Live data from Hacker News

The Island Where People Forget to Die

nytimes.com

61–70 of 74 posts

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#61
post #8
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And where have you read about this "widely misused pension system"? I am Greek and I can asure you that this is another one of the "rumors" floating around about Greece which, as all rumors, is a blatant lie. In fact, the pension system in Greece has been following the European standards since at least 10 years. I am so sick and tired of outsiders spewing nonsense all of the internet about Greece without knowing any…

No rumors, the source are the Greek Labour Ministry and the European Union. Search for "greek pension abuse" on Google: * Greece pulls the plug on pensions for the dead (Apr 25, 2012): http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/25/greece-benefits-id... * 2% of Greek population abuse pension system (26 Apr, 2012): https://www.devere-group.com/news/Greek-population-abuse-pen... * Greece Still Paying Dead Pensioners (Aug 17…

If you read the articles -- and if you follow the proceedings in Greece, this is linkbaity headlines.

Title: "120,000 families claiming 'ghost pensions' for relatives who died years ago"

Actual content: "Greece has halted welfare or pension payments to 200,000 people either because they are unentitled to the money - or because they are dead, a Labour Ministry official said on Wednesday."

Not that the 200.000 number includes all pensions under examination -- and most of those were found to be absolutely OK in subsequent checks.

So, first the "dead getting pensions" were far from "120,000" (more close to a few thousands -- and of those "dead cases" most were recent deaths of a few months were the reported death wasn't yet registered (the bureacracy is chaotic).

The final tally was some 40.000 problematic pensions (which in a huge messy bureacracy like Greece includes pensions missing a few supporting documents, having 1% less "pension credits" than needed, etc), and around 2.500 cases of "dead pensioners".

Moreover, of those "dead pensioners" most were cases of people who died with no relatives etc and weren't declared to stop the pension being deposited. Of the 35 million euros deposited to dead pensioners, the state found that the 21 million euros were such and reclaimed it immediately ( http://www.enet.gr/?i=news.el.article&id=380165 ). The rest could be actual fraud cases.

Not as impressive as the BS baity headlines that preceded the investigation one year before. The government merely wanted to give an impression of wide corruption, in order to sweeten the passage of some anti-pension laws.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#62
I wonder about these longevity clusters and whether they aren't just random. If you've read The Drunkard's Walk, (which I highly recommend by the way) there's a similar phenomenon with cancer clusters and the distribution of shells when the Germans were bombing London.

In both cases people rushed to find some explanation for why the events happened in clusters like they did. What were the Germans trying to target? What's in the water/air that's causing cancer? But if you distribute things completely at random, you end up with the same sort of clusters purely by chance.

So if everyone has a given percent chance of living to a certain age, and it's randomly distributed throughout the world, you'd expect that there would be some clusters where groups of people living a long time show up by chance. It's not quite that simple of course, because longevity isn't independent from one person to the next. e.g. if everyone in your family lives a really long time, there's a good chance you'll live a really long time too. But I'd be curious to see if these clusters happen at a greater incidence than one would expect them to randomly occur or if there's even some way to measure that.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#64

I don't know if his story checks out, but I was intrigued by the idea of cancers going away on their own, as if they were a typical illness. It turns out, sometimes they do: http://bigthink.com/videos/can-cancer-cure-itself-4 - and even weirder (to me), many cancers are self limited in nature and more harmful to treat than just leave in place: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/30/health/cancer-screening-ma...

This actually happened to my grandfather. He had skin cancer (likely basal cell carcinoma). He was quite old and decided not to treat the cancer.

It grew quite large, then scabbed over and fell off. The skin healed up and he was cancer free.

Apparently it happens relatively often with some cancers.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#65

> It’s easy to get enough rest if no one else wakes up early and the village goes dead during afternoon naptime. It helps that the cheapest, most accessible foods are also the most healthful — and that your ancestors have spent centuries developing ways to make them taste good. It’s hard to get through the day in Ikaria without walking up 20 hills. You’re not likely to ever feel the existential pain of not belonging…

I think its entirely possible to live in a Western society and live with those principles ascribed above.

