Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
1–10 of 51 posts
Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#2Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#3The study only seemed to compare An iPad with print books. While I am sure many people who do use an iPad for ebooks I am sure there are many more Kindle readers, which may well have given a different result.
Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#4Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#5> The light emitted by most e-readers is shining directly into the eyes of the reader, whereas from a printed book or the original Kindle, the reader is only exposed to reflected light from the pages of the book.
So it's talking entirely about brightly backlit tablets, not e-readers with e-ink.
Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#6The study only seemed to compare An iPad with print books. While I am sure many people who do use an iPad for ebooks I am sure there are many more Kindle readers, which may well have given a different result.
Thats the primary reason I would buy a kindle over an iPad. Its not comparing e-readers and books, its comparing a bright screen with books.
EDIT: Looking at the actual paper they were definitely aware of this with measurements of the colour spectrums of different tablets, unfortunately not including the Paperwhite. Disappointing journalism skewing the story as normal.
Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#7Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#8The study only seemed to compare An iPad with print books. While I am sure many people who do use an iPad for ebooks I am sure there are many more Kindle readers, which may well have given a different result.
Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#9"They spent five days reading from a paperback and five days from an iPad.". If only iPads were used, I don't believe the word e-reader is appropriate.
If you use an e-ink display without a built-in light, there are no reason this would be any different then using a book (as mentioned in the article but it's not only about "the original kindle"). Also there were tons of studies about the effect of light on sleep and especially blue light emitted by LCDs, most e-reader makers use a warmer light if I'm not mistaken.
EDIT: elaborating
Re: Backlit e-readers 'damage sleep and health'
#10Probably the only useful line in the article: > The light emitted by most e-readers is shining directly into the eyes of the reader, whereas from a printed book or the original Kindle, the reader is only exposed to reflected light from the pages of the book. So it's talking entirely about brightly backlit tablets, not e-readers with e-ink.
Also, I dispute the OP's contention that reflected light on s paper book is any better; certainly, a normal bed-side lamp is worse for the sleep of anyone sharing the room with the reader.
EDIT. Although like I just said, an iPad probably has less of a deleterious effect on sleep than a Kindle Paperwhite does, it is probably possible to do better in the current market. Specifically, Samsung makes a tablet (the Tab S, which comes in 10.5- and 8.4-inch versions) with an OLED display, which has the advantage over LCD displays that the portions of the screen that are supposed to be black do not emit any light at all. Especially if used with software that displays red or orange text on a black background (to minimize the blue-ish photons) an OLED display is the best choice in the current smartphone-plus-tablet market AFAICT if protection of sleep is the main consideration.
EDIT. Oops, I forgot to include my main reason for preferring the iPad to the Paperwhite: on iOS, Settings > Accessibility > Invert Colors reverses black and white. Combined with the fact that many iOS apps like Safari and iBooks normally present a white field broken only by text and thin lines, the use of "Invert colors" probably results in less light entering the eye than a Paperwhite since (unless they changed it since I last updated the software on my Paperwithe a couple of months ago) you cannot alter the Paperwhite's default color scheme of black text on a white background. I will concede that the Paperwhite's brightness setting goes a lot dimmer than the iPad's does, but I consider that consideration to be trumped by what I just wrote, and, again, neither Paperwhite nor iPad comes close IMHO to an OLED display used with decent software.