Live data from Hacker News

µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

github.com

31–40 of 87 posts

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#31
post #12

still not able to block youtube ads, thanks, but no thanks. I´ll stick with adblock edge.

I have never seen a single YouTube ad with uBlock and Chrome.

IME, youtube ads seem to come on dynamically, with dynamic amount of "forcible viewing" time, eg 5sec, 30sec, 60sec, etc. It does a pretty damn good job of showing me the most ad without my walking away in disgust. For example, I was on a binge of science videos and the ads went from 0 sec, to 15, to 30, in lock-step with my curiosity.

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#32
post #9
post #8

I still havent figured out how to unblock resources with ublock.

In the "options" page for the Chrome extension there's a whitelist tab.

Does that whitelist the entire host? I would like to block everything but a specific JavaScript file on specific host. This is very easy to do with ghostery

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#33
post #24

Denying 3rd-party resources by default is nice, but definitely experts-only. Pages will break in weird ways when half their rat's nests of JavaScript are missing, and it will take some coding knowledge to figure out which parts are necessary. I may switch to this myself, but I think I'll keep telling friends and family to use Ghostery

Ghostery breaks so much stuff, I don't know how people can bother. I've found that Privacy Badger does a great job of blocking third-party tools in a way that rarely breaks anything - in which case it's easy to turn off. That and Ad Muncher for Windows.

The only really noticeable impact I've seen is that it blocks Disqus, which too many people seem to use for comments. That's usually not a problem, and I can always disable it in the rare cases where I really want to comment on something. What sites are breaking for you?

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#34
post #16

Okay, I'm probably stupid. This would allow me to throw away NoScript, Disconnect and Adblock. But I can't figure out how to enable deny by default mode?! (Yes I have advanced mode enabled)

There's a tiny little + by the "Requests Blocked" label on the Button panel. Click that. Then red the left side of the top five boxes (images and scripts and the like). If I understand correctly, it's not really a mode, it's just several broad filters. 0.8.5.7 on Firefox doesn't have an 'all' that I can see.

Oh, I see. I was under the assumption that these settings were still site specific, got it, thanks!

Edit: Would be nice to be able to set those global settings once and not have them pop up on every page. And/or have a visual distinction between global and site specific rules, right now there is no option to globally disable images and then whitelist on a per site basis, right? I can just whitelist a domain which will then load everything?

My initial impression wasthat I could globally blacklist everything I don't want per default and then enable it on a (sub)domain basis.

I'll certainly give this a shot though. My firefox is really slow with ~20ish addons.

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#35
post #24

Denying 3rd-party resources by default is nice, but definitely experts-only. Pages will break in weird ways when half their rat's nests of JavaScript are missing, and it will take some coding knowledge to figure out which parts are necessary. I may switch to this myself, but I think I'll keep telling friends and family to use Ghostery

Ghostery breaks so much stuff, I don't know how people can bother. I've found that Privacy Badger does a great job of blocking third-party tools in a way that rarely breaks anything - in which case it's easy to turn off. That and Ad Muncher for Windows.

What does it break apart from google ajax search?

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#36
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a tiny little + by the "Requests Blocked" label on the Button panel. Click that. Then red the left side of the top five boxes (images and scripts and the like). If I understand correctly, it's not really a mode, it's just several broad filters. 0.8.5.7 on Firefox doesn't have an 'all' that I can see.

Oh, I see. I was under the assumption that these settings were still site specific, got it, thanks! Edit: Would be nice to be able to set those global settings once and not have them pop up on every page. And/or have a visual distinction between global and site specific rules, right now there is no option to globally disable images and then whitelist on a per site basis, right? I can just whitelist a domain which wil…

If you go into the settings and look at "My Rules", you can get a pretty good sense of the scope of the rules you have running.

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#37

Denying 3rd-party resources by default is nice, but definitely experts-only. Pages will break in weird ways when half their rat's nests of JavaScript are missing, and it will take some coding knowledge to figure out which parts are necessary. I may switch to this myself, but I think I'll keep telling friends and family to use Ghostery

Reminds me a lot of the first time using NoScript. Figuring out which domains added functionality, and which just unleashed another tree of third party domains that may or may not unlock the content. Fun, for certain definitions of the word.

Re: µBlock dynamic filtering: default deny

#38
post #32
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the "options" page for the Chrome extension there's a whitelist tab.

Does that whitelist the entire host? I would like to block everything but a specific JavaScript file on specific host. This is very easy to do with ghostery

Perhaps, you should just switch to µMatrix.
Post reply on HN