Live data from Hacker News

Wire – Modern Communications Network

wire.com

31–40 of 411 posts

Re: Wire – Modern Communications Network

#31

"What we need is another messaging app" said nobody, ever. It looks pretty, but this is yet another app in the long list of "Skype killers" or "Voice/video/text" messaging. It seems like it's the default goto for anyone that can't think of something more interesting these days.

Agreed. What we need is a protocol people can make clients for. With end to end encryption and PFS, of course.

That's what Tox is aiming for.

http://tox.im/

Re: Wire – Modern Communications Network

#33

"What we need is another messaging app" said nobody, ever. It looks pretty, but this is yet another app in the long list of "Skype killers" or "Voice/video/text" messaging. It seems like it's the default goto for anyone that can't think of something more interesting these days.

We didn't need yet another IRC clone, and yet Slack seems to be cleaning up.

The core value prop of the internet is easy communication. Don't be surprised when people continue to iterate on it.

Re: Wire – Modern Communications Network

#34

"What we need is another messaging app" said nobody, ever. It looks pretty, but this is yet another app in the long list of "Skype killers" or "Voice/video/text" messaging. It seems like it's the default goto for anyone that can't think of something more interesting these days.

I really disagree. There's simply no good secure cross-platform messaging app available. Telegram has fantastic clients on all the platforms, but isn't secure. TextSecure is secure, but has only a mediocre app on a single platform (Android). The other alternatives are even worse. Tox is looking really promising though: https://wiki.tox.im/FAQ

What about Threema? (https://threema.ch/en)

Re: Wire – Modern Communications Network

#35
post #9

Hmm, no Linux client ... and you 'have' to set a picture when you register? Really? I'm out.

No OSX Lion compatibility too. And they've put it on App Store as if it's the only way to distribute it. Looks like a BS.

Not many people seem to use Lion these days though. An app that I work on has less than 6% (of the 13,000 users who have opted in to providing system stats) on Lion.

Re: Wire – Modern Communications Network

#36
If they put "win client coming soon, sign up for updates" to get how many people even want it, that would be at least something. But this "only ios and android" philosophy, i just don't get it. What kind of smart business decision has to be to rule out 80-90% of users!?

Re: Wire – Modern Communications Network

#37
post #11

Skype has video chat. So far Wire only has audio. Skype can call a regular phone or receive calls from a regular phone. It seems like Wire can't, yet. Skype has all my contacts, Wire has none, yet. Let's call it a Skype killer if it kills Skype. Not yet.

+1 totally agreed
Post reply on HN