Live data from Hacker News

A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

newyorker.com

21–30 of 60 posts

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#21
For those debating about reading the article:

I read it in its entirety. It's quite long, but it has some fascinating vignettes into life in Egypt. Topics covered include garbage collection and recycling, politics, marriage and divorce, and the roles of males and females in Egypt.

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#22
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Meanwhile, in the actual developed world, nobody buys bottled water because the tap water is perfectly indistinguishable from the bottled stuff, which the stores only keep for tourists.

Unless you're American

This American cannot recall the last time he purchased or consumed bottled water. I do purchase and consume Diet Mountain Dew, which may amount to the same thing.

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you're American

This American cannot recall the last time he purchased or consumed bottled water. I do purchase and consume Diet Mountain Dew, which may amount to the same thing.

I refuse to buy bottled water myself. But bottled water is very popular in America; right up there with not vaccinating your children.

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#24
post #18
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My tap water (from a well) is highly sulfuric. The quality and taste of tap water varies greatly from location to location, "developed world" or not. There are all sorts of good reasons to buy bottled water.

If your tap water is unusable, you do not live in a civilized society with modern infrastructure.

Save the juvenile snark for reddit. About 15% of Americans - almost 50M people just in the US - have private water sources like wells.

Heavily mineralized water is not "unusable", the taste is just rather unpleasant.

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#25
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If your tap water is unusable, you do not live in a civilized society with modern infrastructure.

Yikes! Perhaps it's best to leave "civilization" out of this?

(Thanks for the correction; fixed.)

A civilization needs modern infrastructure. One of these is certainly tap water. If the tap water is not usable for one of its primary purpose – drinking – then I would say that the infrastructure is lacking, and, by inference, the civilization.

The same with road systems. If I can confidently know that I can drive safely on the roads, I live in a civilization with a modern, maintained, infrastructure. If, on the other hand, I must constantly look out for potholes, missing roads, etc. then I don’t.

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#26
post #24
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If your tap water is unusable, you do not live in a civilized society with modern infrastructure.

Save the juvenile snark for reddit. About 15% of Americans - almost 50M people just in the US - have private water sources like wells. Heavily mineralized water is not "unusable", the taste is just rather unpleasant.

Is your argument that Americans are by definition civilized, and that wells (however they taste, as long as they are not poisonous) are therefore somehow acceptable?

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#27
"In 2009, during the worldwide epidemic of H1N1 swine flu, the Ministry of Agriculture decreed that all Egyptian pigs had to be killed. There was no evidence that pigs were spreading the disease, but the government went ahead and slaughtered as many as three hundred thousand animals. Some Egyptians believe that the decision was driven by a desire to appease Islamists, who had become outspoken critics of the regime, and supposedly hated pigs even more than they hated Mubarak."

wow.

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#28

"In 2009, during the worldwide epidemic of H1N1 swine flu, the Ministry of Agriculture decreed that all Egyptian pigs had to be killed. There was no evidence that pigs were spreading the disease, but the government went ahead and slaughtered as many as three hundred thousand animals. Some Egyptians believe that the decision was driven by a desire to appease Islamists, who had become outspoken critics of the regime, a…

Also see http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/05/05/us-afghanistan-pig...

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#29
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yikes! Perhaps it's best to leave "civilization" out of this?

(Thanks for the correction; fixed.) A civilization needs modern infrastructure. One of these is certainly tap water. If the tap water is not usable for one of its primary purpose – drinking – then I would say that the infrastructure is lacking, and, by inference, the civilization. The same with road systems. If I can confidently know that I can drive safely on the roads, I live in a civilization with a modern, mainta…

Oh well, the place where I live has tap water with better health standards than bottled one, but when driving, one still has to look for potholes. So much for civilization :(.

Re: A neighborhood garbageman explains modern Egypt

#30

For those debating about reading the article: I read it in its entirety. It's quite long, but it has some fascinating vignettes into life in Egypt. Topics covered include garbage collection and recycling, politics, marriage and divorce, and the roles of males and females in Egypt.

Very interesting read indeed, a very thorough insight into life in Egypt. I especially liked the relationship part, the female oppression and dominance at the same type. Seems almost like a paradox through the eyes of a westerner.
Post reply on HN