Earlier quoted context omitted.
This is a phenomenal reply tokenadult. Would you be willing to reply to the same question if I post it in http://writers.stackexchange.com/ ?
I'd have to register an account over there, but I could get ready for that while you post the question. Thanks for the suggestion. AFTER EDIT: I'm registered on Stack Exchange now. I refer in my user profile there to my Hacker News user I.D.
How do you get to write so well in HN?
21–30 of 110 posts
Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#22English is my second language and posting a comment on HN takes me five rewrites before clicking "add comment" and two+ edits after. Even then they don't necessarily come out all that clear judging by some of the responses I get. Maybe start a blog in English or hang out in IRC channels related to your interests?
Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#23Try summarising other people's texts - and don't just take each sentence separately and try to make it shorter, take all the ideas in the piece and experiment with reorganising them in your mind and then on the page to produce a more elegant and concise means of expressing them to your reader. Lots of the good HN writers you've noted see the short and compelling 'elevator pitch' that summarises months of work and aspiration as their greatest challenge. Politicians are always looking for the 10 word phrase that conveys the heart of their policy.
Read what you write back to yourself. Aloud. Good writing also tends to be 'performable' - no rambling subclauses to get lost in, no awkward word combinations that make the speaker (or listener, or reader) stumble and disengage. Be more Harrison Ford and less George Lucas (Han Solo said something like "You can write this stuff, George, but I can't say it")
And finally, do exactly what you've started here: Seek advice and feedback. This is a community that shares ideas, so dive in, but ask for comment on how you express them as well as their content. Grab a native speaker and check your idioms. Ask friends to point out the clunky sentences that lets down an otherwise good paragraph.
Good luck to you!
Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#24Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#25Also writing is an iterative process, at least when you are learning a foreign language. Write a paragraph, then stop and think: how can I express the same idea in a better way? Rewrite it until you cannot add or remove anything else. Then keep writing another paragraph. After several of them go back to the first ones and read them for yourself. They might not make sense anymore; so start again.
It's not simple and not everyone can make it. You have to aim for doing your best and stop any "it's good enough" thoughts that you might have. There will be a point when you don't need to rewrite it anymore; that's when you pick up a a new language (;
TL;DR:
1. Read 2. Write 3. Rewrite 4. GOTO 1
Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#26Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#27Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#28Read well-written copy, whether it is elaborate prose, wartime speeches, or clean and fresh ad copy. Analyse it. Emulate it.
Write first, then edit. Don't do both at the same time.
Read your old stuff and find flaws in it.
Shorten text. Shorter is almost always better.
Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#29There are plenty of pedantic people spending their time on forums who will naturally correct you if you make an error in your writing.
Writing a blog entry once a week and asking a friend or two to review the draft might be another way.
You're not doomed to anything if you take on a mindset where you believe that you can and will improve.
Re: How do you get to write so well in HN?
#30http://www.amazon.com/Writing-Well-30th-Anniversary-Edition/...
http://www.amazon.com/The-Curious-Case-Misplaced-Modifier/dp...