Live data from Hacker News

How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

tilden.github.io

31–40 of 59 posts

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#31
post #28

Discussion is a bit baseless without actual data saying whether most people prefer to snooze or dismiss alarm first.

You don't need consensus or lots of data to say that you don't like the user experience for an app.

No. But you need to be able to state that all the smartphone platforms get it wrong.

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#32

Sleep Cycle, a sleep tracking alarm clock for iOS, uses the accelerometer to implement snooze with a smack of the phone (while it is on your bed), while the alarm off is the de facto slide to the right. I think this is about the best phone alarm clock I've used for this feature alone. It is so similar to interacting with a regular alarm clock.

I've never used a real alarm clock, but I do feel like it is easier to wake up with sleep cycle. It is also awesome that you have a limited number of snoozes, after those it doesn't stop ringing.

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#34
post #29
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

related to this, if you have a daily alarm and wake up 2 minutes before it, you have to remember to toggle it off before getting in the shower. Anyone know an app to get around this problem (like a "skip today" button) ?

Android (at least the Nexus 7) has a 'dismiss now' notification option. Very handy.

Not specific to the N7. It's a feature of 4.4 (probably one of the later dot releases).

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#36
Using the default Android alarm clock, in my sleepy state, I would sometimes forget whether I wanted to "snooze" or "dismiss".

I've been using Timely (mentioned in the article) for about 6 months now, and I love it. I use a feature that forces you to do a puzzle before the alarm will turn off.

Unfortunately, my sleepy self recently discovered that I can dismiss the alarm (turn it off) without the puzzle though, by closing it from the notification bar. Hopefully that doesn't become a bad morning habit.

One of my childhood ideas for an invention was a variant of this alarm clock puzzle concept: an alarm clock that forced you to play the game "Simon", each time you wanted to snooze. Each time you snoozed the alarm, the puzzle would become more difficult.

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#37
post #15

Erm.. Clicking any physical button on iPhone will snooze the alarm. Swiping will turn it off. I always click without looking, never ever had the same problems as the author. They probably should remove touch snooze completely, and just rely on click snooze. Maybe then it wouldn't be confusing.

Where are those instructions listed?

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#38
I would be happy with the app knowing which button I press. On my iPhone if I push the home button it could snooze, if I hit power or volume it would stop.

trying to hit some arbitrary button on the screen is not my idea of fun, I don't want to even look at the screen. My phone has physical buttons I can determine by touch alone, use them

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#39
post #36

Using the default Android alarm clock, in my sleepy state, I would sometimes forget whether I wanted to "snooze" or "dismiss". I've been using Timely (mentioned in the article) for about 6 months now, and I love it. I use a feature that forces you to do a puzzle before the alarm will turn off. Unfortunately, my sleepy self recently discovered that I can dismiss the alarm (turn it off) without the puzzle though, by cl…

I, too, am quite fond of Timely. For me, enabling my phone's lock screen works quite well: in order to access the notification bar (and skip the shake/puzzle prompt), I would need to unlock the phone. Which is almost as difficult.

If you're as sleepy in the mornings as I am, try face unlock. I haven't tried, but I'm reasonably sure my pre-shower face should not unlock the phone. ;-)

Re: How every smartphone platform gets the alarm clock wrong

#40
post #13

I also find the Android alarm to be not nearly persistent enough. The clock radio I have at home goes off until you turn it off or snooze it - for hours if needed. But the Android alarm stops after a few minutes, and I've slept through it many times. (Doesn't help that it's quieter too.)

The Android alarm stops after an hour of snoozing. That's reasonable, but I've also been bitten by the "you have snoozed enough already" behaviour.
Post reply on HN