Live data from Hacker News

The Human Toll of Flashbangs

propublica.org

31–40 of 262 posts

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#31
post #15

I don't live in the US, so I am maybe missing something but, if the police wants to arrest someone, wouldn't be easier to wait until this person leaves the house, grab him on the street and tell him: "Hi mate, we are the police and now you are under arrest". I don't see the need of assaulting a home.

> I don't see the need of assaulting a home. it's almost always for drugs, where they'd be afraid the person could flush them down the toilet.

[deleted]

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#32
post #15

I don't live in the US, so I am maybe missing something but, if the police wants to arrest someone, wouldn't be easier to wait until this person leaves the house, grab him on the street and tell him: "Hi mate, we are the police and now you are under arrest". I don't see the need of assaulting a home.

As I understand it, this is part of the war-on-drugs mindset. Since possession of even minor quantities of drugs can result in severe sentences, they assume offenders will be as violent as anyone receiving such sentences.

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#33
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

...and what they call "well-intentioned" I call "doing a job despite its moral indefensibility." (and to be clear: I'm talking specifically about pre-dawn violent raids as a measure to ostensibly enforce drug laws, not policing in general)

What's most amazing is how smug and unapologetic the involved LEOs are when they've been interviewed on camera about this incident. One can only hope that the video is accepted as evidence in the civil case and will add a significant multiplier to the damages awarded.

I'm guessing their lawyers have told them not to apologize (show apathy), as it may actually be worse for them in the civil suit.

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#34
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I grew up in Ellijay, GA and many police offers were bullies in my highschool. The city doesn't really have the cream of the crop or the pay to choose otherwise.

When your job ads say "not much pay, but you get to carry a big gun and scare people with it," this is what you get. I wish cops and primary/secondary teachers were paid enough that the people reading this post would consider those jobs, because they kind of matter.

Seems like a chicken and egg problem.

They barely deserve the salary they get now with all the incidents going on, but they won't get more intelligent people applying until the wages are increased.

Probably best to start with the teachers so theres a larger pool if educated people to hire from.

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#35
post #15

I don't live in the US, so I am maybe missing something but, if the police wants to arrest someone, wouldn't be easier to wait until this person leaves the house, grab him on the street and tell him: "Hi mate, we are the police and now you are under arrest". I don't see the need of assaulting a home.

> I don't see the need of assaulting a home. it's almost always for drugs, where they'd be afraid the person could flush them down the toilet.

As the GP said, that's why you simply wait until they leave the house. In nearly all these cases, they're only looking for one person.

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#36
post #15

I don't live in the US, so I am maybe missing something but, if the police wants to arrest someone, wouldn't be easier to wait until this person leaves the house, grab him on the street and tell him: "Hi mate, we are the police and now you are under arrest". I don't see the need of assaulting a home.

> I don't see the need of assaulting a home. it's almost always for drugs, where they'd be afraid the person could flush them down the toilet.

If you arrest people outside their house when they go for a walk, how on earth are they going to "flush the drugs down the toilet"?

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#37
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's most amazing is how smug and unapologetic the involved LEOs are when they've been interviewed on camera about this incident. One can only hope that the video is accepted as evidence in the civil case and will add a significant multiplier to the damages awarded.

I'm guessing their lawyers have told them not to apologize (show apathy), as it may actually be worse for them in the civil suit.

Cops in the US are immune to civil liability for acts while on duty.

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#38
“Everyone carries a flashbang,” Malette testified. “Any time we encounter locked doors, we have an unknown, we have to gain back that initiative.”

I understand that police are interested in maintaining control of a situation, but practices like throwing flashbang grenades into houses without looking...these guys seem to think they're Delta Force.

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#39

Bou Bou was sleeping in a portable playpen at the foot of his parents’ bed when the Habersham County Special Response Team broke down the door to the room and threw a flashbang. The grenade landed on a pillow next to Bou Bou’s face. The blast blew a hole in his chest, severed his nose, and tore apart his lips and mouth. That's horrifying. I can't believe that these things are allowed to be used with so little oversig…

> “Some of what contributed to this tragedy can be attributed to well-intentioned people getting in too big a hurry,”

The things you can get away with when you have an uniform...

Re: The Human Toll of Flashbangs

#40
post #15

I don't live in the US, so I am maybe missing something but, if the police wants to arrest someone, wouldn't be easier to wait until this person leaves the house, grab him on the street and tell him: "Hi mate, we are the police and now you are under arrest". I don't see the need of assaulting a home.

Depending on where you live, that's exactly what happens.

In Kentucky, they'll send (usually) 3 state troopers, and knock on your door. If the person that they want isn't at home, they'll take your word for it, and let you be on your way.

In Ohio, it's usually six or more officers with guns drawn. They'll try to open the doors of the house to gain entry without knocking or announcing their presence. When the person that they're looking for isn't at home, they'll try to find a reason to come inside and search the property looking for that person (and a reason to arrest everyone inside). They'll then circle the house outside for 24-48 hours to intimidate the people inside but eventually give up when they realize that the person doesn't actually live there.

What's really sad is that I was great friends with a member of Law Enforcement until I realized how short-sighted and two-faced he was; the LEO community really breeds an environment of "us versus them" and if you're a defendant (regardless of guilt or innocence), you're a scumbag who deserves to be in jail.

Post reply on HN