Live data from Hacker News

This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

gizmodo.com

51–60 of 69 posts

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#51
post #49

I don't get how this is going to replace photoshop. The images will not look as good, or as clean as a regular photoshopped image, I doubt that automated image editing is that advanced right now. The examples they gave, is probably the best that was available, I bet on average, the results don't look nearly as good or clean. But hey, I could be wrong.

photoshop + 24hours of work = awesome image

photoshop + 1h of work = worthless image

this snake oil thing + 1h of work = so-so usable image

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#52

Sigh...third time today and I only got one karma point for pointing it first. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=862216 if you feel sympathetic :) EDIT: gee guys, the smiley should tell you this ^ is not a serious complaint. I thought people might actually be interested in reading the actual paper v, since project page link has been inaccessible. Sheesh. Site is down but this is the Siggraph paper: http://www.ece.nu…

> the smiley should tell you this ^ is not a serious complaint.

Then why put the link at all?

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#53
post #9
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree... But they have the source available if you can get to the site. Otherwise, here's the Google cache link: http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:http://cg.cs.tsinghua.ed...

The download doesn't include source. It does include 5 executables totaling ~140k. I am not quite brave enough to run them but I did run them through strings, and a cursory inspection suggests either that they're either attempting to do what they're claimed to do or they're the best disguised malware in history.

So gentlemen our plan is simple. We study computer graphics for 10years, get PhDs, develop a system that gets headlined at siggraph, become famous and - then we release a binary that the HN readers will download.

World domination is in our sights

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#54
post #49

I don't get how this is going to replace photoshop. The images will not look as good, or as clean as a regular photoshopped image, I doubt that automated image editing is that advanced right now. The examples they gave, is probably the best that was available, I bet on average, the results don't look nearly as good or clean. But hey, I could be wrong.

Good enough for display on TV news or a newspaper ?

Get me a picture of the president, put a girl in a red dress in his eye-line. Get me a picture of evil dictator - add some WMD in the background.

At the moment you need an intern to do this be much better when you can do it yourself.

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#55

Sigh...third time today and I only got one karma point for pointing it first. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=862216 if you feel sympathetic :) EDIT: gee guys, the smiley should tell you this ^ is not a serious complaint. I thought people might actually be interested in reading the actual paper v, since project page link has been inaccessible. Sheesh. Site is down but this is the Siggraph paper: http://www.ece.nu…

> the smiley should tell you this ^ is not a serious complaint. Then why put the link at all?

because it's useful?

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#56

Sigh...third time today and I only got one karma point for pointing it first. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=862216 if you feel sympathetic :) EDIT: gee guys, the smiley should tell you this ^ is not a serious complaint. I thought people might actually be interested in reading the actual paper v, since project page link has been inaccessible. Sheesh. Site is down but this is the Siggraph paper: http://www.ece.nu…

In today's hypercompetitive world, branding is key. Compare: "Photorealistic image composition from simple sketches" vs. "This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch" Which one would you rather click on?

The one that isn't a PDF.

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#57
post #16
post #2

I'm having a very hard time believing that this is real. If it is, they have just made breakthroughs in multiple domains in computer graphics, recognition, and composition at the same time. Here's hoping it's real.

Surprisingly, not really. Computer vision has been moving along lately. This is good stuff, but incremental progress against the backdrop of other good stuff in the field. A few times in the past few months the question of whether "all the good stuff" has been discovered or whether there's no progress left to be made came up, and computer vision has been one of my go-to examples of a field that has just been booming…

When I took an AI class back in University, the professor noted that the term AI is usually only applied to the problems we can't solve. As soon as we determine an algorithm for something, they no longer call it AI.

So technically, it was a Data Mining class I guess.

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#58

Sigh...third time today and I only got one karma point for pointing it first. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=862216 if you feel sympathetic :) EDIT: gee guys, the smiley should tell you this ^ is not a serious complaint. I thought people might actually be interested in reading the actual paper v, since project page link has been inaccessible. Sheesh. Site is down but this is the Siggraph paper: http://www.ece.nu…

In today's hypercompetitive world, branding is key. Compare: "Photorealistic image composition from simple sketches" vs. "This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch" Which one would you rather click on?

And some one said HN doesn't accept sensational headings.

PS: It was in the days I started here. Fair enough, it has been a while.

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We've been seeing some pretty fascinating developments in graphics and pattern recognition recently. A few days ago someone submitted that amazing Photoshop plugin that allows you to select a region and move it around seamlessly, and also fill in areas seamlessly. The demo showed the software filling in the broken areas of the Pantheon and the results were quite impressive. A combination of both technologies would be…

Just FYI, that stuff to which you refer is a teaser for CS5, the next iteration of Photoshop...due around April, most likely.

The SIGGRAPH presentation video for this is here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dgKjs8ZjQNg

Re: This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch

#60

Hey, this is the technology from Wag The Dog. De Niros character is a Hollywood producer, hired to produce a fake war in Albania to distract from a sex scandal before an election. At one point, he's directing news footage by shouting something like "there's a girl in front of a village, it's on fire .. hmm, no, more smoke.. her hair is too light. Can she have a cat? Show me cats" while having a technician type in the…

Ha, true. FWIW, though, the character you're describing is played by Dustin Hoffman. Awesome movie, though.
Post reply on HN