended my app i was being contacted by another team from google, AdMob, to "help grow my business". so i thought i was fine as long as i can make them money. they got me excited, then suddenly removed my app.

Re: App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

#15
post #7

after getting 100k active users, and over 2million sessions per week, which was 1 year after submitting my app, google play suspended my app without warning, and i lost all. they were right, i didn't accurately follow their terms, but if they reviewed my app once submitted a year ago, that could've been avoided. it was a bitter experience for me, and i decided to port my app to iOS. i heard iOS provides warnings atle…

For what reason was your app removed?

Re: App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

#17
post #5

If they want to make the appstore a better place, why not spend some time to make search work? I dunno, an eigen-vector algorithm of some sort. Copying Apples mistakes are not the way to go.

I believe the top search engine in world with 100s of search engineers have thought of an eigen-vector algorithm of some sort".

Re: App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

#18

Nice. I just hope they won't be as annoying as Apple.

Well if you've been submitting apps in the last month or so then you used this system. They say even with adding humans apps are approved in hours not days/weeks as has been known to happen with Apple. Also they use a lot of automation to reduce the number of apps and the amount of work each reviewer has to review.

From my experience (with one app published in that time frame) it's… meh. The review process is fast, granted (<1 business day), but the enforcement of rules is as arbitrary and byzantine as with Apple, with no useful appeal process.

Re: App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> they were right, i didn't accurately follow their terms, but if they reviewed my app once submitted a year ago, that could've been avoided. Couldn't they say that to you about reading the terms a year ago?

that's what i'm saying. i wish they did. when they suspended my app i was being contacted by another team from google, AdMob, to "help grow my business". so i thought i was fine as long as i can make them money. they got me excited, then suddenly removed my app.

> that's what i'm saying. i wish they did.

Their terms weren't secret a year ago. At no point have they said "None of these apply if you make us money".

Re: App Submissions On Google Play Now Reviewed By Staff, Include Age-Based Ratings

#20
post #7

after getting 100k active users, and over 2million sessions per week, which was 1 year after submitting my app, google play suspended my app without warning, and i lost all. they were right, i didn't accurately follow their terms, but if they reviewed my app once submitted a year ago, that could've been avoided. it was a bitter experience for me, and i decided to port my app to iOS. i heard iOS provides warnings atle…

For what reason was your app removed?

infringement. my app was called Nexus Photos. before submitting i read that google was denied the trademark on the name nexus. i also sent an email before publishing the app to google play, and they said it's ok to use the word "Nexus" in the title. i provided this info in my appeal. but the appeal was refused. as i said, they were right, but removing the app with no warning was brutal.
Post reply on HN