Live data from Hacker News

Who smeared Richard Feynman?

blog.nuclearsecrecy.com

11–20 of 58 posts

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#11

It seems like there needs to be another approach to redacting text like this. This one doesn't really cut it, apparently. And slips such as 'her' and 'she' was what primarily gave her away here. So the people who published the file should have been way more careful with this.

The difference of length between "he" and "she" would be enough to reveal that information.

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#12

It seems like there needs to be another approach to redacting text like this. This one doesn't really cut it, apparently. And slips such as 'her' and 'she' was what primarily gave her away here. So the people who published the file should have been way more careful with this.

They just draw a black box over the text in the PDFs now...

(No joke)

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#14
My first thought when I saw this letter was that it was Richard Feynman himself, perhaps appropriating the name of someone he knew had been interviewed. It would be entirely consistent with his character to smear himself in order to convince the government that they didn't want him -- just like the letter he wrote to the draft board proclaiming that he was not truly crazy, but was instead precisely crazy enough to not want them to think he was crazy.

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#15

> Through the years that he has been at the California Institute of Technology (REDACTED) he has in my opinion made a definite point of knowing well and cultivating such persons as the president of California Institute of Technology, the dean of the school of physics, department heads (including REDACTED and Linus Pauling), regents of California Institute of Technology, as well as REDACTED. Well it shouldn't be too m…

Why would someone working at Caltech be interviewed in Idaho? The ex-wife theory seems a whole lot more credible.

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#16
Feynman was in fact critical of the Soviet Union:

>I think that Russia represents danger in saying that the solution to human problems is known, that all effort should be for the state, for that means there is no novelty.

(from 'The Meaning Of It All', Ch. II)

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#17
post #12

It seems like there needs to be another approach to redacting text like this. This one doesn't really cut it, apparently. And slips such as 'her' and 'she' was what primarily gave her away here. So the people who published the file should have been way more careful with this.

They just draw a black box over the text in the PDFs now... (No joke)

Yes, but now they remove the underlying text too. It was fun while it lasted.

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#18
A little gem from the article: "It was an extremely ugly, long (2 years!) divorce hearing: it made the newspapers because of Bell’s allegations of “extreme cruelty” by Feynman, including the notion that he spent all of his waking hours either doing calculus and playing the bongos."

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#19
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Typewriter text is fixed width, so I imagine they get an average width for one character then calculate the number of characters in each redacted bit. What had you in mind?

Interestingly, although it seems harder, this sort of analysis is much more reliable with proportional fonts, because the specific width of the gap narrows the number of possibilities down considerably.

That would would depend heavily both on the proportional-width font that was used and the accuracy with which we could measure the width of the gap.

Re: Who smeared Richard Feynman?

#20

A little gem from the article: "It was an extremely ugly, long (2 years!) divorce hearing: it made the newspapers because of Bell’s allegations of “extreme cruelty” by Feynman, including the notion that he spent all of his waking hours either doing calculus and playing the bongos."

if only we could all live in a world where the highest form of domestic abuse was calculus and playing drums.
Post reply on HN