Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 164 posts

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#61
Forget all the people who say "the solution already exists" plenty of people have built successful businesses by building a solution that already existed.

I did have a hard time figuring out what your app is. Work on the copy and you might see a better response.

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#63

I'll come out with a contrarian point of view: I think you're wasting your time and certainly your money. To have invested your life savings into this app which, uh, is really hard to determine what it does seems silly to me - especially since you have a family to care for. Slack Meets GitHub Issues? Doesn't Slack already meet GitHub issues in that it integrates with GitHub fine? The fact that you need a very long bl…

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#64

I like the idea of "chat is your to-do list, and your to-list is your chat", but you're website doesn't communicate this, I had to try it out to really get what the product was about. It's annoying that I can't delete the first loops from Loopy. I also think the app needs an easier way to navigate between loops, rather than relying on the back button. I think the user list is not very privacy focussed, I remove it fo…

"chat is your to-do list, and your to-list is your chat"

OP, I think this phrase, or something like it, should be front and center of your communication effort. IMO it describes your product better than all the stuff I've read in ~5min on your sites.

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#65
post #51

You could have validated this idea (for next to nothing, I might add) before quitting your job and investing all of your savings. There's a lot of good reading out there around how to do what you've tried to do here in a safe and sensible way that doesn't waste time and your own hard earned money, but you seem to have ignored all of that. I suggest you purchase a copy of http://theleanstartup.com/ I genuinely wish yo…

I already have the leanstartup and I have read many, many books on the subject, but I didn't do all this just to start a business. Of course, I want it to become successful, but this project means more to me than that, so I didn't need validation before starting on the journey. In a way, I was scratching my own itch. This is something I will use on a daily basis, and if that's as successful as it will ever be, then it was still worth it.

Seriously, I apologise if I make out in my post that this has been the worst time of my life! It wasn't the intention. For the most part it's been an amazing ride, and I had enough funds to be relatively comfortable while doing it (once I got used to the adjustments).

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#66

I'll come out with a contrarian point of view: I think you're wasting your time and certainly your money. To have invested your life savings into this app which, uh, is really hard to determine what it does seems silly to me - especially since you have a family to care for. Slack Meets GitHub Issues? Doesn't Slack already meet GitHub issues in that it integrates with GitHub fine? The fact that you need a very long bl…

#middlebrow_dismissal

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#67
post #63

I'll come out with a contrarian point of view: I think you're wasting your time and certainly your money. To have invested your life savings into this app which, uh, is really hard to determine what it does seems silly to me - especially since you have a family to care for. Slack Meets GitHub Issues? Doesn't Slack already meet GitHub issues in that it integrates with GitHub fine? The fact that you need a very long bl…

[deleted]

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#68
post #13

Unfiltered First impressions: Your medium article is 50X better than your website. Your website is useless for promoting your product. I don't like the headline font for your site, the lack of screenshots, basically the lack of focus on a product that will live or die on its usability and interface. I'm not a fan of the Z in openloopz. Combined with the comic sansy looking headline font it doesn't feel polished. The…

Wow, this is fantastic feedback, thank you for taking the time to write it. Apologies if my post came across as personal suffering - I certainly don't want any pity! I didn't intend for it to be too negative - I was just being honest and got a bit carried away! This has been a very, very hard slog and I realise most people on here are going through the same thing. I would never write something like this on a more mai…

You've got this, these are all problems we've all had before, and there are solutions to them ;) We will all be here to give feedback, commiserate, and help you succeed. You have a great attitude in this response. An ability to take honest (often unpleasant to hear) feedback and use it to improve your product and pitch is the single most important thing you can do for yourself. Keep on crushing problems and I look forward to your next showing!

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#69
post #60

I'll come out with a contrarian point of view: I think you're wasting your time and certainly your money. To have invested your life savings into this app which, uh, is really hard to determine what it does seems silly to me - especially since you have a family to care for. Slack Meets GitHub Issues? Doesn't Slack already meet GitHub issues in that it integrates with GitHub fine? The fact that you need a very long bl…

I agree with your assessment. I don't think this product has the type of competitive advantage needed in this highly saturated communications market. I think you can use this to lead to better things. Iterate on the product, get some feedback, and attack it again. In the meantime, blog throughout the process. Get your voice out. If you generate interest about your product before you release it, you can generate more…

Right on. Somebody should've told Mark about the saturated social media market, or Larry about the saturated search market.

There are so many communication tools, surely its a solved problem right. Ask a knowledge worker today about their favorite communication tool, and you will end up with a dozen answers in about a week's time. Definitely a sign that the problem is solved. There are a dozen solutions after all. :)

Re: Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues

#70
I think the most sensational aspect of your Show HN is your story, so I'll focus my comments there (seems like you're getting a lot of critical feedback on the product, mine is just that I don't know how to use it). I've done exactly what you have, betting everything, and then put the fruits of my work out to the universe. I've racked up $80k in credit card debt. One mentor once told me that if I was to start my own company, to be completely prepared for $100k in debt and divorce.

But every single time it's been worth it, and I learned and grew in ways I may not have anticipated. Maybe the product will succeed, maybe it won't, but usually there's a great opportunity (consulting, job offer, realizations that lead to the next thing, acquisition, friendships, other learnings, etc.) that comes from building something you know is great. I expect that this will be your story, so I just wanted to say congrats on your journey from a YC founder, 34, and forever at it.

Post reply on HN