Live data from Hacker News

Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]

youtube.com

11–20 of 85 posts

Re: Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]

#11
post #3
post #2

I thought this was going to be his older video, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zGnxeSbb3g . But he's improved. Splitting an incoming arrow???

And not even that but unloading with less than a second after spinning around from facing the other way? It actually puts Legolas to shame.

i wonder what happen when he fails

Re: Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]

#13

I'd love to know the draw weights of the bows he's using. One of the differences between the sort of archery he's doing and the standard recurve competition shooting you'll see is that the latter is much slower, more relaxed, with very defined, conscious aiming. The idea is to do precisely the same thing, with your whole body, over and over and over again. His aiming is completely instinctual. Because of the way the…

I imagine that in combat (as bows were used when these techniques were "lost") you didn't have to be bullseye-accurate. Close to where you were aiming is often good enough.

Re: Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]

#14
post #3
post #2

I thought this was going to be his older video, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zGnxeSbb3g . But he's improved. Splitting an incoming arrow???

And not even that but unloading with less than a second after spinning around from facing the other way? It actually puts Legolas to shame.

Well, and they CGI'd the most of the movie's Legolas' "arrows" as well.

http://www.kotaku.com.au/2014/06/game-of-thrones-has-cgi-in-...

Re: Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]

#15
post #2

I thought this was going to be his older video, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zGnxeSbb3g . But he's improved. Splitting an incoming arrow???

We just saw the time it worked. And he had a big grin on his face. How many times did it fail?

Probably quite a few, but what's your point? That he shot enough arrows that it eventually hit without requiring significant skill? I tend to believe his success is above that of chance.

Re: Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]

#17

I'd love to know the draw weights of the bows he's using. One of the differences between the sort of archery he's doing and the standard recurve competition shooting you'll see is that the latter is much slower, more relaxed, with very defined, conscious aiming. The idea is to do precisely the same thing, with your whole body, over and over and over again. His aiming is completely instinctual. Because of the way the…

He is very specifically releasing quickly. I didn't see anywhere an attempt to hold a bow in position for a long time to aim --- just like throwing a ball, you don't have to hold it cocked when you are an expert.

How are these trick shots, and not refined? Those sound like belittling statements. He has done good research and discovery of how ancient warriors fought. It is fair to call them different techniques, but not refined vs unrefined. It would take some serious practice to duplicate the masters in either style.

Re: Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]

#19

I'd love to know the draw weights of the bows he's using. One of the differences between the sort of archery he's doing and the standard recurve competition shooting you'll see is that the latter is much slower, more relaxed, with very defined, conscious aiming. The idea is to do precisely the same thing, with your whole body, over and over and over again. His aiming is completely instinctual. Because of the way the…

So you want to compare sports archery vs combat archery and expect the results to be anything less than obvious?

Your comment does make me consider, though, whether longbowmen use a technique more similar to the modern sports technique than to Andersen's here. Kind of like how sniping is more similar to target practice than urban combat.

Post reply on HN