Live data from Hacker News

When Women Stopped Coding

npr.org

111–120 of 190 posts

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Regardless of the source of the comment, it would be interesting to have the source data to know exactly what they're classifying as "Computer Science" programs. That term has certainly increased in usage over the last several decades, and was not always in use in the decades prior to the 1980s. So what did the study use in its place? That's a valid question regardless of who raised it.

Sure, but "we don't know, therefore let's provisionally go the MRA's unsourced claims," is not a sound interim position.

As I said, it's an interesting question, regardless of the source.

So I went and looked it up, since that seemed more productive than fighting endlessly over it.

The NSF study helpfully includes an appendix that shows what fields they counted as "Computer Science", and it turns out that "Data Processing" and "Data Processing Technician" were indeed counted in that category.

Of course, that says nothing about the relative numbers and how they changed, but it does raise a possible explanation for the shift in numbers as Data Processing died out as a field.

http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf13327/pdf/tabb1.pdf

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#112
Wasn't the early-mid-80's when programming/computers held much of a social stigma (ie nerd, geek, etc were insults). The market followed that trend and instead of offering a computer as a consumer gender un-biased product, it was marketed at men.. But even then, if you look at ads from around that time for computers.. It's a computer. It's not something that you can assign a gender to in advertising very effectively. It's the social aspect surrounding computers that does that.

Also I disagree with what nathan_long said regarding "Women felt they must not be "naturally good" at computers, based on how men already knew more". To me that is absurd to assume that woman would think that "men know more than us, so why try"? His third point would be nullified by the associated social stigma during their teen years.

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#113

I am a female born in 1983 and have always been deeply interested in computers, but have nonetheless felt inexplicably out of place for it. I was in advanced math classes my entire life and placed out of calculus in college. I took a summer programming class at a different university in 2000 and fell in love with programming. But when I got back to school, I took another CS class that was exactly as described in this…

> have always been deeply interested in computers, but have nonetheless felt inexplicably out of place for it

You know what stopped me from becoming a professional programmer? It wasn't the fact that I didn't get to study CS in high-school, nor that I didn't have a PC until I was a university student, nor the lack of Internet access at home until I was 20+ years old, nor the language barrier (English is my third language), nor being limited to free resources by my finances.

Nothing. Nothing stopped me from pursuing my interest.

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#114
I had a very similar experience when I entered one of the best universities of Iran in 2000. Although the number of female students were almost as much as males, every professor assumed that students should at least know one programming language and be familiar with all the basic concepts of computers. and many students, especially female ones did not have that knowledge prior to university which was a great turn off as they realised they would be easily judged by their lack of knowledge. The sad thing is that all of these students were great in their high school in order to get in in the first place.

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#115

This story makes a compelling case that women stopped programming because - 1. Computers started being sold as consumer products - 2. They were marketed almost exclusively to boys - 3. Boys played with computers and learned about them, while girls were made to feel that computers weren't for them - 3. Men showed up to college with more computer experience - 4. Women felt they must not be "naturally good" at computers…

> We're missing out on talented developers.

As a sought after developer in a niche area I appreciate the lack of competition.

But then again I am a selfish, cynical bastard.

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#116
Romantic story telling for a line graph, but really it is more like the profession of computer operators, originally drawn from the largely female secretary pool, disappeared as computers evolved from big buildings where you submitted decks of punched cards to their modern form.

Nowadays we have IT, EE, CS, etc. but these are really different professions than what was originally mostly women. The first crop of nearest equivalent computer scientists usually majored in mechanical engineering, simply because there were no computer majors yet and the computers were much more mechanical, and had the same gender imbalance we see today.

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find this explanation extremely hollow. Most programmers didn't start programming when they were kids. They started when they realized it was a good paycheck.

Hmm.. I wonder if that's true of younger programmers, but I don't think I've met a single one around my age (early 30's, late 20's) who didn't start when they were young. I got my start near the end of high school and I felt _impossibly_ late. I still do, frankly.

