Live data from Hacker News

Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

translate.google.com

21–30 of 30 posts

Re: Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

#21

Russia's Tzars really doomed Russia for the last hundred years + the future when they decided to wait a century or more too long to emancipate their serfs. Russians have never had a chance to experience freedom, just corruption and authoritarianism because their nobles couldn't do the right thing when almost everywhere else in Europe there was enlightenment among the higher classes. Russia also never had a French rev…

You forgot about the Decembrist revolt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decembrist_revolt

Re: Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

#22
post #7

Here's a bit on the photographer and the specific technique used to capture these photos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergey_Prokudin-Gorsky#Photogr... When I was younger, in the early 90s, I had a chance to be on one of the earliest U.S.-Russian student exchanges following the fall of the Soviet Union. I spent a summer there, mostly in the Urals, but a bit East of those mountains as well, sometimes out in open step…

From my stay and travels in Russia I can confirm that Russian hospitality is incredible. Plus they all have cats.

Re: Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

#23
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wouldn't say that. The clothes look uncomfortable, there are mud tracks rather than road, the whole city is two- or even one-story buildings (which implies you'd be living without any subcultural clubs in walking distance - hope you enjoy the same things everyone else does). Even the melons the guy is selling are clearly in much worse condition than modern supermarket produce. And look at how many people it takes j…

Yeah I don't know how people managed to live happy lives with all those mud tracks and sub-par melons.

Vodka.

Re: Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

#25

What's most awesome about these pictures, is that looking many of them, you could easily imagine they were taken today. It's astonishing that the picture of modern life we see all around us, we build up this idea in our heads that we've come so far in the past hundred or so years, but in reality, much of the world - even in the West, hasn't come that far at all.

It would be very cool to see photographs of the same places today. How much have the clothing and building styles changed? (or not changed)

Re: Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

#27
post #7

Here's a bit on the photographer and the specific technique used to capture these photos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergey_Prokudin-Gorsky#Photogr... When I was younger, in the early 90s, I had a chance to be on one of the earliest U.S.-Russian student exchanges following the fall of the Soviet Union. I spent a summer there, mostly in the Urals, but a bit East of those mountains as well, sometimes out in open step…

From my stay and travels in Russia I can confirm that Russian hospitality is incredible. Plus they all have cats.

[deleted]

Re: Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

#28
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wouldn't say that. The clothes look uncomfortable, there are mud tracks rather than road, the whole city is two- or even one-story buildings (which implies you'd be living without any subcultural clubs in walking distance - hope you enjoy the same things everyone else does). Even the melons the guy is selling are clearly in much worse condition than modern supermarket produce. And look at how many people it takes j…

Yeah I don't know how people managed to live happy lives with all those mud tracks and sub-par melons.

If you look at happiness surveys, as best as we can tell such people would have been significantly less happy than we are.

Re: Czarist Russia in color (1905–1915)

#29
post #21

Russia's Tzars really doomed Russia for the last hundred years + the future when they decided to wait a century or more too long to emancipate their serfs. Russians have never had a chance to experience freedom, just corruption and authoritarianism because their nobles couldn't do the right thing when almost everywhere else in Europe there was enlightenment among the higher classes. Russia also never had a French rev…

You forgot about the Decembrist revolt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decembrist_revolt

Yes I did, that was pretty important.
Post reply on HN