Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

steady.stupeflix.com

71–80 of 113 posts

Re: Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems like google auto stabilized my video. They probably did it on the server side though.

Yes, Google has had some pretty good video stabilization on Youtube for 2 years now. I wish it happened in the camera app, though, especially since I once posted some private videos on Youtube, and Google deleted them anyway because there was some music in the background. It even said some company made a claim against them (even though they were private ). So yeah, Google's shitty copyright takedown system makes me n…

"It even said some company made a claim against them (even though they were private)."

The claim system is automatic based on Shazam-style audio "fingerprints"; companies basically pre-complain about any uploads that match audio sources they supply to Google that the claim copyright on.

On one hand, I can sort of understand Google's position with this proactive system because the alternative would mean they have to manually deal with probably hundreds of thousands, if not millions of copyright claims.

On the other hand, it is horribly broken in a lot of ways. In addition to not caring if your video is private, there are basically two classes of people (the ones with lots of subscribers who generate a lot of adwords hits for Google and everyone else), with the former class having a much easier time of disputing bad claims. Also I've run into situations where music that was creative commons licensed was flagged with attempts to unflag it automatically denied (with no legal basis to do so) and most amusingly(?) of all, Google offers a bunch of public domain recordings they suggest you use for your videos, but using them is almost guaranteed to generate a copyright claim from some third party that you then have to manually dispute.

I basically stopped using YouTube for videos because there seems to be like a 80% chance anything you upload will be auto-copyright-flagged, even if there is no recognizable music in it and it isn't worth the hassle to deal with the system.

Re: Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

#72
Thanks everyone for the input. Quick answer to most common questions :

* The video you can see on the landing page (steady.stupeflix.com) were all taken w/ Steady. Try using it outside on a sunny day for best results !

* Steady is not yet compatible with iOS8. Working on it ;)Same for iPad and iTouch.

* We use gyroscope informations to know the attitude of the iPhone while you shoot a video, and uses this information to correct the video.

* The app is not available yet on Android. We're pretty much tied to the iPhone right now, as the algorithm relies on a given gyro / camera pair to work.

If you like the app, a kind review on the App Store would be appreciated ! Thanks for taking the time to try it

From

Trueduke, Olotiar, Madlag, thomas 759 and Kaahne at Stupeflix

Re: Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

#74

This is a most brilliant landing page - flashy, but in a way that directly demonstrates what the product does, and the text is readable even against the white waves. Each of the sequences look beautiful and seem like if I just had this app, I would be able to make my videos just as beautiful. Congrats. I'm not sure, but I believe the beauty lies in the fact that each of these scenes is something I can see myself tryi…

I have some trouble with fonts on Elementary http://i.imgur.com/dYHPbvP.png

Re: Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

#75

I tried it on a bike and then edited the video with replay. I was really impressed with the result https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ynVeMFAQM8

What is impressive about that movie ? To me it's quite the opposite.. it's not impressive at all (too dark, bad fps) and when I watch it there is something in it that causes head aches. It's very hard to watch.

Shooting while in motion leads to a very shaky video. Being able to shot that steady video while using iPhone on a bike counts as very impressive to me.

To understand more, see this product called MoVI

The final footage:

http://vimeo.com/62917185

Behind the scenes for the same footage:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDv2OYKICoc

Re: Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

#78
post #77

Does this, by any chance, use the 3D deforming based stabilization demonstrated here [1]. That was already an impressive demo when it came out. [1] http://web.cecs.pdx.edu/~fliu/project/3dstab.htm

Yes and no. Going through the paper real quick, we use similar technique, but do not analyze the video to reconstruct the movement of the camera, which allows us to speed up the algorithm significantly.

Re: Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is impressive about that movie ? To me it's quite the opposite.. it's not impressive at all (too dark, bad fps) and when I watch it there is something in it that causes head aches. It's very hard to watch.

I am biking with one hand and filming with the other. The image doesn't shake, try do film walking or biking and you'll see

I think he's trying to say that it's hard to tell because of the effects and filters added to the video distract from the example of stabilized video. The additional edits are unappealing to some so it's hard to get a feel for how the footage looks.

Re: Show HN: Steady – Shoot Cinematic Videos

#80
post #74

This is a most brilliant landing page - flashy, but in a way that directly demonstrates what the product does, and the text is readable even against the white waves. Each of the sequences look beautiful and seem like if I just had this app, I would be able to make my videos just as beautiful. Congrats. I'm not sure, but I believe the beauty lies in the fact that each of these scenes is something I can see myself tryi…

I have some trouble with fonts on Elementary http://i.imgur.com/dYHPbvP.png

Looks the same on Ubuntu.
Post reply on HN