Live data from Hacker News

My year with a distraction-free iPhone

medium.com

161–170 of 189 posts

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#161
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And yet he continues to be mocked on sites like HN.

Things that don't help: - When people want to point out that "Stallman predicted this X years ago," they phase it as, "Richard Stallman was right, as usual." Richard Stallman is not infallible. Overstating one's case doesn't win any new friends. - There are many of Stallman's "followers" that are very aggressive at promoting the GPLv3 over all other open source licenses. While this might not be Stallman's personal po…

When people take the phrase: " Stallman was right, as usual." and suggest that this is a claim of infallibility. Overstating one's case doesn't win any new friends.

The claim is that on these issues Stallman is more usually right than wrong. Do you have anything that suggests otherwise?

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#162
We are doing our small part to help.

I sometimes post about my company working on the next big "social platform". And we are trying to do things RIGHT - open source, fully distributed (while respecting CAP theorem), people own their own data, etc.

So when it comes to notifications, like in every other area we want to encourage the apps to use "best practices" and only notify people of what they really WOULD want to know about. That means turning down the "slot machine" factor and handing over control over notifications to the people. To do this, we needed to design a standard, expressive interface and "language" that people could use in any app across the platform to quickly indicate what they want.

And here's an overview of how it works withte rest of the system:

Every piece of data in Q (http://platform.qbix.com) is typically stored in a Stream. Which means things like access control (privacy), real time updates (like chat), offline notifications (delivered to any endpoints), etc. are all implemented by the system and available to the app for free.

The user can fine tune notifications settings for any stream or type of stream, and each app can provide Rules with configurable settings and thresholds. For example, a "Groups/activity" published by a user who is in my contacts under a "Friends" or "Family" label and matching my interests would accumulate enough weight to bust through my notification threshhold for sending me an in-app notification, or an email, or an sms. At certain hours of night, my notificaion threshold goes up. When I get into my car, and start moving fast, my notification threshhold goes up until I get out of the car, so only the most urgent things distract me.

And that red badge on the icon? It should earn your trust, like all interface elements it represents a relationship and shouldn't cry wolf. It should NOT show the number of messages waiting for you, but rather show the number of streams with "important" messages posted since you last checked that stream on ANY device.

In short - there are lots of things to solve but they only have to be solved once. That's what we have been working on for over 3 years.

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#164

I think the biggest problem with the smartphone are the PUSH notifications. Disable them and your life becomes instantly better. If deleting apps is a big leap for you then I think disabling all push notifications is the second best thing you can do.

Push is great for messages that are both timely and relevant. A lot of app-makers don't seem to get this.

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

¿Do you know any page with a collection of his predictions? Some kind of "The Stallman Prophecies"

For starters http://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman

Aaand I just learned there is such a thing as rhinophytonecrophilia. Really, Stallman never lets you down.

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#166
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Things that don't help: - When people want to point out that "Stallman predicted this X years ago," they phase it as, "Richard Stallman was right, as usual." Richard Stallman is not infallible. Overstating one's case doesn't win any new friends. - There are many of Stallman's "followers" that are very aggressive at promoting the GPLv3 over all other open source licenses. While this might not be Stallman's personal po…

When people take the phrase: " Stallman was right, as usual." and suggest that this is a claim of infallibility. Overstating one's case doesn't win any new friends. The claim is that on these issues Stallman is more usually right than wrong. Do you have anything that suggests otherwise?

'As usual' is unnecessary unless you're trying to passively aggressively say "I told you so," or imply that people should blindly accept everything that Stallman says.

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#167
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When people take the phrase: " Stallman was right, as usual." and suggest that this is a claim of infallibility. Overstating one's case doesn't win any new friends. The claim is that on these issues Stallman is more usually right than wrong. Do you have anything that suggests otherwise?

'As usual' is unnecessary unless you're trying to passively aggressively say "I told you so," or imply that people should blindly accept everything that Stallman says.

I would hardly tell anyone to blindly accept everything or anything Stallman (or for the matter, any charismatic leader) says.

However, "I told you so" is a phrase much needed these days... specially directed towards people that insist on making the same kind of mistakes that drove us to the mess we're right now.

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#168
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

'As usual' is unnecessary unless you're trying to passively aggressively say "I told you so," or imply that people should blindly accept everything that Stallman says.

I would hardly tell anyone to blindly accept everything or anything Stallman (or for the matter, any charismatic leader) says. However, "I told you so" is a phrase much needed these days... specially directed towards people that insist on making the same kind of mistakes that drove us to the mess we're right now.

Look. Coming from someone that already "drinks the kool-aid" I find those people off-putting. Do you really think that people who currently disbelieve are going to suddenly "see the light" from them? It comes across to me as a massive circle-jerk. "Look! I^HStallman was right!"

Think about it this way. What would make you consider a vegan diet/lifestyle? A person calmly having a reasoned discussion with you, presenting you with facts, and chatting about your concerns? Or the 'angry vegan' on the street corner screaming "Meat is Murder" and "Shame on you" to everyone passing by?

> However, "I told you so" is a phrase much needed these days... specially directed towards people that insist on making the same kind of mistakes that drove us to the mess we're right now.

"I told you so" is the opposite of constructive. If you feel that it is constructive, I suggest that you re-evaluate your methods for dealing with other people.

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#169

(Posting using a throwaway as I changed my noprocrast settings in HN as mentioned in these comments and ironically blocked my account for the day!) Somewhat related, I've come to a similar conclusion myself recently but via app fatigue instead. I've been running a Windows Phone for over a year now, and although I loved the OS, constant remarks regarding the app gap made me wonder if I was missing out on the full smar…

That's an interesting idea. I'd never considered Windows Mobile before, but since I, too, don't really need much in the way of apps (just the ones you mention), maybe I should look into it. Any idea how well a Windows mobile phone can integrate with a household that's predominantly Mac?

Works well for me!

I guess most integration would be fine - email, calendar and so on. There are WP alternatives for most services, i.e. OneDrive for cloud syncing, etc. - however iTunes, iCloud and so on could be an issue.

It could be MS's new marketing angle - "come to Windows Phone, we don't have any apps, and that's a good thing" :)

Re: My year with a distraction-free iPhone

#170

(Posting using a throwaway as I changed my noprocrast settings in HN as mentioned in these comments and ironically blocked my account for the day!) Somewhat related, I've come to a similar conclusion myself recently but via app fatigue instead. I've been running a Windows Phone for over a year now, and although I loved the OS, constant remarks regarding the app gap made me wonder if I was missing out on the full smar…

That's an interesting idea. I'd never considered Windows Mobile before, but since I, too, don't really need much in the way of apps (just the ones you mention), maybe I should look into it. Any idea how well a Windows mobile phone can integrate with a household that's predominantly Mac?

Works great, there's a Windows Phone app on the Mac App Store, even syncs with iCloud.
Post reply on HN