Live data from Hacker News

Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

nytimes.com

11–20 of 67 posts

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#11
post #4

I'm just finishing up All About Love: New Visions by bell hooks. In it, she talks about love as an action. She frequently quotes Erich Fromm's The Art of Loving , which seems good as well. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_About_Love:_New_Visions [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Art_of_Loving

The Art of Loving, while feeling a bit dated in some parts (especially Fromm's views on homosexuality), is on the whole a fantastic, short little book that I reread every few years or so. I always liked his definition of love: "Love is the active concern for the life and the growth of that which we love. Where this active concern is lacking, there is no love."

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#12
I thought this was great and recommend the article. Click through to the list of questions - http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/11/fashion/no-37-big-wedding-...

There's no harm in trying it. At worst you'll get to know someone. I'd have no qualms working through this set with at least a dozen people I can think of off-hand (some of whom aren't available anyway, it doesn't matter, or where we flirt anyway.)

The questions are mostly quite interesting. I'd lie about #34 though as it's embarrassing that, like most people here, I have unbacked up stuff on a laptop, which would be an easy decision over other stuff (since there's so much and it's so easy to take) but gives the wrong impression about my priorities. So what - say someone isn't completely honest with you in some of the answers. still an interesting set of questions.

I'm also curious what happens if you just do this with an acquaintance of the same gender assuming neither of you two have any interest in that gender romantically. if you're a man, imagine just answering this stuff with a casual acquiantance (think of bros or colleagues) vaguely similar to you but not a gender you're attracted to, and looking into each other's eyes for 4 minutes. same if you're a woman with another woman acquaintance. [1]

It would be interesting to know what kind of bonding this elicits.

[1] I specifically chose to mention only a same-gendered examples - two guys who aren't into guys, or same with two girls - because the example of a purely gay person doing so with someone of the opposite gender is a bit different for a couple of reasons. some gay people will date or even marry someone of the opposite gender - e.g. a beard - plus social norms would push in that direction even if neither party is attracted. I'm more interested in the example of two acquaintances who are of the same gender but not gay doing this.)

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#13

This is sophistry. She was already attracted to him (here, I use it in the sense primarily of "willing to go out on a date with him") before they started. I don't see any mention of "to build attraction, do this", and intimacy will smother their boundaries and their relationship without attraction.

do you happen to know a good word for reading an article but commenting on the title?

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#14

This is sophistry. She was already attracted to him (here, I use it in the sense primarily of "willing to go out on a date with him") before they started. I don't see any mention of "to build attraction, do this", and intimacy will smother their boundaries and their relationship without attraction.

do you happen to know a good word for reading an article but commenting on the title?

Touche.

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#15

I thought this was great and recommend the article. Click through to the list of questions - http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/11/fashion/no-37-big-wedding-... There's no harm in trying it. At worst you'll get to know someone. I'd have no qualms working through this set with at least a dozen people I can think of off-hand (some of whom aren't available anyway, it doesn't matter, or where we flirt anyway.) The questions…

As for doing this with a person of the same gender, i think we most likely know the answer - it won't lead to falling in love. Why ? because if it did, we would have seen many female best friends(who do similar stuff all the time), or or males that are found in even more bonding situations(like war) - who don't fall in love.

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#18
post #5

I harvested the questions out of the PDF. https://gist.github.com/shmup/3bc1229f24486d746bf3

Oddly those don't match the list which the NYT published: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/11/fashion/no-37-big-wedding-...

They match the questions under "Task Slips for Closeness-Generating Procedure" but don't include the "Task Slips for Small-Talk Condition in Study 1" questions.

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#19
post #11
post #4

I'm just finishing up All About Love: New Visions by bell hooks. In it, she talks about love as an action. She frequently quotes Erich Fromm's The Art of Loving , which seems good as well. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_About_Love:_New_Visions [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Art_of_Loving

The Art of Loving , while feeling a bit dated in some parts (especially Fromm's views on homosexuality), is on the whole a fantastic, short little book that I reread every few years or so. I always liked his definition of love: "Love is the active concern for the life and the growth of that which we love. Where this active concern is lacking, there is no love."

Love has a circular definition? I find that interesting. It implies (to me) that more love grows from love. Maybe the experiment successfully lays the down a foundation to begin the circular love reinforcement.

Re: Applying an experimental procedure to fall in love

#20
Time for all of us to come up with pre-canned answers.

"My greatest weakness is that I'm a workaholic perfectionist. I know I should spend more time doing stuff other than working and preparing for work, but it's just so important to do everything that is best for my company."

Post reply on HN