Live data from Hacker News

The New Foursquare

avc.com

31–40 of 77 posts

Re: The New Foursquare

#31

Does their new welcome page look broken/ugly to anyone else? I'm wondering if it's just on my end; scroll down past the initial tick. https://foursquare.com/download#welcome

Yeah it's broken. I'm on Firefox with Win8, the gray text is misaligned and missing an element / backdrop.

Re: The New Foursquare

#32

They've sacrificed their core of users who supplied all of the checkins and tips in order to try to kill Yelp. Problem was, only those loyal users were ever convinced that they were better than yelp. Now that they've chosen the foursquare name, which is synonymous with checkins, for their Yelp clone, it seems like they haven't thought out... 1. If the checkin users leave because Swarm is stupid and eliminates everyth…

I work for Foursquare; here's my answer to #3:

It's not just that tips are shorter than reviews, though that's part of it. The issue with Yelp is that every single user gets the same recommendations if they search at the same place and time. And in a world where everything is becoming more personalized, it's crazy that the predominant app in the local search category does nothing to tailor its results to you. When you sign up for the new Foursquare, it asks you for your tastes so that every time you search, every time you open the app, it will be tailored for the things you like. It's like Amazon recommended products vs the experience you get on non-smart ecommerce platforms. It's smarter at a fundamental level; the things we are doing with our data are really smart and unprecedented in this space. That's why I'm confident we have a differentiated product in this new app, and I hope you try it out and see what I mean.

Furthermore, we still have tons of check-in data - 90% of our checkin users have moved over to Swarm and continue to check in. So I don't think there's much to worry about with regards to our data getting stale and losing quality.

Re: The New Foursquare

#33
I think this has been one of the toughest decisions foursquare has made till now albeit in the right direction. Alienating the check-in feature from core-foursquare app might piss off some power users but IMO there is not much value added by check-in for the user. With the amount of data FS has gathered from users up until now will be better utilized via place-discovery. Also I believe that there is a need for this kind of service which we can use to discover places globally rather than depend on something like Yelp which is mostly US centric. On improvement side, I think they should make check-ins using Swarm as easy as possible in one tap. Currently they ask to select/write lot of optional stuff while check-in which slows down the process.

Re: The New Foursquare

#34
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I recall seeing a data presentation on 4square a few months ago, and the numbers suggested that check-ins were tapering. They definitely realized that all their corporate value was in the data. Perhaps they are trying to avoid the split issues from Netflix? I think they needed to give the Foursquare name to the Yelp-killer so that people would know about it. The space is too crowded to start from scratch. And Yelp is…

"And Yelp is ready to be killed." Why? Is that your personal sentiment on their company, or are you suggesting their business isn't successful? Who's their biggest competitor? They killed Citysearch, and Sheckys, and all the other websites that used to dominate that space, but I can't think of another company that comes close to their brand awareness apart from Google, who probably won't dominate since it's not their…

Two issues with Yelp:

1 - The recommendations are not personalized. We are getting more and more accustomed to personalization. I love FreshDirect, but I don't trust their anonymous ratings either. Same with SeamlessWeb.

2 - The Yelp reviews are frequently gimmicked by advertisers.

Re: The New Foursquare

#35
post #18

I don't buy the privacy argument. Its an inherently extroverted market so you split your apps into an introvert app that no one in the market will want to use and an extrovert app. Why? I don't buy the assertion that the small segment of the population that was into 4sq would be into privacy. They're optimizing the experience for people that don't exist beyond the initial fad-explosion. I would extend my remarks that…

Using Facebook as a model for privacy reinforced my decision to stop using foursquare.

Re: The New Foursquare

#36
post #8
post #6

I have 2.4Ghz i5, 8G Ram, SSD Macbook and the performance of the landing page is horrendous.

3.2Ghz i7, 16GB Ram, SSD Windows, landing page seems ok, even with the processor on power-saving mode. Does your browser's CPU count increase significantly?

Yes 100%. I'm using Chrome. I could by any plugin or extension that I'm using (Chrome Helper is 89%) Flashblock, AdBlock etc. On the other side, timeline says that I my FPS is below 30 with many spikes caused by render and paint. Hmmm.

Re: The New Foursquare

#37

They've sacrificed their core of users who supplied all of the checkins and tips in order to try to kill Yelp. Problem was, only those loyal users were ever convinced that they were better than yelp. Now that they've chosen the foursquare name, which is synonymous with checkins, for their Yelp clone, it seems like they haven't thought out... 1. If the checkin users leave because Swarm is stupid and eliminates everyth…

I work for Foursquare; here's my answer to #3: It's not just that tips are shorter than reviews, though that's part of it. The issue with Yelp is that every single user gets the same recommendations if they search at the same place and time. And in a world where everything is becoming more personalized, it's crazy that the predominant app in the local search category does nothing to tailor its results to you. When yo…

> 90% of our checkin users have moved over to Swarm and continue to check in.

That's an incredibly high number, so I'm guessing it doesn't mean "all users ever", but rather "all users who check in at least once a day"?

Re: The New Foursquare

#38
post #13

They've sacrificed their core of users who supplied all of the checkins and tips in order to try to kill Yelp. Problem was, only those loyal users were ever convinced that they were better than yelp. Now that they've chosen the foursquare name, which is synonymous with checkins, for their Yelp clone, it seems like they haven't thought out... 1. If the checkin users leave because Swarm is stupid and eliminates everyth…

I've stopped using 4sq when they forced to check in through Swarm. Swarm was constantly monitoring me and eating the battery. At least in Foursquare app you could turn of the 'Radar'. Good bye 4sq.

FYI you can go into iOS preferences -> General -> Background App Refresh and turn off apps that you don't want to run in the background. I've done that with Swarm with no problems, and you can do it with other apps too (Facebook?)

Re: The New Foursquare

#39

They've sacrificed their core of users who supplied all of the checkins and tips in order to try to kill Yelp. Problem was, only those loyal users were ever convinced that they were better than yelp. Now that they've chosen the foursquare name, which is synonymous with checkins, for their Yelp clone, it seems like they haven't thought out... 1. If the checkin users leave because Swarm is stupid and eliminates everyth…

I work for Foursquare; here's my answer to #3: It's not just that tips are shorter than reviews, though that's part of it. The issue with Yelp is that every single user gets the same recommendations if they search at the same place and time. And in a world where everything is becoming more personalized, it's crazy that the predominant app in the local search category does nothing to tailor its results to you. When yo…

> 90% of our checkin users have moved over to Swarm Really? I find that extremely hard to believe that 90% of users would download a second app. That would be a super huge success if true. Or how do you define 'checkin user'? Someone who checks in every day? At least once a week? etc

Re: The New Foursquare

#40

Does their new welcome page look broken/ugly to anyone else? I'm wondering if it's just on my end; scroll down past the initial tick. https://foursquare.com/download#welcome

babby's first scroll-hijacking landing page. In addition to shit usability, the heavy dependency on jQuery plugins is a big clue.
Post reply on HN