Worth noting that this was only a single-blind test, with a sample size of 1 violinist.
Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
11–20 of 26 posts
Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#12Worth noting that this was only a single-blind test, with a sample size of 1 violinist.
Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#13Worth noting that this was only a single-blind test, with a sample size of 1 violinist.
There were 5 violins, 2 of which were fungus violins, one of those in particular received a staggering 60% of the votes. Not sure what the best conclusion to draw is but it's certainly believable that one day you'll be able to get a cheap violin with incredible tone quality.
Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#14As the article points out, other more mundane violins have done the same thing.
Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#15Earlier quoted context omitted.
There were 5 violins, 2 of which were fungus violins, one of those in particular received a staggering 60% of the votes. Not sure what the best conclusion to draw is but it's certainly believable that one day you'll be able to get a cheap violin with incredible tone quality.
But it's quite plausible that the performer played slightly differently on the various violins. A more robust test would include several performers, playing the different violins in arbitrary order, to rotating groups of listeners.
Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#16Worth noting that this was only a single-blind test, with a sample size of 1 violinist.
There were 5 violins, 2 of which were fungus violins, one of those in particular received a staggering 60% of the votes. Not sure what the best conclusion to draw is but it's certainly believable that one day you'll be able to get a cheap violin with incredible tone quality.
Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#17Worth noting that this was only a single-blind test, with a sample size of 1 violinist.
I still think it's interesting that, even though the violinist knew which violin he was playing, the audience liked him playing the Opus 58 violin better than playing his own Stradivarius, which he could have been subconsciously influenced to play better because of its familiarity.
Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#18Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#19Re: Fungus-treated Violin Outdoes Stradivarius
#20Fungus is the new computer. There's nothing like that feeling a beginning programmer has when he realizes that he can give the computer a few simple instructions and, in a matter of seconds, the computer does something that would take thousands of man-years of manual computation. This is why biotech is such an interesting field. If we can give fungi and bacteria simple instructions and let them execute those instruct…
I don't really see the link with computing here. The fungi changed the cell structure of the wood, chemistry and woodworking on a microscopic scale.