I started when I was 21. So at least you can feel that you're better than me.

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#118
I don't think girls ever completely stopped to program, but for sure there are less girls in those kinds of subjects at higher education levels. But from my view, it all comes down to interest and I have no real explaination to why girls are less interested in computer science.

However, I can tell my story on how I got intersted and why I do not think girls at that age would have any issues having the same story.

I can only answer for my experience, but here it goes:

When I were younger (I'm still in my 20s) I started with computers and mainly to play computer games which I quickly realized was a lot of fun.

Later on, and surely labeled as a "nerd" by my fellow classmates (girls and boys) I started to take interest in cheating in games and wondered how the hell to do it. That made me walk out on the internet learning about how programs work in the first place and I discovered modding.

I understood that I can change the game data which was saved on my local hard drive in order to gain powers in the game. Cheating quickly became boring so I wanted to know how to mod a game so bosses would spawn more powerful to meet my newly crafted gear that could beat anything. So I started to mod the client with programs that were available on the net.

At this point, I barely understood all the english grammar that was used but the interest in learning on how the stuff works eventually led me to learning to program and awoken an interest I didn't even know existed. Previously to this, I had no idea how computers really worked like I had no idea how a car engine worked. I didn't examine this until I really wanted something done.

I am sure my story is like many stories in the early 00's of people who eventually learned to program. I don't think any girl that did the same during this period would have any specific attention except good ones. Maybe the girls in my school did not learn to program because they were less interested in games, maybe something else. But what I am totally conviced of, is that there were no sexism hindering these girls to learn if they wanted to. Actually, I would think that most boys would not care as much if a girl was as interested as me.

I were labeled a nerd (and had really no problems with it) but I do not think that a girl would be labeled the same. Of course there were girls labeled as nerds but not because they were interested in computers, but because they did "too much homework" or "took school too seriously". The funny thing is that I were not labeled as a nerd because of my interest in computers, I am pretty convinced that it was only because that I had a nerdy look and sat a lot in front of computers. In fact, most of them when I showed some tricks were actually impressed and had no issues with that. Children can't hate on something they do not understand and in my experience a kid always goes on the visual things or very basic information that they do understand (i.e. do too much homework / sit a lot in front of computers).

I am sure there are some sexism out there still, but in my experience the sexism has been reversed. I have always felt "second picked" or less important because of my gender. I don't understand why girls need "extra attention" regarding computer interest anymore and I actually think it's damaging for several reasons.

My question remains the same, why can't we just try to treat everyone equally?

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#119

This story makes a compelling case that women stopped programming because - 1. Computers started being sold as consumer products - 2. They were marketed almost exclusively to boys - 3. Boys played with computers and learned about them, while girls were made to feel that computers weren't for them - 3. Men showed up to college with more computer experience - 4. Women felt they must not be "naturally good" at computers…

"They were marketed almost exclusively to boys" You mean exactly like chemistry sets? Yet chemistry is the most equal major in terms of gender of graduates. I like Planet Money, but this story is unconvincing.

I don't have data on this, but I'd imagine the popularity of computers in the home in the 1980s was outshining that of chemistry sets. In the NPR piece they talk about how computers were marketed to boys for playing games.

And chemistry is also taught in high schools, so both male and female students interested in it would've had some experience before attending college. The same is not true for computing.

Re: When Women Stopped Coding

#120

I am a female born in 1983 and have always been deeply interested in computers, but have nonetheless felt inexplicably out of place for it. I was in advanced math classes my entire life and placed out of calculus in college. I took a summer programming class at a different university in 2000 and fell in love with programming. But when I got back to school, I took another CS class that was exactly as described in this…

If you really love programming, it does not matter what other people do. You learn more alone in front of a computer, solving things, than in a classroom. Youn do not need a degree to hack.
Post reply on HN