Live data from Hacker News

This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

theatlantic.com

11–20 of 96 posts

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#11
FYI, he's doing a Kickstarter to raise awareness and funding:

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/noahdyer/a-year-without...

Philosophically speaking, the idea of a society where every actioned is monitored, recorded and made available, is a potentially interesting thought experiment.

That said, I find it rather difficult to feel too excited, for this specific campaign.

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#13
Tl;dr guy thinks privacy is dead and so sets up a project to be completely transparent (public access to emails, video of daily life etc). He is a divorced Ex Mormon also, not relevant but a good story hook

I like it btw - I agree that dealin with loss of privacy means asymmetry in knowledge unless we make things transparent.

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#14
post #4

Sounds like the person is an exhibitionist. My best take away from the article is the insightful statement by the author: "Every one of us is entrusted with information that our family, friends, colleagues, and acquaintances would rather that we kept private."

This is a great point. Fundamentally, how well I uphold the trust of my friends is connected to the security of my computing environment. You damn well bet I want more secure software.

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#15
post #6

New technologies like Google Glass are going to make this guy's dream a reality. I suspect people with glass will behave differently when wearing them than when not.

I think you're overestimating the effect of Glass, since taking pictures and recording video is still a conscious decision. (Except when someone publishes the inevitable life-blogging app that captures a shot every few minutes. Even then sharing with the public (via Google) is still a conscious decision - sharing with Google & the NSA isn't of course. Luckily batteries are still a limiting factor.)

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#16

Reading this reminded me of the adage, "Character is who you are when nobody is watching". Can you imagine being this guy's child and reading him talk about how "Yeah, maybe if people were watching me then I would have tried harder to spend time with my kids last summer". It's not that he wants to spend time with them, he's just worried about how it looks to other people. The truth hurts, but that doesn't mean that t…

It gets better: His "transparency" includes being open and honest with the world that he has had several affairs with married women where the husbands did not know.

So, is that some kind of loophole? How does he justify that in his twisted logic? Everyone else knows, so it's okay?

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#17
Was thinking about this line in some comment: "if you have nothing to worry about, you shouldn't mind if the government reads your emails".

Besides the obvious flaws, shouldn't it also go the other way?

The government hides tons of things, from classified documents to internal memos. What about that?

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#19

Reading this reminded me of the adage, "Character is who you are when nobody is watching". Can you imagine being this guy's child and reading him talk about how "Yeah, maybe if people were watching me then I would have tried harder to spend time with my kids last summer". It's not that he wants to spend time with them, he's just worried about how it looks to other people. The truth hurts, but that doesn't mean that t…

This is how I feel when people give all of their email to LinkedIn. :(

Re: This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password

#20
> "secrets exist to prevent other people from acting as they would if they had complete information"

And? I don't understand why the reader must assume it would be good for people to act with complete information. Privacy is required where trust is absent because people in the abstract are not responsible or empathetic enough to warrant the risk. Ask any celebrity if privacy is a barrier to equality. This isn't pessimism either; I could see privacy not be needed but only if the protection from harm is replaced by other protections embedded in the culture or environment.

Post reply on HN