Live data from Hacker News

We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

listnerd.com

101–110 of 138 posts

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#101

I call BS. This appears to be a new take on "Show HN"...trying to get attention. The site works, looks OK, and you appear to have users, so it doesn't really suck. If you thought the concept sucked, then you wouldn't have done the site in the first place. If this were a legit post, I would say this: I think this is a relatively crowded niche you're in. I'm also sure that you dramatically overspent if you actually spe…

I don't know, $200k does look a lot for that site...

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To clarify, for the `.buy-button` class, is that where one should put super-specific styles like `margin-left: 12px`? Also, is there a good place I can learn these kind of things? I'm a programmer trying to get better at CSS (SCSS now that we've setup the asset pipeline)—so far I've been reading random A List Apart and The Sass Way articles, but I feel like I could use a more holistic, in-depth understanding of CSS i…

To answer your first question, yes that is exactly where you should put your super-specific styles. You want to put your communal styles in your placeholder, styles that all types have but are different in the mixin (background color, etc) and the rest on the class itself. The best way to get better at Sass is to follow people who are active in the community (which unfortunately is not me). Start with Chris Coyier an…

I appreciate your advice on this! From what I'm learning from you, it sounds like I'm committing some bad CSS practices myself.

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#104
post #77

Brilliant marketing stunt. Take my point.

We weren't trying to get marketing, I promise. But we were trying to agitate some of the brightest brains in tech into giving us extremely valid and honest feedback, and we succeeded at that.

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#105

When the list first loads, it is not visible on the screen but instead pushed down by a large margin. Also I believe many of your hits will come from google searches vs friend shares. Maybe make 100 SOE lists in house.

Hey, what page is this? I'm trying to reproduce the issue, but I can't? (I even installed a slow-loading plugin for Chrome, to mimic a slow browser to see if it was a CSS issue) :)

Also, what is a "SOE list"?

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#106

I think the idea is great - I actually had the same idea last summer and built www.curate.im which ended up getting absolutely nowhere (log in with username 'test' and pw 'test' if you wanna see inside). In terms of your actual site, the focus seems to be less on the content itself and more on sharing/commenting on things, almost trying to force people to interact with the site. Not a huge fan of the content on there…

Thank you very much for your comments :) A lot of people mention Buzzfeed like it's a bad thing, but I think it should be remembered that we're talking about one of the biggest sites in the world. But, as you say, there are plenty of sites where you can find that kind of content. We might target a niché more specifically from this point on, perhaps doing more gaming-related lists and focusing on that target audience.

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#107

I think HN is the wrong kind of audience to seek feedback from for your specific site. It appears to be pop-culture/teen culture focused, which you won't find here in HN.

To some extent, I agree with you. At the same time, there are a lot of smart people on here, who might be able to give solid advice anyway. And I've gotten lots of really good stuff already, we really have our work cut out for us now.

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#108

Oh man, not another "11 sexy girls with star wars tattoos"... Normally I would follow "if you don't have anything nice to say" but since you literally asked for it: Your site tries to build a better mousetrap in one of the worst corners of the internet (better means 'worse' in this case). "List sharing" is a known cheap trick for internet marketers who are the bottom of the barrel, exploitative of both original conte…

Clickhole also does sites like this gloriously.

http://www.clickhole.com/

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#109
post #30

I'll take a different tilt: Your biggest problem is that you have 4 people listed on your team page yet there are two with the title 'Project Manager'. From what I can tell from playing with the site, it just lets you build 'top 10' style lists and allows people to vote/comment on them. Frankly, this is a weekend project for a good developer or for a better outcome, a good developer/designer pair. What exactly are th…

There is a lot more work to a startup than just design. We have 4 content creators, we do SEO, marketing, customer support, product development, legal and economic issues, bug fixes, etc. If you think Listnerd is a "weekend project", then you're either inexperienced or simply don't see the full picture. Building something like good admin backend can take 1-3 months for a project alone.

Re: We put $200k into a site that sucks. Please destroy us with your criticism

#110
post #71

You seem to be resizing the footer in javascript (I haven't looked at the code so could be off base) and sometimes it seems to go a little crazy. When I first scrolled to the bottom there was a huge empty space below the "blog browse about... " stuff. About 800 pixels I would estimate. It seemed to go away when I refreshed and resized the page, but something caused it to happen at least one time, so under the same co…

Thank you for your input :) We'll look into that footer issue.
Post reply on HN