Live data from Hacker News

Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

app.getflowmeter.com

11–20 of 74 posts

Re: Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

#11
I have a separate local user account on my computer for work. When I start work in the morning, I switch to the work user and all of my personal stuff goes away. When I'm done with work at night, I switch back, all my personal stuff comes back and work goes away. It's almost like having a separate computer.

People often look at me like I'm crazy when I tell them this. I haven't quite figured out why.

If I need to look up some personal thing in the middle of the day, I reach for my phone. If I find I've been reaching for my phone too much that day, I get up and put it on the other side of the room. Now every would-be distraction requires me to physically move my entire body.

Re: Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

#13
post #9

The author may be on to something with the line "A popup notification that runs without concern for what the user is doing is hostile behavior. Notice how there's no API in any OS for "is now a good time to interrupt the user?". Maybe there should be." Notifications could be deferred while the user is actively typing. When the user goes idle, deferred notifications can be displayed. This becomes more important as mor…

I'd like to point out that even if a user goes idle, it might still be a bad time to display notifications. What if a developer is working on a hard problem, and pauses for a while to think about the problem, maybe doodle on a whiteboard/paper, etc.? This could actually be the most damaging time to display a distraction to the developer. The solution to this kind of problem would likely need to be slightly different,…

There are already problems with the assumption (user idle=nothing important happens).

Namely I'm trying to watch a movie and screen goes black after 30 minutes (yes I know how to configure this, just an example).

Re: Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

#14
Computers are designed for open-ended productivity, where the assumption by the computer operating system designers is that they don't really know what users want to do, but will give them the option anyway.

Computers don't do anything without computer Programmers. It is the user which makes things 'productive', where 'productive' is entirely up to the users' free will to decide to use the computer to do something.

A full-screen app at the checkout window is quite productive. This is still a computer. Its just that the Programmer has done the job of making the user attracted to the device, for the purposes of doing some job. Its the same with massive open-ended cornucopia-style operating systems that give you all the power in the world, and a bundled card game.

Either way, no matter what, its the user which makes productivity occur.

Re: Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

#15

I have a separate local user account on my computer for work. When I start work in the morning, I switch to the work user and all of my personal stuff goes away. When I'm done with work at night, I switch back, all my personal stuff comes back and work goes away. It's almost like having a separate computer. People often look at me like I'm crazy when I tell them this. I haven't quite figured out why. If I need to loo…

For me it involves like 10 keystrokes.

Ctrl+Shift+N -> "new" -> select auto complete to hacker news -> enter.

This place can suck my whole day away, and because I'm a web developer and work in the browser constantly, there's no easy way to dodge it.

I can do things like blocking dns lookups or browser extensions but then I outsmart myself.

Re: Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

#17
I've come to similar realizations during my programming career, and realized the value of simple mindfulness in all tasks, especially while communicating to those around you. I've found simple mindfulness to be like a superpower in our age of constant notifications and hundreds of tabs. I even try to force myself to be mindful while checking my email by dealing with a single email at a time (thanks to Mailbox app), and consciously delegating emails and tasks to a particular time if I'm unable to deal with it immediately. In my experience, multitasking is a sleep depriving, mentally taxing, stress inducing, debilitating activity which only reduces quality of life from every conceivable angle, and hurts productivity in general.

It all boils down to one thing: have a single conscious intention when doing something. This takes practice, but eventually you can do it for anything and everything. I've found this can even make routines like brushing your teeth very enjoyable and meaningful (see here: http://www.fastcompany.com/3036363/how-to-be-a-success-at-ev...)

Also, there is a clear rebounding shift towards desktop computers being serious work tools, as opposed to consumption devices, which is what mobiles and tablets are for. This is undoubtedly a trend that is already happening, and I think that OS and software designers need to respect that. It is an unfair, deadly sabotage to mobilify desktops while upsetting the highly focused workflows of programmers, graphic designers, architects, writers, business managers, video editors, students and academic researchers just to pander to a generation of ADHD social network addicts (I'm looking at you Windows 8).

As for people arguing that you simply need self-control and discipline, they are kidding themselves. Focus and concentration are extremely delicate things to create and preserve, and it is a designers responsibility to make products easier for their intended purpose, not simply demand "self control" from their users.

Re: Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

#18
post #5

I have a Linux laptop on which I run a tiling window manager (in my case, Xmonad), and nothing else. No system tray, no quick launch bar, nothing. (if you're not familiar with tiling window managers, they're window managers in which windows are arranged automatically to a) fully occupy the screen and b) never overlap. They're extremely customizable, but typically you'll have a vertical half of your screen with a main…

Came here to say this. Normal window managers are great for normal computers where you don't know whether it's going to be used to do graphic design, spreadsheets or whatever. But for IT people and especially programmers it is insane not to specialize your machine, to spend half of your mouse gestures on moving windows around, maximizing, minimizing, finding them in the clutter you are producing.

Re: Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity

#20
post #9

The author may be on to something with the line "A popup notification that runs without concern for what the user is doing is hostile behavior. Notice how there's no API in any OS for "is now a good time to interrupt the user?". Maybe there should be." Notifications could be deferred while the user is actively typing. When the user goes idle, deferred notifications can be displayed. This becomes more important as mor…

In Gnome 3 there's a nice notifications on/off button in the notifications tray. I like manual controls.
Post reply on HN