Live data from Hacker News

Setting the Record Straight on Tor

corporate.comcast.com

11–20 of 56 posts

Re: Setting the Record Straight on Tor

#11

"Customers are free to use their Xfinity Internet service to visit any website, use any app, and so forth." Any app, but not on any device as I found out when I tried to activate HBO GO on a Roku. Apparently if Comcast is your ISP, you cannot use HBO GO on your Roku (or PS3 for that matter). EDIT: You can see what devices are supported here: http://www.hbogo.com/activate/

Wow, I'd never seen that. What an odd restriction.

Re: Setting the Record Straight on Tor

#12
post #7

Comcast seems to get negative press on reddit - at least as much as Netflix has positive. The site must be very easy for marketeers to game.

Or Comcast just is that terrible. I'm not sure people are faking these 30 minutes long captures of a sales person repeatedly asking you to upgrade when you are calling to cancel.

Re: Setting the Record Straight on Tor

#14
post #7

Comcast seems to get negative press on reddit - at least as much as Netflix has positive. The site must be very easy for marketeers to game.

The marketing hype for Netflix on Reddit is astounding.

I've stopped reading many movie related subs because of it.

Re: Setting the Record Straight on Tor

#15
post #11

"Customers are free to use their Xfinity Internet service to visit any website, use any app, and so forth." Any app, but not on any device as I found out when I tried to activate HBO GO on a Roku. Apparently if Comcast is your ISP, you cannot use HBO GO on your Roku (or PS3 for that matter). EDIT: You can see what devices are supported here: http://www.hbogo.com/activate/

Wow, I'd never seen that. What an odd restriction.

Probably a restriction imposed by HBO because they have been so terrified of loosing their content into non-traditional outlets.

Re: Setting the Record Straight on Tor

#17
post #6

It's a very good sign that Comcast is posting this kind of correction. It indicates that they perceive a broad social consensus that supporting internet anonymity is a crucial responsibility of an ISP, and lends credence to the ongoing importance of net neutrality. It also, as a secondary effect, might incline us to look more favorably on Comcast's arguments regarding backbone capacity negotiations.

They didn't actually say they didn't monitor Tor tho. :/

That is why I'm kinda amused by the positive posts.

They said they don't monitor people's browsers and http connections. TOR wouldn't look like that at all to them. Its a lie of omission. They clearly monitor Torrents, etc.

Re: Setting the Record Straight on Tor

#18
post #13

It's a little scary how quickly an unsourced and highly questionable story can spread when it feeds a popular narrative (in this case that Comcast is evil).

"A lie can travel half way around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes." ~ Mark Twain, Winston Churchill, Jonathan Swift, or some other person who said things good.

Whoever said it, they said it before the dawn of the internet. What was once a figurative embellishment is now the literal truth. This story was almost everywhere on social media before any of the high level people at Comcast had the chance to put their shoes on and show up at work on Monday morning to comment on it.

Re: Setting the Record Straight on Tor

#20

"Customers are free to use their Xfinity Internet service to visit any website, use any app, and so forth." Any app, but not on any device as I found out when I tried to activate HBO GO on a Roku. Apparently if Comcast is your ISP, you cannot use HBO GO on your Roku (or PS3 for that matter). EDIT: You can see what devices are supported here: http://www.hbogo.com/activate/

Sort of.

Its important to note that there is a difference between what they restrict in the way of internet traffic, and what they sponsor in terms of allowing access to specific content over the internet.

The services that you log into via your Comcast account (I use HBO Go, HGTV, NBC Live Extra...) are provided by an agreement between the content provider and the carrier. They aren't stopping you from using HBO Go on a Roku with their internet service, and your friend with FiOS can hook his Roku up and watch shows at your house over your Xfinity connection.

Post reply on HN