Live data from Hacker News

CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

amanpour.blogs.cnn.com

21–30 of 138 posts

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#21
post #9

We've been over this already. US just fucking doesnt care. Extradition treaties are ONE WAY. http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/feb/13/italy-c... http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/31/obama-j... One of kidnapper/torturer fuckers was even apprehended, and despite international arrest warrant magically released very next day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Seldon_Lady Those people are un…

[deleted]

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The prestige hit and vulnerability to "letting down the troops" criticisms will ensure this doesn't happen.

The real reason is that they were carrying out the official policy of the US government. Just calling it CIA torture is minimizing how far up this went. Bush ordered it. DOD knew. DOJ not only knew, it crafted the governments tortured definition of torture. Congress knew. This isn't some off the books CIA wet team opp. It was planned and signed off at the highest levels. John Yoo, who wrote the torture memos, is a pr…

The fact that "24" with Jack Bauer routinely using torture ran for eight years with high ratings surely reflected the US public's tacit approval.

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#23
post #7

Keep in mind, 23 CIA employees have already been convicted and sentenced by an Italian court for a rendition operation. None of these people can be located.

The Italians can go pound sand. They had no problem allowing the lead Achille Lauro hijacker safe passage to Egypt. And in 2008 they release another Achille hijacker -- a murderer and PLO terrorist. I don't really care if the Italians had their sensibilities offended by rendition. Rendition never resulted in an Italian citizen's death, but the Achille Lauro incident certainly resulted in an American's death.

I am not making a statement about if rendition is good or bad; I'm only addressing the Italian's hypocrisy.

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#24
post #10
post #7

Keep in mind, 23 CIA employees have already been convicted and sentenced by an Italian court for a rendition operation. None of these people can be located.

Oh they can be located, they are all living safely in US.

One would wonder what would happen if they where "rendered" to a prison in italy.

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#25
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The real reason is that they were carrying out the official policy of the US government. Just calling it CIA torture is minimizing how far up this went. Bush ordered it. DOD knew. DOJ not only knew, it crafted the governments tortured definition of torture. Congress knew. This isn't some off the books CIA wet team opp. It was planned and signed off at the highest levels. John Yoo, who wrote the torture memos, is a pr…

The fact that "24" with Jack Bauer routinely using torture ran for eight years with high ratings surely reflected the US public's tacit approval.

I don't think you can sensibly infer anything of the sort from television ratings.

As I recall, The Sopranos, Breaking Bad and Dexter all rated pretty well too.

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The prestige hit and vulnerability to "letting down the troops" criticisms will ensure this doesn't happen.

The real reason is that they were carrying out the official policy of the US government. Just calling it CIA torture is minimizing how far up this went. Bush ordered it. DOD knew. DOJ not only knew, it crafted the governments tortured definition of torture. Congress knew. This isn't some off the books CIA wet team opp. It was planned and signed off at the highest levels. John Yoo, who wrote the torture memos, is a pr…

According to this study, the public did not support torture: http://academic.reed.edu/poli_sci/faculty/rejali/articles/us...

Also, I don't think election votes can ever count as approval; Congress has approval ratings nearing single digits yet incumbents usually get re-elected.

> The public supported it directly. We've known for a long what was going on.

We know what goes on in North Korea too but that doesn't mean we approve.

And the US is under ubiquitous NSA surveillance, along with domestic propaganda now legalized. Given this, I think the US people are, if anything, being subjugated by the government, not conspiring with it.

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#29
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The real reason is that they were carrying out the official policy of the US government. Just calling it CIA torture is minimizing how far up this went. Bush ordered it. DOD knew. DOJ not only knew, it crafted the governments tortured definition of torture. Congress knew. This isn't some off the books CIA wet team opp. It was planned and signed off at the highest levels. John Yoo, who wrote the torture memos, is a pr…

The fact that "24" with Jack Bauer routinely using torture ran for eight years with high ratings surely reflected the US public's tacit approval.

24 is a terrifically evil show and helped sell torture by showing Jack routinely torture people and get the right actionable information every time without any ramifications.

Re: CIA agents who tortured are vulnerable to prosecution in any country

#30
post #29
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The fact that "24" with Jack Bauer routinely using torture ran for eight years with high ratings surely reflected the US public's tacit approval.

24 is a terrifically evil show and helped sell torture by showing Jack routinely torture people and get the right actionable information every time without any ramifications.

That always ruined shows for me. They punch someone, they say nothing. They punch them again, and they immediately give them the truth and stop the torture. But they can't check the truth for quite a while, possibly not without killing or letting the suspect go.
Post reply on HN