Live data from Hacker News

Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

tsu.co

41–50 of 73 posts

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#41
post #37

Why can't I just give you money for a service. I don't want ads. I don't want you to give me ad revenue. Just take my money and respect my privacy. Is that really so much to ask. I will happily pay someone a yearly subscription for a simple social network that respects users privacy.

http://app.net

Can I pay my friends to switch?

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#42
post #32

not going to work, checkout Marc Andreessen's take on his own version of the same concept: Ning. Edit: typo Xing Ning

I think you meant Ning [1]. Xing [2] is the German LinkedIn. [1] http://www.ning.com [2] https://www.xing.com

I really don't see any correlation at all, except doing some advertising for ning.com...

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#43

The more I've played with various ways to share revenue with or create economic opportunity for users, the more I've realized that people just don't care about the money. There are of course some notable exceptions to this (Uber, eBay etc), but generally users have jobs and a few extra dollars just isn't enough to motivate them to change a single behavior.

I fully agree. Social networks have the chicken and egg problem of users only using already established networks, though. Tsu.co's way of incentivizing content production could be a way to solve that.

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#44

Why can't I just give you money for a service. I don't want ads. I don't want you to give me ad revenue. Just take my money and respect my privacy. Is that really so much to ask. I will happily pay someone a yearly subscription for a simple social network that respects users privacy.

Network effect would kill a paid social network. Very few people would use it when there are so many free alternatives.

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#45
post #40

Yet another centralized initiative? Every new initiative is good if it brings new ideas. But sadly, most new social networks we see try to convince people that Facebook is bad (ads, privacy concerns, etc) instead of convincing them that the new thing is good. IMO, this is backwards. I have never heard someone tell me "Facebook should share revenue with us". I mean come on: Facebook hosts servers, creates tons of jobs…

Sure thing Facebook has nice servers architecture and most brilliant engineers, but does FB creates any content? That's just a website, an empty shell where people upload content. And FB gets 100% of ads revenue, generated by others' content. Look at content creators like The New York Times's website, they get money through ads by attracting people thanks to their article. Plus you give up all of your rights and privacy, in exchange of a free service. I think the idea is not to "start paying users", but creating a fair platform.

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#46
post #26

A lot of for-profit companies have referral programs (which is what this amounts to), and many of them have a similar multilevel marketing component. So this isn't really anything new or novel. What I would love to see is an social-media site that is willing to take the concept of sharing profits with its members to the next level and organize itself as a cooperative. Co-ops, unlike for-profit companies, are entirely…

check out http://www.favorsome.com/, you may find what you're looking for

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#47

The more I've played with various ways to share revenue with or create economic opportunity for users, the more I've realized that people just don't care about the money. There are of course some notable exceptions to this (Uber, eBay etc), but generally users have jobs and a few extra dollars just isn't enough to motivate them to change a single behavior.

People had jobs before doing youtube videos for a living.

I don't think Tsu should be seen as a way to make money (at least not in a near future) but as a way to get rewarded for the content you produce. The same content which makes the value of Tsu. Take Instagram for example, talented people post beautiful pictures which add value to Instagram. And yet they only are rewarded with likes/comments. Tsu tries to fix this.

Re: Tsū: A social network that shares its advertising revenue with its users

#49
post #26

A lot of for-profit companies have referral programs (which is what this amounts to), and many of them have a similar multilevel marketing component. So this isn't really anything new or novel. What I would love to see is an social-media site that is willing to take the concept of sharing profits with its members to the next level and organize itself as a cooperative. Co-ops, unlike for-profit companies, are entirely…

check out http://www.favorsome.com/ , you may find what you're looking for

I don't see how that's at all relevant to what I was talking about. Favorsome doesn't appear to be a co-op, or anything like one. By the way, I see your only other HN activity is also plugging Favorsome. Kinda spammy?
Post reply on HN