Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

news.ycombinator.com

161–170 of 316 posts

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#161

I haven't dropped Dropbox because I was unaware of the appointment of Condoleezza Rice prior to this poll. I've been considering dropping it for awhile for general privacy reasons, but this might be what pushes me over the edge.

I'm sure that was the purpose of this poll.

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#163
post #125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1. The poll was framed in a way that did not make my opinion available. 2. Nobody else had expressed my position so I thought that it was uncommon. 3. I assumed the poll was meant to try to force Dropbox to drop her from the board. 4. I expressed a position that wasn't that political but that I knew would anger or confuse political witchhunters. 5. It is quite common for people to downvote information that does not a…

Your "argument" wasn't that good to begin with, since you don't say why political links to the US government would be a good thing nor why she in particular would be a good choice for making/maintaining those links.

Well I didn't have long to type it so sorry if it wasn't great, but I would say that with regards to principles like Net Neutrality your idea that the tech industry doesn't need better political links to the US government is not well-grounded.

I couldn't possibly speculate on who the best people to make or maintain political links are, but my speculation is that the more connected to government you are the more you will be able to affect policies affecting the tech industry.

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#164
successful democracies have so many protections built in for open debates and protection of minority viewpoints, as well as labor law to protect people's jobs... it just seems so creepy to me the current trend toward squelching disagreement by attacking people's jobs when you disagree with them or if they hold an unpopular opinion.

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#165
I dropped Dropbox because I no longer found it useful. The composition of a company's pro-forma board of directors is quite possibly the last on my list of decision procedures when making choices about what technologies I use.

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah she is female and black so plenty for the right to hate.

While a large swath of people believe that conservatives hate women and people that aren't white, this is not the case. Racists prejudice a specific race. Sexists prejudice a specific gender. Conservatives, however, are just people that have a different view on how a country should be run. These three things are completely separate qualities. Some people may exhibit several of these qualities, while others do not. I…

> Racists prejudice a specific race. Sexists prejudice a specific gender. Conservatives, however, are just people that have a different view on how a country should be run.

For everything else, there's Fox News ...

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#168
post #34

I continue to use Dropbox and I'm pro the appointment of Condoleezza Rice as for the sake of our industry it is wise for us to have better political links to the US government. (Politics is irrelevant to me, but power is not. The government can already twist your arm; being on first name's basis with somebody important will be invaluable.) Edit: I thought we could openly state our opinions, but it seems I am getting…

I like your reasoning; it's always nice to encounter someone who doesn't confuse "ought" with "is". (Also, anent voting patterns, anecdotal but perhaps still of interest: I've noticed, when expressing on HN political opinions which don't accord with the local consensus, that there will generally be a few slow downvotes early, followed by a quick spike of upvotes bringing the comment up to a net positive score, follow…

>when expressing on HN political opinions which don't accord with the local consensus

This is the case not only with unpopular political opinions, but anything mildly or even vaguely controversial. I'm convinced that it's mostly the same few individuals who sit on HN all day and downvote away.

I've also wondered about the possible existence of a bot or bots that downvote comments with certain keywords, in a misguided effort to avoid any Reddit-like dilution of HN's usual quality. What makes me think it might be bots is the consistent speed with which mildly controversial posts get downvoted once or twice. It seems too regular to be human-mediated (and if it is, then I worry for the mental state of said human).

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#169
post #125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1. The poll was framed in a way that did not make my opinion available. 2. Nobody else had expressed my position so I thought that it was uncommon. 3. I assumed the poll was meant to try to force Dropbox to drop her from the board. 4. I expressed a position that wasn't that political but that I knew would anger or confuse political witchhunters. 5. It is quite common for people to downvote information that does not a…

Your "argument" wasn't that good to begin with, since you don't say why political links to the US government would be a good thing nor why she in particular would be a good choice for making/maintaining those links.

I suppose the OP thought, like I do too, that it is obvious what positive effects come from fraternal relations with politicians.

Have you read the newspapers lately from ANY part of the world? Does it still need to be explained why, in general, being cosy with the politicos is usually a good thing?

Re: Poll: Did you “drop Dropbox”?

#170
post #34

I continue to use Dropbox and I'm pro the appointment of Condoleezza Rice as for the sake of our industry it is wise for us to have better political links to the US government. (Politics is irrelevant to me, but power is not. The government can already twist your arm; being on first name's basis with somebody important will be invaluable.) Edit: I thought we could openly state our opinions, but it seems I am getting…

"Politics" is discrete from ethics. Condi is a pariah, ethically speaking-- a war criminal walking free.

Political links to the US govt are also a bit of a hazard-- the more you willingly approach them and enable them, the more they will take from your pocket and the more they will push you around. The Snowden leaks have painted a bad picture of the US companies as a result of their compliance with ridiculous government policy, and these companies are being scrutinized fiercely as a result.

Post reply on HN