Live data from Hacker News

Why Are PC Sales Up and Tablet Sales Down?

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 75 posts

Re: Why Are PC Sales Up and Tablet Sales Down?

#11
Tablets are simple appliances limited to consuming content . My IPad 1 lets me watch Netflix, Youtube and surf the web just as well as the latest version of the IPad .Therefore I see no reason to buy the latest version. I have in the meanwhile bought/upgraded laptops thrice for myself as I see an immediate improvement in my productivity with faster CPU and more RAM or bigger SSD.

Re: Why Are PC Sales Up and Tablet Sales Down?

#13
Tablet sales are down because 10" tablets are not very useful devices, and 7" tablets are increasingly having their lunch eaten by phablets. (edit: And because manufacturers push 10"s over 7"s, and some other reasons)

The article is all about the purported benefits of tablets as being low maintenance, lower user burden, but a tablet is a form factor. There's no reason why you can't produce a machine with a keyboard and monitor that has the limited options and simplicity of set-up as a tablet, and indeed there have been periodic attempts to do that -- ChromeOS is perhaps the latest. It turns out that, contra the article, they haven't been wildly popular.

The tablet form factor is never going to be a good choice for office workers who use MS Office, even with various plug-in keyboards and other hybrid approaches.

Re: Why Are PC Sales Up and Tablet Sales Down?

#14
post #7
post #3

Anecdotal: the PC and laptop I bought around the time tablets started coming out are starting to show their age. So now I'm in the market for their replacements. Could a factor be the fact that the age of the tablet market currently equals the average lifetime of a PC?

I would expect PC end-of-lifes to be distributed randomly or on a yearly cycle, not on a three-year cycle.

Good point. Here's a theory: laptops were running out of time and people had to opt for a new laptop or a tablet (which, at the time, had the novelty factor) and most of them decided to try a tablet. Tablets did not replace the old laptops so (some) people have since bought a new laptop. This could explain why laptop sales were down during the first stages of tablets' market penetration.

Re: Why Are PC Sales Up and Tablet Sales Down?

#17
My tablet, which I bought 4 years ago, collects dust in the closet and I use it maybe twice a year - I just can't find a single reason to use a tablet on a daily basis and yes, I had the new iPads, Surfaces etc. in my hands. Everything I need to do outside home I can do on a smartphone and if I need to do real work, I just use a laptop.

Re: Why Are PC Sales Up and Tablet Sales Down?

#18

I guess 5 - 7 years are over and people replace their old desktop/laptop PCs this year. As for tablets: They are pretty boring content consumption devices. Why would you buy every year a new tablet if all you do with them is surfing the web/watching netflix? Also there's no mobile network operator who will give you one "for free" every two years when you renew a contract.

"Also there's no mobile network operator who will give you one "for free" every two years when you renew a contract."

I live in South Africa, and that regularly happens here. People take out 2 year contracts for "data" and get tablets/laptops for free along with it. I suppose it's not so common in more developed countries where most mobile internet packages are "unlimited". Here, they're very much limited to multiples of 500MB/month.

Re: Why Are PC Sales Up and Tablet Sales Down?

#19

It is only a matter of time before someone sells a "docking station" for smartphones with HDMI outputs to a monitor and a keyboard/mouse setup as a replacement for a desktop. (if it doesn't exist already)

http://www.amazon.com/Motorola-Lapdock-500-Pro-Smartphones/d...

I give you, the recent past! I used one once, the experience was underwhelming. It could have been good (my phone had more than enough power to run a lightweight linux window manager and web browser pretty well, the android software just wasn't very polished)

And it's untimely death

http://www.cnet.com/news/motorola-confirms-death-of-webtop-l...

http://www.androidcentral.com/tag/webtop

Post reply on HN