Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Echo

amazon.com

61–70 of 746 posts

Re: Amazon Echo

#61
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Absolute first thought was along similar lines. If it did all the processing locally and just fetched results I might be interested. But this? Not so much.

Why are you saying things you don't want the cloud to know about anyway?

Okay, give me your Facebook password please. Thanks in advance.

Re: Amazon Echo

#62
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Absolute first thought was along similar lines. If it did all the processing locally and just fetched results I might be interested. But this? Not so much.

Why are you saying things you don't want the cloud to know about anyway?

Are you trolling? Do you know nothing about privacy?

Re: Amazon Echo

#63
There might be some interest from the DIY people to hack the hardware/software. But I am not sure if there will be interest from general consumers for this product.

Re: Amazon Echo

#64
post #46

We've now got Microsoft (XBox One), Amazon (Echo), Google/Motorola (Moto X) and maybe others who want to place some kind of "always-on" microphone in our houses. They all say the same thing, sure - that the microphone won't be listening to your conversations, that it won't be sending the data to any other servers, etc. Do we believe them? And will they change those policies in the future? Do they even have real contr…

To be fair, the portable devices are not yet monitoring all conversations due to battery life constraints. If it were a wall powered device, I would be very wary of it, but until then it seems highly unlikely it can achieve that behavior and not drain the battery in a noticeable way.

Re: Amazon Echo

#65

Well that's an out-of-the-blue introduction. I'm increasingly unconvinced of the market for voice-driven devices (innate reluctance to talk when not to a person), but at a glance looks like this is as laudable an effort as can be attempted. At $199 it's too pricy for most, given the untested/unfamiliar niche. At $99 (select Prime members), some of is might give it a chance. I'm reminded that Apple started its move in…

Wouldn't consider it at $199, impulse buy at $99.

Seconded! I always expected my Nest thermostat and Nest protect smoke detectors to turn into Google Now endpoints, but Amazon beat them to it.

Just requested my Echo invite!

Re: Amazon Echo

#66

Well hang on - doesn't my iPhone already do all this? And presumably so does the Android equivalent? I appreciate this will have much better microphone technology but it still seems a little redundant.

A couple differentiators: -The speaker in Echo is presumably much better -The microphone in Echo is presumably much better -On most Android phones (I don't know about iPhone), you have to wake the phone up before you can talk to it

Re: Amazon Echo

#67
post #16

[deleted]

Probably because it does two things:

1. Positions this as a product that is for "normal" people, not the stereotypical silicon valley techie (a la Google Glass)

2. Makes it seem easy to use, the "even a little kid could use it" effect.

Re: Amazon Echo

#68

Can I change the wake word? Alexa was the name of a girl I once dated, and would prefer not to call out her name.

In the video, the dad says something along the lines of "We just have to say the wake word we choose."

Re: Amazon Echo

#69

This could be the natural next step for one click shopping. Obviously it'll be more difficult without textual or visual capabilities, but things like "Add gelato to my shopping cart "(as apposed to shopping list ) would be huge for Amazon fresh shoppers and other products that aren't too ambiguous. Another application: "Alexa, order a Dominoes pizza with extra anchovies. "

Since you mention fresh:

https://fresh.amazon.com/dash/

It still requires a jump to the pc to order; but no reason they couldn't add a way to initiate an order from it. It's also a tad less privacy intrusive then echo.

Re: Amazon Echo

#70

That was an incredibly painful video to watch, what's wrong with just demonstrating the product's features in home environments? Why do we need these ads that make it seem like this "is a real conversation happening in a family home".

This video was so over the top I had to check my calendar to make sure it wasn't April 1.

Alexa, is this a joke?

Post reply on HN