I find the idea that "less than 5% of employee option grants are exercised" both very sad and unsurprising. From working in this industry I've gotten the overwhelming impression that employees don't know how equity works. That leads them to systematically overvalue it, and by doing so they accept lower wages than they would otherwise. And companies that might have the best of intentions don't help at all, because the…
You can't discount that most companies fail though, you'd expect the majority of options to go unexercised. Edited to expand a bit: Shares are ugly and annoying and cap tables are broken but it so rarely matters. Things should obviously be better and cleaner and more organized but since so few companies return anything to anyone besides the preferred shareholders, I'm not sure the 'cost' of this disorganization is ve…
Broken cap tables
11–20 of 32 posts
Re: Broken cap tables
#12It took me over a year to get the stock certificates for a well known, highly funded (> $80m total) company. CFO kept blowing me off. I kept emailing every few months. Finally got it. A lot of "don't worry we recorded it", but when I give you a 5-figures check I want physical proof! Based on this article, looks like I was well justified in this.
Put that sucker in a safe deposit box, if you haven't already. If you lose it, you'll be in for a bureaucratic nightmare of indemnity bonds (which are expensive!) and notaries to get your money. And on the happy day you get to exchange your piece of paper for cash, you get to live through the unique experience of trusting a huge sum of money to the postal service.
It's a like backing up your computer on a local hard drive because you don't trust cloud providers: the chance that a law firm will lose your certificate is a lot lower than the chance that you will.
Re: Broken cap tables
#13A family member had many months of struggle getting stock certificates too. It's a real issue.
Re: Broken cap tables
#14Re: Broken cap tables
#15It does amaze me how much companies that are changing the future externally have such awful systems internally. A family member had many months of struggle getting stock certificates too. It's a real issue.
Human attention and willpower are limited resources, and assuming that when someone or a company does one thing right they must be doing other things right as well is one of the oldest fallacies in the book.
Re: Broken cap tables
#16It does amaze me how much companies that are changing the future externally have such awful systems internally. A family member had many months of struggle getting stock certificates too. It's a real issue.
I find it completely unamazing. Companies that are "changing the future externally" are spending their resources in one place instead of another. Human attention and willpower are limited resources, and assuming that when someone or a company does one thing right they must be doing other things right as well is one of the oldest fallacies in the book.
Re: Broken cap tables
#17The system is surely broken.
Re: Broken cap tables
#18I had major stock admin issues at a fairly mature (then 6-year-old) company that is now public. Soon after I started, my boss promised me a follow-on stock award for good performance but failed to do any of the paperwork. I only discovered this issue when I later requested HR to audit my paperwork, and I ended up having to fight our General Council (who was also on the board) for an ENTIRE QUARTER over this mess. The GC not only badgered me but completely mislead me and had the board change my grant without my signature on the final agreement in order save his face (and likely the company from running into trouble with pre-IPO auditors). It took a ton of painful arguments with my boss (and revelations that he had other 'broken' stock promises) to finally get that stock re-awarded. To save HIS face he ended up giving a bunch of my colleagues pre-IPO stock bonuses too (though some had that 'fuck-off' back-weighted 10/20/30/40 vesting). The whole process unfortunately obliterated the trust in the relationship and made /vesting/ the (mostly) restored stock very, very painful.
If the law, regulations, and administration were a lot more straightforward, I doubt any of this would have ever happened. (Well, if my boss and the General Council would have owned up to their mistakes, that would have helped, too :) . Something like eShares might have also enabled my company to let non-management employees do 83(b)s leading up to what turned out to be a highly successful IPO.
eShares is nice, but some sort of basic, open-source and free baby gate would be a huge help, too. When managers have so much control over employee compensation, it's really easy for them to fuck things up (intentionally or not).
Re: Broken cap tables
#19Could not agree more: "the practice of equity administration is systemically biased against employees" (and to protect companies and investors). Equity admin isn't just a mess for startups but can be a mess for mature companies, too. If you have a chance to interview a manager before accepting an offer, I highly recommend asking them how well Finance has their shit together. You don't want to, say, get in a fight wit…
Re: Broken cap tables
#20The 90 day exercise window for stock options really catches some non-finance employees off guard. They don't realize the high amount of tax and investment that has to be made for illiquid shares (which are still pretty risky for most start ups). That being said, there are a few options that I feel more people should know about including the Employee Stock Option Fund ( http://esofund.com/ ). If you fall within the 90…
[0] http://blog.samaltman.com/employee-equity
[1] I work @eShares.