Live data from Hacker News

How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

financejobs.co

81–90 of 143 posts

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#81
post #66

Having hired a lot of quants and programmers in finance I can probably give a bit of background on what to expect: Get this book, read it and understand it. http://www.amazon.com/Heard-Street-Quantitative-Questions-In... Quants tend to be in 1 of 3 categories: 1) pricing quants, you work for a bank or investment house like Goldamn. You know stochastic calculus very well, you know finite differencing like the back of…

This article and discussion are quite timely for me, as I was recently offered a position as a "quant analyst" at a derivatives arbitrage firm -- from what I understand, similar to 3). My other two options are working at an ambitious new robotics startup, and a PhD in deep learning. I have a few questions: 1) What would you say is a reasonable salary range for someone with a master's degree in computer engineering an…

To be clear, I'm an engineering whose moved into the quantitative side, but am really poor at stochastic calculus, I haven't used it in 5 years. I wouldn't get a pricing job at a top their Investment house:) So I can't speak for the kind of quant job that most people consider to be the typical quant job.

Off the top of my head...

> 1) What would you say is a reasonable salary range for someone with a master's degree in computer engineering and a year of experience in back office, as well as an assortment of ML side projects? How high could you expect it to be in 2, 5, 10 years?

First off your education counts for nothing when negotiating salary. If you can do the job, you get the salary for the job. Some people really have a tough time of letting go of this. I don't care if you have Phd or are a high school drop out, you get paid based on performance and role.

In Toronto, starting $100,000 with raise to 200,000 at the high end in 10 years.

Bonus is 0 - 2x that, expect about 0.75 . Alot of that would be based on the firms record and not your own. It doesn't sound like you'd be actually making money so you have a chance to be higher if you develop trading strategies.

That's great money but not the kind of money some people think. You don't get huge bonuses until you, yourself, produce even larger profits.

> 2) Is it very difficult to break into the industry? This opportunity just landed in my lap (recruiter), and I'd like to know how likely it is that I'll find something like it again

Connections really help. A Phd really helps. Writing a piece of open source software that a firm uses really helps, Writing a paper that the firm uses really helps. Jobs can be hard to come by as the industry is pretty incestuous. People move around alot and that means someone trying to break in has to answer the question of why hire you instead of the guy whose done this for 10 years and I know everyone he's worked for.

> 3) Will a PhD in machine learning (and the resulting five year gap in the industry) make me more or less employable? How will it affect my salary/job opportunities?

If its for pricing, it probably won't help at all. If its a HFT then it helps.

Machine learning is used alot less than people think at most funds. Alot of people are under the assumption that you can just apply some machine learning to the market and make money, it just isn't possible for most people. There are just too many factors that can affect the price of a stock.

how do you model panic? Consumer confidence? Russia invading the Ukraine? OPEC selling oil below $80 a barrel? The US invading Iraq?

All of these affect the price of stocks, and its often modeled as an additional fudge parameter, that is positive or negative according to the whims of the modeler on that particular day, in other words, its a hack in the greatest sense:)

4) Just how much of the job is reading and implementing machine learning papers, and how much of it is general software engineering?

A lot less than you'd like. a ratio of 10:1 plumbing vs paper implementation is about what I do and I get to chose what i do:( If you think about it, the algorithm is small compared to the surrounding code you need just to get an order out the door.

Back testing can be 3 weeks out of 4 sometimes because for every idea you have that succeeds, you'll have 10 that fail at some level.

> 5) Where can you derive meaning and satisfaction from a job in quantitative finance? How do you reconcile the opportunity cost to society from not working on directly socially beneficial applications in fields like medicine and artificial intelligence?

Not touching this question with a 10 foot pole. I know I'm really excited for Monday mornings, others might not be.

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#82
post #44

I got an applied math Ph.D. with a good course in measure theory and stochastic processes from a star student of E. Cinlar and a lot in optimization, wrote my dissertation on stochastic optimal control, had a solid background in software, especially in scientific computing, including a lot of applied statistics, sent a resume to Fisher Black at Goldman Sachs, and still have his nice answer back that he saw no opportu…

Hey, I wanted to send you a message but your profile has no email. Can you send me a message or put an email in your profile? Thanks.

How do I send you a message?

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#83
post #66

Having hired a lot of quants and programmers in finance I can probably give a bit of background on what to expect: Get this book, read it and understand it. http://www.amazon.com/Heard-Street-Quantitative-Questions-In... Quants tend to be in 1 of 3 categories: 1) pricing quants, you work for a bank or investment house like Goldamn. You know stochastic calculus very well, you know finite differencing like the back of…

This article and discussion are quite timely for me, as I was recently offered a position as a "quant analyst" at a derivatives arbitrage firm -- from what I understand, similar to 3). My other two options are working at an ambitious new robotics startup, and a PhD in deep learning. I have a few questions: 1) What would you say is a reasonable salary range for someone with a master's degree in computer engineering an…

> 5) Where can you derive meaning and satisfaction from a job in quantitative finance? How do you reconcile the opportunity cost to society from not working on directly socially beneficial applications in fields like medicine and artificial intelligence?

If this is a strong concern of yours you should probably go with one of the other two options. There's opportunities to make money in many industries. You might not end up with as high as a net worth as you would've if you went into quantitative finance, but that's not an absolute rule and you'll more likely burn out if you don't find satisfaction in your job. This isn't a dig towards anyone that is in the finance industry and enjoys their job, but it's common for people to end up quitting from dissatisfaction/work conditions.

Besides that, a robotics startup sounds pretty exciting.

