Live data from Hacker News

So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

i.imgur.com

41–50 of 88 posts

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#41
I think it's highly subjective. What worked for the sample space might not work for me or you. That's why I always take these type of researches as a grain of salt, and try to figure out what works for me and what doesn't.

I believes many of these claims will be debunked as the 'The Human Connectome Project' and 'The Human Brain Project' nears completion. But I think many things like creativity will always remain subjective.

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#42

Might I add yet another bit of input on how to be creative? John Cleese had a few words to say about being creative a while ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DMpdPrm6Ul4

One of the best bits: "Look babycakes, I don't have to make the decision until next Tuesday. And I'm not chickening out of my creative discomfort by taking a snap decision before then -- that's too easy!"

I've observed that many hacker types flinch from the megahertz, ironically enough, as a way to keep up with the speed of the systems they've built.

Killing creativity is the least of it. Many snap judgments rot the brain.

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#45
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually I used to work as a rafting guide. Didn't earn a lot of money, but I had a lot of free time (in nature), and met a lot of people. I notice that I had way more ideas then than I do now that I have settled into a 9-6 lifestyle. Sometimes that creativity starts coming back when I am on holiday for a while. I think a "normal" office job / lifestyle is very stifling to creativity.

Might be true, but it's easy to misjudge this: in your 9-6 you have lots of time to process any interesting ideas that come your way and then move on to the next thing, whereas while you were a rafting guide you probably chewed on the same ideas for longer and at odd times, making them appear more salient and profound.

I think many of us mistake "creativity" for "having great ideas appear in our minds". That's only a part of it, and "rafting guide" is a great environment for that part. The next part - filtering and workshopping those ideas - probably works best in a more traditional work environment with some constraints and teammates.

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#46
The headlines, indeed, are mutually discrediting. Probably the later ones were submitted in response to the others.

All these studies suffer from inadequate efforts to properly operationalize the concept of "creativity". On the bright side, I believe that information sciences and statistics can shed a great deal more light on this particular problem in the near future.

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#47

See also: http://kill-or-cure.herokuapp.com/

"deodorant causes cancer"

"being southern causes cancer"

"being black causes cancer"

"being male causes cancer"

"fatherhood causes cancer" / "childlessness cause cancer"

"work causes cancer"/"working causes cancer"

"bras cause cancer"

"bacon causes cancer"

"burgers cause cancer"

I feel sorry for deodorant-wearing, southern, black, working fathers (or not) that cross-dress and enjoy bacon-burgers - they clearly don't stand a chance against cancer! Who knew?

@JonnieCache - Thanks for sharing! Kill or cure does a great job highlighting how research can be contradictory, as well as how research headlines are often made sensationalist.

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#48
I had the same confusion after seeing the headlines, but after reading the respective articles, I think the point is that happiness and non-focussed dreamy state are helpful in freely exploring problems and links semi-consciously – sort of finding ideas in the back of your head – while the sadness (and anxiety) is needed to focus and keep trying to succeed in hard disciplines.

Moods correlate with states of focus and attention, and hence some states of mind are more useful in particular phases of the creative process.

I think it makes sense to some extent, as a happy person has no needs and can let their mind float aimlessly while an unhappy person wants to strive, focus and achieve to change his/her condition or to at least forget about the state of mind he/she is in.

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#49
post #39

To be really creative, you need to stop reading Hacker News frantically and go out and explore nature, other people and your own thoughts.

Ah, the fabled Outernet. I've heard a lot about it.

There's nothing on Snopes, but I'm pretty sure that "outside" is a myth.

Re: So I need to be sad, bored and happy to be creative

#50
The only insightful article I've ever read on creativity is from Douglas Hofstadter's Metamagical Themas – love the anagam! – column: "Variations on a theme as the essence of imagination". Anything written by Hofstadter is gold and this is no exception.

link: http://www.bgrosjean.com/files/Metamagical_Themas.pdf

Post reply on HN