Live data from Hacker News

Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

atomtips.com

11–20 of 68 posts

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#11

Notepad++ Next question

Wow downvotes by the hipsters. Not surprising i guess..

No. Your previous comment is simply irelevant as a HN comment. Look at the other comments in a similar style to yours. All downvoted as well. Editor wars are so damn dull without any factual exchanges.

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#13
post #9

The biggest issue for me is startup speed. Atom simply takes too long for me. I'm often quickly having a look at large numerical csv files and Atom startup times plus csv load times are always large enough to immediately switch back to sublime. Still want to like Atom though.

I feel the same way about Sublime. Notepad++ starts faster.

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#14
post #9

The biggest issue for me is startup speed. Atom simply takes too long for me. I'm often quickly having a look at large numerical csv files and Atom startup times plus csv load times are always large enough to immediately switch back to sublime. Still want to like Atom though.

I've settled on using Atom for my longer-term work, where I can just leave it open and am not too bothered by sluggishness here or there.

Then I use Sublime Text for big files, quick edits, and the occasional stuff that Atom can't do yet.

But after avoiding Atom initially, trying it again about a week a go was a nice surprise. It has almost any plugin that I used Sublime Text for, and a bunch more. It's good enough for me, and I'm pretty picky.

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#15
Atom has an ambitious concept and is generally engineered well, but the performance is crippling it so far. I'm not sure whether it's possible in the current web-to-native implementation to actually reach native performance, especially for large files, but so far it's just not ready for the primetime.

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#16
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow downvotes by the hipsters. Not surprising i guess..

No. Your previous comment is simply irelevant as a HN comment. Look at the other comments in a similar style to yours. All downvoted as well. Editor wars are so damn dull without any factual exchanges.

You are right, I had a lot of downvotes until I realized that I am not in reddit and that comments should be made to anrich the conversation, not to express a single word like 'notepad++' that means nothing.

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#17
I don't think you should rely on other's opinions when picking an editor. Just try each one (really try) for a week or two and decide after that.

Everyone uses editors differently (hence the big vim/emacs/etc flame war) and it is where you'll spend time coding. A lot of time. I don't think reading someone else's opinion really helps.

When I chose my editor everyone was crazy about TextMate. I tried it out and didn't like it. I was completely afraid of Vim (and all of the jokes about how hard it was) and after I tried it I couldn't stop using it. It's a very personal choice.

Just try them out!

Edit: typo

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#19
You have to understand that Atom is repurposed webkit, with all the flaws and benefits that come with a browser engine.

I liked it, the dealbreaker (to say the least) for me was broken support for non-US keyboard layouts, it can't differentiate alt from alt-gr making it impossible for me to type most brackets and pipe.

This has been an open issue for months, with a couple of community contributed "solutions" that don't quite cut it. Considering they are pretty much ignoring the problem I won't be checking out Atom again soon.

Re: Atom Editor or Sublime Text – which one to pick?

#20
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow downvotes by the hipsters. Not surprising i guess..

No. Your previous comment is simply irelevant as a HN comment. Look at the other comments in a similar style to yours. All downvoted as well. Editor wars are so damn dull without any factual exchanges.

What facts do you want about a subjective topic like editors. I prefer notepad. I use everything.

I dont feel more hip in vim.

Post reply on HN