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you give an example or two of the more complex issues you deal with? I honestly have no idea.

Can't be too specific, but I often need to solve differential equations, find closed form solutions to some integrals (mathematica helps but is often not sufficient), build models which strike a good balance between realism and tractability. Find which properties are important to preserve in models and which aren't, etc. chollida1's comment is spot on and I oscillate between 1 and 2.

None of these have any similarity to brainteasers. In fact, these are all excellent subjects on their own that could be tested directly. For example:

"Give me an overview of a numerical method used to solve differential equations."

The more time you spend asking brainteasers, the less time you have to devote to your actual skills of interest. You may even find that quizzing someone on mathematics may help refresh and solidify your own understanding.

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#85
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When was this?

Long time ago, e.g., Fisher Black was still alive (maybe he's not now). I hadn't yet heard of James Simons. The rumor I heard was that Simons liked to hire mathematical physicists from Russia. I had no way to go to Wall Street and already know all about everything they they were doing. The martgingale convergence theorem, measurable selection, power spectral estimation, sure, all about Wall Street, no. When I was in…

Sounds like you'd have been a much better fit for Renaissance Technologies than Goldman.

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#86
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can't be too specific, but I often need to solve differential equations, find closed form solutions to some integrals (mathematica helps but is often not sufficient), build models which strike a good balance between realism and tractability. Find which properties are important to preserve in models and which aren't, etc. chollida1's comment is spot on and I oscillate between 1 and 2.

None of these have any similarity to brainteasers. In fact, these are all excellent subjects on their own that could be tested directly. For example: "Give me an overview of a numerical method used to solve differential equations." The more time you spend asking brainteasers, the less time you have to devote to your actual skills of interest. You may even find that quizzing someone on mathematics may help refresh and…

Do you have experience interviewing candidates?

Many candidates will answer this question correctly and yet be totally unable to do anything when they're confronted with a non textbook case. To be clear the brain teasers I ask are mathematical problems, not the type of brain teasers used in consulting interviews. For instance:

We play a game where we each draw a secret random number uniformly between 0 and 1. We each may re-throw if dissatisfied with our first throw, or me may keep it. We do not know whether or not the other has chosen to re-throw. We then compare our results and he who holds largest number wins $1. What is the best strategy to follow?

That's the type of brainteaser I'd ask. It's accessible to a good high school student. I interviewed a PhD candidate in applied mathematics from a top Ivy league university who:

- wouldn't believe that maximizing the expected value of the number obtained wasn't optimal until shown an explicit counterexample

- was unable to write the equations properly or model the problem

- was unable to solve the equations after I handed them out to them

He was however able to talk about his thesis work. Your questions wouldn't have caught that at all. His thesis work was in game theory.

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#87
post #17
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's the perfect market at work, I tell you. The private industry can do no wrong because then people would stop investing in the company and/or stop buying their services. /s

I don't see why the sarcasm. Hedge funds are not banks; they live or die by the brains of the people they hire. If they perform well, they get more investors. If they fail to perform, they go bust, and noone is there to bail them out.

The sarcasm's there because the market clearly doesn't work as it should here, just as it doesn't work in many other industries. The free market works for commodities trading, but not much else.

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#88

Having hired a lot of quants and programmers in finance I can probably give a bit of background on what to expect: Get this book, read it and understand it. http://www.amazon.com/Heard-Street-Quantitative-Questions-In... Quants tend to be in 1 of 3 categories: 1) pricing quants, you work for a bank or investment house like Goldamn. You know stochastic calculus very well, you know finite differencing like the back of…

>someone asked if you can do these without a math degree. The short answer is probably not. YOu'll need a math, engineering, or physics degree, unless you really are driven to learn hte math yourself.

This is interesting, but I have a slightly different interpretation of the question: Assuming you _can_ learn the math yourself, will anybody believe you? Is the degree necessary, if only for pedigree purposes?

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#89

Having hired a lot of quants and programmers in finance I can probably give a bit of background on what to expect: Get this book, read it and understand it. http://www.amazon.com/Heard-Street-Quantitative-Questions-In... Quants tend to be in 1 of 3 categories: 1) pricing quants, you work for a bank or investment house like Goldamn. You know stochastic calculus very well, you know finite differencing like the back of…

Thanks, great information. I'm a software developer, and I have worked for a long time in the telecom/mobile/VoIP sector. Half a year ago I switched to SW development in the financial world (not quant though). I am currently halfway through a really excellent book aimed at technical people moving into finance (quant or otherwise). It's called The Complete Guide to Capital Markets for Quantitative Professionals" [0] (yes, I know, no prize for imaginative title).

So far, it's been a fantastic read. Detailed, good information, and very well written. I saw the recommendation for the "Heard on the Street" book. I was wondering if people can recommend some other books for moving into finance?

[0] http://www.amazon.com/Complete-Quantitative-Professionals-Mc...

Re: How to Get a Quant Job in Finance

#90

Having hired a lot of quants and programmers in finance I can probably give a bit of background on what to expect: Get this book, read it and understand it. http://www.amazon.com/Heard-Street-Quantitative-Questions-In... Quants tend to be in 1 of 3 categories: 1) pricing quants, you work for a bank or investment house like Goldamn. You know stochastic calculus very well, you know finite differencing like the back of…

I'm in university for engineering right now, and this is an industry that I have been considering going into when I get out of school. What are things I can be learning/studying/reading/doing in the interim to give myself a head start?

I am already a good programmer and my mathematics ability is not lacking. My weakest point is probably finance, as I only have a rudimentary understanding of economics.

Post reply on HN