Live data from Hacker News

Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 28 posts

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#11
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes indeed. $3.99 can get you a book at a used bookstore. But you might not be able to find the one you want immediately. Used bookstores are for explorers, not buyers. Besides, $3.99 isn't enough for a popular title or a hardcover. However you can get them through swapping with a flat fee. -- We'll focus on one thing and make it work. In our case it's book swapping. If our service is good then we'll have users. I do…

Are you paying shipping or is it $3.99 + shipping?

It's $3.99 total, including shipping.

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#13
One question and an observation.

Q: if this is a "swap", who pays the 4 bucks? Both parties?

O1: I think you are onto something here. But it is probably not this exact idea. If your proposition is "cheap + used + as fast as Amazon"... why not just use Amazon? People with books valued over 4 bucks lose out; better to sell it.

O2: You have been working on this full-time for 6 months, and have 3 months more to go? That is an unhealthy amount of time to do something like this without user feedback.

I am tempted to invest, but I think that's more to do with the low minimum than my excitement. The most innovative and clever thing is the funding method, not the business.

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#14
You expect people to donate to a profit seeking venture? That is insane.

I think you would have better luck asking for investors of >= 1000 and giving them equity.

edit: Nevermind. I just read one of the co-founders is a business-dev guy with a "big idea" and I just vomited in my mouth.

edit edit: Why do you keep telling us you are Taiwanese? Note Paul Graham never tells us he is English.

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#15
post #13

One question and an observation. Q: if this is a "swap", who pays the 4 bucks? Both parties? O1: I think you are onto something here. But it is probably not this exact idea. If your proposition is "cheap + used + as fast as Amazon"... why not just use Amazon? People with books valued over 4 bucks lose out; better to sell it. O2: You have been working on this full-time for 6 months, and have 3 months more to go? That…

yea the video was very well put together, but not once did you address the very important nuts and bolts as to what exactly mean with the $3.99 swap.

do both parties mail their books at the same time? why the $4 fee? what does that money buy? to me, this looks like you could get leapfrogged by a facebook app, which says a lot.

also, is this $10 an investment or a donation? do we get any equity for purchasing?

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#16
post #6
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What happened then? Some thing went wrong?

It was impossible to do it in a way I was sure was legal without any legal budget. If it wasn't for that, I think it would be a great way to raise money.

Because it's not legal in just about any way you try and do it.

I'm no lawyer but companies are always trying to do this, and some get smacked down by the FTC.

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#17
I'd also recommend you do some contracting work if you can swing it.

I recently left a full-time position and now devote 50% of my time to contracting, making 2x as much per hour.

Net result: I have 50% more free time and make roughly the same amount.

There could be dry spots if the economy / web bubble slips, but for the most part demand seems to be exceeding my capacity so far. ($4k contract for 50 hours of my time this month, for example)

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#18
$5000 isn't worth the risk of using 500 non-accredited investors. If you really believe in your company my advice is to put some real sweat equity into your business and a. get a part time job, restaurant servers get good tips b. take out a credit card c. liquidate everything you can to afford it d. or a combination of all three

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#19
1. How do you compare with all the other book swapping sites out there?

2. You financials seem to indicate that by 2010 you'll have revenue of $70k is that correct?

3. Why would I pay to swap a book? It seems to me that in swapping a book I'm already giving something and getting something of 'equal' value; what makes you think people will pay for this service?

Re: Fundraising from... you - Need $5,000 from 500 people, each giving us $10.

#20
Talk to a lawyer first!

IANAL, but IIRC, once you have more than a certain number of investors, you are effectively a public company (and will be forever the bitch of the demon-prince SarbOx!)

Make sure your competent legal representation gives you the go-ahead before doing this...

Post reply on HN