It just takes will power but it hasn't ever been easier. The overall population has more access to healthful, natural foods than in the past. I'm always amazed that on many street corners in NYC a vendor is willing to sell you produce at incredible prices (4 bananas for $1, $2 for a small cart of blueberries, etc) considering that many of these products come from thousands of miles away and are incredibly perishable.

Discovering communities that share your beliefs and lifestyle is also a lot easier today than it has been.

I think a lot of people that don't ascribe to this healthful lifestyle just have different values. Some people like cheap processed food. It's a lot more consistent and convenient than many other food products. I don't believe in any kind of global conspiracy that wants to push foods bad for your health or inactive lifestyles. I guess maybe its less depressing to think that societal forces manipulate people rather than the idea that people make conscious health related trade-offs for their own reasons.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#66
post #63

The article glosses over the contribution of genetics by providing just one vague counterexample. However, see this http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.... Very clear evidence in a wide study about the contribution of genetics.

I spend a lot of time in a journal club discussing human behavior genetics with researchers who include researchers on extreme old age. That's a data-mining study, and would not impress other researchers in the field (or even get published in a better journal) without being replicated in an independent dataset. Spurious gene-correlation studies of this kind are a dime a dozen.

Food for thought is that the heritability of longevity as discovered in twin studies is actually not particularly high.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>20? Maybe. but How about being in the body of a 30- or 40-year old again? I can't imagine any 70-year olds not wanting to have a more "hassle-free" body, all other things being equal. Nobody is going to pay for your pension forever. Do you really want to spend your entire life working?

>>Nobody is going to pay for your pension forever. What? I don't know where you are from,but in EU state pensions are absolutely paid until death.

I live in germany but I tried to use common sense.

In this scenario our society would be split into two groups if we pay pensions for eternity:

Those who lived long enough to receive their pension. Their body turns 30 again thanks to breakthroughs in science. And those who never age beyond 30 and so they never get their pension.

The first group effectively gets "basic income" and they probably own houses/apartments so their living costs are quite low. You can either let everyone have pensions or get rid of pensions.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#68
post #35

> It’s easy to get enough rest if no one else wakes up early and the village goes dead during afternoon naptime. It helps that the cheapest, most accessible foods are also the most healthful — and that your ancestors have spent centuries developing ways to make them taste good. It’s hard to get through the day in Ikaria without walking up 20 hills. You’re not likely to ever feel the existential pain of not belonging…

Not sure how you can describe frozen pizza as "tasty". I would never want to eat a frozen pizza through choice.

You can bake it first; it's better that way.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#69
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Getting older and eventually dying is imho, what defines our humanity. Maybe, but is that a good thing? To simply "expire out of existence" is a big issue for "humanity". It's the main reason why there's no proper answer to "what's the meaning of life" - whatever you do during your 50/70/120/.. years of life you'll eventually end up just as dead as the guy right next to you. Congratulations! Being immortal would al…

>20? Maybe. but How about being in the body of a 30- or 40-year old again? I can't imagine any 70-year olds not wanting to have a more "hassle-free" body, all other things being equal. Nobody is going to pay for your pension forever. Do you really want to spend your entire life working?

Not a lot of people get pensions where I live anymore (or at least, not enough of one to live on comfortably). If you don't want to spend your entire life working, you could save for retirement, same as you (hopefully) do now. A lot of people plan their retirement so that they can live off the returns of their investments without touching the principal. If you do this, there's not much difference between retiring for 20 years versus 200.

Re: The Island Where People Forget to Die

#70
for me - the environment has a huge affect. utopia for me would be a distributed global community based in various exotic locations that are +50% self sufficient.. where everyone contributes to building social or eco progressive products, services, and biz models. with possibilities for virtual schooling ( for those w/kids )
Post reply on HN