Live data from Hacker News

'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

citylab.com

31–40 of 117 posts

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#31
post #17
post #7

This is depressingly true. I just exchanged contracts on a 2 bed flat in zone 4 that will leave me and my gf with a 300k debt. If it wasn't for her stable job in town I would think about going somewhere else. And we know that we will probably never be able to upgrade to a bigger place if prices keep rising at this rate since our income will not increase at the same speed. I wonder if London will become a boring rich…

Sorry, I don't know London, but I'm trying to understand your situation. You have a mortgage for around 1.5k for the next 25 years, shared between you and your gf for a flat with a spare bedroom close to the centre of London ? Sounds rather affordable, what am I missing ?

£1500 for the mortgage, plus bills, council tax, land rent, home insurance, repairs, etc... that is around £2000 per month not counting food, travel, clothes and entertainment.

So realistically you need to earn £3000 after tax to be able to afford it, which translates to a pre-tax salary of £50k.

We are lucky to earn more than that but the vast majority of people I know would not be able to do it.

We barely feel middle class here, I don't even own a car.

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#32

I spent my childhood in London, moving overseas after graduation - not financially motivated. With two kids now I often entertain ideas of moving back, primarily because it really is an amazing city and because of the opportunities my children would have. Unfortunately, even with the handsome salaries senior devs earn I cannot see how I could possibly pay rent and support children. So I often wonder where all this mo…

[deleted]

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#33

I spent my childhood in London, moving overseas after graduation - not financially motivated. With two kids now I often entertain ideas of moving back, primarily because it really is an amazing city and because of the opportunities my children would have. Unfortunately, even with the handsome salaries senior devs earn I cannot see how I could possibly pay rent and support children. So I often wonder where all this mo…

"even with the handsome salaries senior devs earn" People working at Google etc think they're paid handsomely, but in reality in London they are paid a fraction compared to what you can get in the financial sector. This article and the comments here talk about software developers and graphic designers, and the reality is there's a whole community above you earning much more. That's who's able to buy the houses.

That's what I suspect, but it's crazy. The average salary in London is £27k, a senior dev will earn 3x that (I'm guessing). And that's still barely enough to live comfortably.

I guess that's the point of the campaign in the linked article, but I can't see how that will change, unless the financial bubble bursts.

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#34

I spent my childhood in London, moving overseas after graduation - not financially motivated. With two kids now I often entertain ideas of moving back, primarily because it really is an amazing city and because of the opportunities my children would have. Unfortunately, even with the handsome salaries senior devs earn I cannot see how I could possibly pay rent and support children. So I often wonder where all this mo…

"even with the handsome salaries senior devs earn" People working at Google etc think they're paid handsomely, but in reality in London they are paid a fraction compared to what you can get in the financial sector. This article and the comments here talk about software developers and graphic designers, and the reality is there's a whole community above you earning much more. That's who's able to buy the houses.

Another factor is generational wealth. Most of my friends who own houses in London earn less than me but were given large amounts of money by their parents. When you have a 20-40% deposit the monthly mortgage payments become much more affordable.

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"even with the handsome salaries senior devs earn" People working at Google etc think they're paid handsomely, but in reality in London they are paid a fraction compared to what you can get in the financial sector. This article and the comments here talk about software developers and graphic designers, and the reality is there's a whole community above you earning much more. That's who's able to buy the houses.

That's what I suspect, but it's crazy. The average salary in London is £27k, a senior dev will earn 3x that (I'm guessing). And that's still barely enough to live comfortably. I guess that's the point of the campaign in the linked article, but I can't see how that will change, unless the financial bubble bursts.

And finance will pay you more than double that, and give you a 100% bonus on top of that again.

http://oxfordknight.co.uk/jobs/all-jobs/core-risk-and-pricin...

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On the other hand you can sell your flat for a higher price in the future.

I would be cautious making assumptions like that. Interests rate have been very low, at times negative even, for a long time.

I agree. My biggest fear is that on the next crash we are left with a massive debt and a property worth less than we payed.

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#37

I also left London recently, although I moved due to the weather. For every 29-year-old graphic designer who moves to Cambridge to buy a family home, there's a 22-year-old who's just started their career who's willing to live in a bedsit in Wood Green (as, coincidentally, I did at 17, trying to break in to the big city). You're meant to get older, and move out of the city. Circle of (urban) life. Give it 50 years, an…

>That you see yourself as being one of the "original" residents doesn't give you some inherent right to below-market-prices in property. It speaks volumes that you implicitly put the rights of Russian oligarchs and Arab oil barons to buy property (which they often leave empty) above those of the working and middle classes of London. I'll come back to London when they start taxing the wealthy again. Until then I'll wa…

> It speaks volumes that you implicitly put the rights of Russian oligarchs and Arab oil barons to buy property (which they often leave empty) above those of the working and middle classes of London.

It's not about putting anyone's rights "above" anyone else's -- whoever is willing to pay the most gets the property, that's all there is to it.

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#38

I also left London recently, although I moved due to the weather. For every 29-year-old graphic designer who moves to Cambridge to buy a family home, there's a 22-year-old who's just started their career who's willing to live in a bedsit in Wood Green (as, coincidentally, I did at 17, trying to break in to the big city). You're meant to get older, and move out of the city. Circle of (urban) life. Give it 50 years, an…

>That you see yourself as being one of the "original" residents doesn't give you some inherent right to below-market-prices in property. It speaks volumes that you implicitly put the rights of Russian oligarchs and Arab oil barons to buy property (which they often leave empty) above those of the working and middle classes of London. I'll come back to London when they start taxing the wealthy again. Until then I'll wa…

"(which they often leave empty)" [Citation Required]

Genuinely curious.

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#39

It's maddening that property owners can vote against new construction, when they have a deep conflict of interest. The community may require housing, but the homeowner has an interest in seeing housing prices go up forever. It's similar to this ridiculous notion that expensive housing is a good thing. We give absurd tax breaks to homeowners (why can't I deduct the lost interest on my rent?), and people lament falling…

> It's maddening that property owners can vote against new construction, when they have a deep conflict of interest.

> landed incumbents voting to screw over the young

That pesky "democracy" and "giving everybody a voice" getting in the way of what I want right now.

(oh, and a small nitpick: Homeowners don't have conflict of interest, they simply have a different interest which may conflict with yours)

Re: 'Nobody My Age Can Afford to Stay Here Forever'

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>That you see yourself as being one of the "original" residents doesn't give you some inherent right to below-market-prices in property. It speaks volumes that you implicitly put the rights of Russian oligarchs and Arab oil barons to buy property (which they often leave empty) above those of the working and middle classes of London. I'll come back to London when they start taxing the wealthy again. Until then I'll wa…

> It speaks volumes that you implicitly put the rights of Russian oligarchs and Arab oil barons to buy property (which they often leave empty) above those of the working and middle classes of London. It's not about putting anyone's rights "above" anyone else's -- whoever is willing to pay the most gets the property, that's all there is to it.

So you are putting the rights of people with more money above those with less money. It's not a natural law that this is the case, it's still a political decision.
Post reply on HN