Live data from Hacker News

Would you use a Linux based computer, better or equal to a mac in quality?

news.ycombinator.com

121–123 of 123 posts

Re: Would you use a Linux based computer, better or equal to a mac in quality?

#121
post #120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

T440p here. I can right click at the top or the bottom of the touchpad, so I'm not sure what you mean.

you can right-click on the bottom right w/ your thumb and that works as a right-click ?

Yes.

Re: Would you use a Linux based computer, better or equal to a mac in quality?

#122
So I use linux on my laptops as my primary OS. Mint on my thinkpad, crouton with xubuntu and chromeos on my chromebook.

I often talk to other developers here in the bay area about their computers, which are almost invariably macbooks. The reason that they continually cite for macbooks is battery life. 10 to 12 hours of typical usage including web browsing. A bit less if you are doing a fair bit of compiling.

If you want to make a laptop, you can do fine with commodity hardware, provided you pick devices with an eye on power. That may mean working with suppliers to get better drivers. I personally don't care if they are proprietary blobs or open source... but power consumption on linux vs. windows is often tracable to driver issues.

I mean a reasonably good screen and keyboard and trackpad are all important, but reasonably good ones exist out there.

Iou need to spend a lot of time tuning battery life. You need to figure out which commodity hardware devices draw the least power. You need to make the computers sleep instantly when the screen is closed. Get battery life up.

If you are going to innovate on hardware, this is where I would do it. Lenovo has a internal battery so you can hotswap external batteries. Dell had a separate arm processor with their Latitude |ON feature and got crazy battery life, and the Moto X had a separate dedicated processor for certain functions to improve battery life... maybe have your machine include a low power multicore arm processor and use that as much as possible, only using your intel cpu when the arm is overwhelmed or can't run a specific program.

The other thing is you have to make your first product good enough so you can improve your second product. Because to really make something good, you have to innovate.

Re: Would you use a Linux based computer, better or equal to a mac in quality?

#123
post #30

I am already using the Linux on laptop better than Mac. It is called Thinkpad (an older model). Now the problem is that Lenovo is trying to be more like Apple and this does not go well with them. You can ask how much people are pleased with the new single button touchpads or how they like 16:9 screens instead of 16:10 screens or how they like the lack of Delete button. So yes, I would buy a laptop (I would not buy a…

> Now the problem is that Lenovo is trying to be more like Apple and this does not go well with them. You can ask how much people are pleased with the new single button touchpads or how they like 16:9 screens instead of 16:10 screens or how they like the lack of Delete button. I have one of those newer lenovos, and if the trackpad is their attempt to "be more like" Apple, they really have a very long way to go in ter…

I had a lenovo ideapad and I didn't find the trackpad that difficult to use. Which one do you have?
Post reply on HN