Live data from Hacker News

Introducing GIFV

imgur.com

31–40 of 205 posts

Re: Introducing GIFV

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would say that Gfycat and Mediacru.sh are actually the leading competitors in this area.

Is Mediacru.sh banned from Reddit? I just saw a thread the other day where someone said the domain was blocked by admins to prevent it from competing with their preferred service (probably Gfycat).

mediacru.sh admin here. We used to be banned, many months ago. I was talking about our past troubles in that thread.

Re: Introducing GIFV

#33
post #15

I dont get the trick.Is it gif or a h264 video inside a "gif" container? looking at the source code,I see a video tag.

It's a video served with the video/mp4 content-type, using the .gifv file extension.

(Well, actually, the .gifv is just a web page that holds the tags for the mp4, but...)

Re: Introducing GIFV

#35
As someone who runs a website with something similar, I'm hoping that Imgur is big enough to push for some open standards around this. I want embedding video to become as commonplace as embedding GIFs.

Re: Introducing GIFV

#36

I don't know if its just me, but the GIFVs embedded on the page dont load for me, unless I click on them to open them in a page on their own, and the second one doesn't play even in this case. Firefox 32.0.3 on Linux

Same. FireFox 32.0.3 OS X

Re: Introducing GIFV

#37

an animated gif is not necessarily a video clip, but it seems that i'm in the minority these days. here's a gif by nicolas sassoon, which format would you prefer? http://i.imgur.com/fv0qgkc.gif (1.3 MB) or http://i.imgur.com/fv0qgkc.gifv (3.9 MB)

Wow, the colors are just gutted in the mp4 version.

Re: Introducing GIFV

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That site actually uses the superior VP8 compression format in a WebM container.

Superior in what sense? Not quality or file size.

Well, it's patents are free to licence and with open source code, so it's superior in a way that for many (me included) believe trump the others.

Re: Introducing GIFV

#39
post #22

"With all these improvements, Imgur will now denote converted MP4s with a .gifv extension. The intention is to signal to users throughout the Internet that these links will feature a GIF experience that incorporates all the current and future enhancements made through Project GIFV. Imgur plans to submit an accompanying specification to relevant standards organizations before the end of the year." This is bizarre. GIF…

No, probably not anyone who is reading hackernews, but imgur has a much wider audience.

GIFV will help communicate 2 things: 1) this file is audio free 2)this file is safe (people don't generally worry about getting a virus from a gif).

Re: Introducing GIFV

#40
post #22

"With all these improvements, Imgur will now denote converted MP4s with a .gifv extension. The intention is to signal to users throughout the Internet that these links will feature a GIF experience that incorporates all the current and future enhancements made through Project GIFV. Imgur plans to submit an accompanying specification to relevant standards organizations before the end of the year." This is bizarre. GIF…

This is a marketing endeavor that is pretending to be a technical innovation.

Yep. Plus gfycat.com does that since a while now, but imgur comes as "oh look we're so innovative".

" Imgur plans to submit an accompanying specification to relevant standards organizations"

Hi we put a .gifv extension to mp4 can we HTML5 standard this non standard file extension of a standard format?!

Riite.

Post reply on HN