Live data from Hacker News

Piratebay strikes back

blog.brokep.com

21–30 of 106 posts

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#21
post #12

BREIN is the organisation that puts inane 'Downloading is theft' (which it a simple lie, as any lawyer can tell you) commercials at the start of movies in the cinema and on DVD - not possible to skip them of course! Talking down to their paying public like they do, it's like they really WANT people to stop paying for movies and pirate them.

Agreed. Not being able to skip that (and other) crap on DVDs is infuriating! It's really one of my pet peeves.

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#22
post #5

To be honest, I hope these guys are going to jail. You must be a fool to believe that they don't own the pirate bay anymore, or are not associated with the keyman islands shell company running the company. Alone mininova disclosed making > 1 million of profit a year, piratebay's profit must be much bigger, all from the copyrighted works of others. Most of you wouldn't support piratebay anymore if your program/source…

I think it would more apt if both sides go to jail, neither is the answer to the future of artistic works. On one side a bunch of cartels that IMO should be investigated by the monopolies and mergers commission and on the other freetards that don't provide a realistic revenue model for artists.

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#23
post #13

I'm happy for the guys behind pirate bay they are making a killing, every time an article like this crops up on pages like this or digg/reddit its more marketing. start-ups take note- controversial is king!

Is there actually controversy here? I thought that the anti-piracy boys had more or less entrenched themselves as antagonists in the public mindset.

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#24
post #13

I'm happy for the guys behind pirate bay they are making a killing, every time an article like this crops up on pages like this or digg/reddit its more marketing. start-ups take note- controversial is king!

Is there actually controversy here? I thought that the anti-piracy boys had more or less entrenched themselves as antagonists in the public mindset.

look at it from both sides- wouldnt be in court if it wasnt controversial

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#25
post #5

To be honest, I hope these guys are going to jail. You must be a fool to believe that they don't own the pirate bay anymore, or are not associated with the keyman islands shell company running the company. Alone mininova disclosed making > 1 million of profit a year, piratebay's profit must be much bigger, all from the copyrighted works of others. Most of you wouldn't support piratebay anymore if your program/source…

I'm disappointed they are gone. I used the Pirate Bay as my primary tracker for distributing my music free of charge.

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#27
post #21
post #12

BREIN is the organisation that puts inane 'Downloading is theft' (which it a simple lie, as any lawyer can tell you) commercials at the start of movies in the cinema and on DVD - not possible to skip them of course! Talking down to their paying public like they do, it's like they really WANT people to stop paying for movies and pirate them.

Agreed. Not being able to skip that (and other) crap on DVDs is infuriating! It's really one of my pet peeves.

If you don't mind using a PC as a DVD player, AnyDvd strips all that stuff out (along with region coding and most other DRM)

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#28
post #11
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

except that source code couldn't possibly show on piratebay.

Of course it could. You/your svn/ftp could be hacked, your code could be decompiled...

he means in a purely technical sense it would "show" on TPB - they just host the torrent not the content.

It was, I think, a distinction.

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#29
post #12

BREIN is the organisation that puts inane 'Downloading is theft' (which it a simple lie, as any lawyer can tell you) commercials at the start of movies in the cinema and on DVD - not possible to skip them of course! Talking down to their paying public like they do, it's like they really WANT people to stop paying for movies and pirate them.

as any lawyer can tell you

As a point of order they would almost certainly tell you it a) depends on the country, b) has been untested in the majority of countries so it is neither right nor wrong and anyway it probably would count as theft in a civil case sense.

However I agree BREIN are a bit crazy - and the video they add to DVD's is inane.

On the other hand better that than suing individuals I suppose :D (even though that happens too :()

Re: Piratebay strikes back

#30
post #5

To be honest, I hope these guys are going to jail. You must be a fool to believe that they don't own the pirate bay anymore, or are not associated with the keyman islands shell company running the company. Alone mininova disclosed making > 1 million of profit a year, piratebay's profit must be much bigger, all from the copyrighted works of others. Most of you wouldn't support piratebay anymore if your program/source…

I think it would more apt if both sides go to jail, neither is the answer to the future of artistic works. On one side a bunch of cartels that IMO should be investigated by the monopolies and mergers commission and on the other freetards that don't provide a realistic revenue model for artists.

The pirates aren't freetards. I resent your accusation.

The current model isn't working if it's so easily subverted. The solution is to figure out a model that's pirate-proof. They exist.

Post reply on HN