Live data from Hacker News

Ruby on Rails vs. PHP

leonardteo.com

1–8 of 8 posts

Re: Ruby on Rails vs. PHP

#3
This is quite a good write, up, points out when you would want to use one or the other, and not crapping all over PHP just because it isn't a great language.

And interesting that he points out that finding a dev will be way easier in PHP. I had a non developer friend with a start-up application. He had obviously spoken to a number of bioinformatics (he was a wet lab biologist) who had obviously ranted about the benefits of Python. So he got a Django dev. Then got a second stage of funding, to pay for a junior-ish level dev. Except no Python / Django devs (he asked me) were willing to work for the money he had available. Had he gone with PHP, he would have probably managed to continue, despite everyone probably telling him PHP was a crap language.

Re: Ruby on Rails vs. PHP

#4
post #2

I agree. I think that for PHP a huge win would be a big API refactoring, which could be not a big deal, with the right aliasing and deprecation management.

Considering the usual lack-of-concern of the version of PHP the user is installing/being provided, I could see a significant amount of compatibility problems if PHP came out with a version where weird functions (like strlen() vs str_replace(), how would you resolve the difference in convention here?) were fixed.

Re: Ruby on Rails vs. PHP

#5
post #3

This is quite a good write, up, points out when you would want to use one or the other, and not crapping all over PHP just because it isn't a great language. And interesting that he points out that finding a dev will be way easier in PHP. I had a non developer friend with a start-up application. He had obviously spoken to a number of bioinformatics (he was a wet lab biologist) who had obviously ranted about the benef…

Finding a developer that is willing to put PHP on their resume on the off chance they'll get a job, and then try and figure it out by scrounging up code on Stack Overflow is not hard.

Finding a good developer is just as hard in any language, since a good developer will be able to go with whatever language you've got.

Re: Ruby on Rails vs. PHP

#6
post #4
post #2

I agree. I think that for PHP a huge win would be a big API refactoring, which could be not a big deal, with the right aliasing and deprecation management.

Considering the usual lack-of-concern of the version of PHP the user is installing/being provided, I could see a significant amount of compatibility problems if PHP came out with a version where weird functions (like strlen() vs str_replace(), how would you resolve the difference in convention here?) were fixed.

With a compatibilty layer, a library which connects the post and the after

Re: Ruby on Rails vs. PHP

#7
post #3

This is quite a good write, up, points out when you would want to use one or the other, and not crapping all over PHP just because it isn't a great language. And interesting that he points out that finding a dev will be way easier in PHP. I had a non developer friend with a start-up application. He had obviously spoken to a number of bioinformatics (he was a wet lab biologist) who had obviously ranted about the benef…

Finding a developer that is willing to put PHP on their resume on the off chance they'll get a job, and then try and figure it out by scrounging up code on Stack Overflow is not hard. Finding a good developer is just as hard in any language, since a good developer will be able to go with whatever language you've got.

A good developer will be able to go with whatever language you have got. However, (assuming I am a half decent developer) I would avoid jobs in PHP or VB.