Live data from Hacker News

How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

wired.com

21–30 of 90 posts

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#21
post #13

Legitimate question. Do you think GitHub would accept a lucrative offer from Google? On the order of billions of dollars. How would that look? Where would we all be then? How much would it change things? Is it even realistic?

Google sells ads. Something like 98% of their revenue is ads. I seriously think they are at this point becoming allergic to any sort of for-pay business model.

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#22

I think one of the underappreciated point of github is its excellent business model. The freemium model of providing everything for free if your code is public and charging only for private repositories allowed them to grow exponentially with rising popularity among open source projects. Sourceforge and Google code tried to cater only for open source projects, while never thinking that code hosting is the problem tha…

IMO, Google's problem is that many enterprise customers believe they need on-premise, and realistically, Google cannot deliver on-premise solutions of systems designed to work on their Google scale platforms.

I mean, that google search appliance seems like a reverse engineering / wikileaks dream. 'Here's a box accesses internal customer documents, and nobody knows how to upgrade'.

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#23
post #13

Legitimate question. Do you think GitHub would accept a lucrative offer from Google? On the order of billions of dollars. How would that look? Where would we all be then? How much would it change things? Is it even realistic?

Google sells ads. Something like 98% of their revenue is ads. I seriously think they are at this point becoming allergic to any sort of for-pay business model.

Just as a little correction, Google makes 6% of its revenue throgh Youtube, so saying 98% is from ads is wrong. Link: http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/permalink/2015/02/27/10-year...

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#24
For a matter of completeness, this[1] is an article worth the six minutes it takes to read it.

[...]Bruce Sterling calls them “the Stacks”: Amazon, Apple, Facebook, Google, Microsoft, [GitHub].

[...]

They don’t want much, those Stacks. Just your identity, your allegiance, and all of your data. Just to be your sole provider of messaging, media, merchandise, and metadata. Just to take part in as much of your online existence as they possibly can, and maybe to one day mediate your every interaction with the world around you, online or off.

[...]

It’s very convenient to live in a Stack. It’s easy, it’s seamless, it’s comfortable. And it means putting much, or very nearly all, of our increasingly important online existences into the hands of a few titanic megacorporations. It means relying on their benevolence, not just today, but for the foreseeable future.

[1] http://techcrunch.com/2013/08/18/the-internet-were-doing-it-...

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google sells ads. Something like 98% of their revenue is ads. I seriously think they are at this point becoming allergic to any sort of for-pay business model.

Just as a little correction, Google makes 6% of its revenue throgh Youtube, so saying 98% is from ads is wrong. Link: http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/permalink/2015/02/27/10-year...

> Google makes 6% of its revenue throgh Youtube, so saying 98% is from ads is wrong.

Doesn't Google make money on Youtube by showing ads?

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google sells ads. Something like 98% of their revenue is ads. I seriously think they are at this point becoming allergic to any sort of for-pay business model.

Just as a little correction, Google makes 6% of its revenue throgh Youtube, so saying 98% is from ads is wrong. Link: http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/permalink/2015/02/27/10-year...

well, afaik, youtube makes 100% of its money from ads

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#27
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can I email you some information on why a large company I interned at mentioned they didn't use Github (they were adopting Atlassian)? I'd rather not post here but happy to share.

Please do! Shoot me an email at pauln@github.com; the feedback would be very appreciated.

I just wanted to say I love the blog posts on the enterprise portion of the site. Each release's page is an awesome snapshot of what you guys were focused on for that release and everything, right down to the screen shots, is beautiful.

Even a simple image like: https://enterprise.github.com/assets/releases/2.1.0/screensh... looks beautiful and makes me want to use GitHub Enterprise even though I don't have any good use for it outside of work :). Keep up the good work!

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google sells ads. Something like 98% of their revenue is ads. I seriously think they are at this point becoming allergic to any sort of for-pay business model.

Just as a little correction, Google makes 6% of its revenue throgh Youtube, so saying 98% is from ads is wrong. Link: http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/permalink/2015/02/27/10-year...

Google has ad revenue sources that are not Youtube. Like you said, Youtube represents only a small part of its revenue stream, but this doesn't mean its revenue stream is not dominated by selling ads.

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#29
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just as a little correction, Google makes 6% of its revenue throgh Youtube, so saying 98% is from ads is wrong. Link: http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/permalink/2015/02/27/10-year...

well, afaik, youtube makes 100% of its money from ads

Not that it really matters, but they do rent movies

https://www.youtube.com/user/movies

Re: How GitHub Conquered Google, Microsoft, and Everyone Else

#30

I think one of the underappreciated point of github is its excellent business model. The freemium model of providing everything for free if your code is public and charging only for private repositories allowed them to grow exponentially with rising popularity among open source projects. Sourceforge and Google code tried to cater only for open source projects, while never thinking that code hosting is the problem tha…

I wish Sourceforge would have come to that realization.

Anytime I search for something that tends to be older enterprisy-ish code and it shows up in Sourceforge (iText for example) I can never figure out what the hell is and isn't an ad. If I didn't know better I would suspect a malware vendor purchased it and turned it into a honeypot for lazy devs.

Post reply on HN